Do’s and Don’ts of Clean Architecture: A Guide for Scalable Software

Clean Architecture is a software design approach that helps create maintainable, scalable, and testable applications by enforcing separation of concerns and dependency inversion. While many developers are familiar with its principles, implementing it effectively requires careful consideration. Here’s a practical guide on what to do and what to avoid when applying Clean Architecture.

? Do’s of Clean Architecture

1. Follow the Dependency Rule

Ensure dependencies always flow inward, toward the core business logic. Infrastructure and frameworks should depend on application and domain layers, not the other way around.

2. Define Clear Boundaries Between Layers

Clearly separate the domain, application, and infrastructure layers. This keeps business logic independent and reduces coupling between components.

3. Use Interfaces to Decouple Implementations

Depend on abstractions instead of concrete implementations. This allows easy swapping of external services and frameworks without affecting core logic.

4. Write Unit Tests for Core Business Logic

Since the domain and application layers are framework-agnostic, they should be well-tested using unit tests without relying on external dependencies like databases or APIs.

5. Keep the Domain Layer Pure

The domain layer should be free of external dependencies, including database operations and third-party integrations. It should only contain business rules and domain models.

6. Use CQRS for Command and Query Separation

Implementing Command Query Responsibility Segregation (CQRS) can improve readability and maintainability by separating read and write concerns.

7. Embrace Dependency Injection

Use Dependency Injection (DI) to manage dependencies, making it easier to replace and test components independently.

8. Adopt a Modular Structure

Organize code into self-contained modules or bounded contexts to avoid monolithic structures that become difficult to maintain.

? Don’ts of Clean Architecture

1. Don’t Let Frameworks Dictate Your Architecture

Frameworks and external libraries should be implementation details, not foundational components. Avoid making your business logic depend on a specific framework.

2. Don’t Overcomplicate Simple Applications

Not every project requires a full-fledged Clean Architecture setup. For small applications, simpler architectures might be more practical.

3. Don’t Mix Concerns Across Layers

Avoid placing business logic in the infrastructure layer or database queries in the domain layer. Stick to the intended responsibilities of each layer.

4. Don’t Ignore Performance Considerations

Excessive layering and abstraction can impact performance. Be mindful of overheads introduced by dependency injection and excessive indirections.

5. Don’t Hardcode External Dependencies

Always abstract database access, messaging systems, and external APIs through interfaces to maintain flexibility and testability.

6. Don’t Forget About Documentation

Clean Architecture can introduce complexity. Ensure proper documentation and onboarding materials so new team members can understand the structure quickly.

7. Don’t Skip Code Reviews and Refactoring

Regularly review and refactor code to ensure Clean Architecture principles are upheld, preventing unnecessary complexity from creeping in.

8. Don’t Assume One Size Fits All

Clean Architecture is a guideline, not a rigid rulebook. Adapt it to suit your project's specific needs rather than forcing a predefined structure.

Conclusion

Applying Clean Architecture correctly helps create scalable, maintainable, and resilient applications. By following these do’s and avoiding common pitfalls, you can build software that stands the test of time.

What are your thoughts on Clean Architecture? Have you faced any challenges implementing it? Let’s discuss in the comments! ??

Check out my website for amazing products that enhance development! https://getautomator.com