Don’t Propose on the First Date (And Don’t Hard Sell Your Prospects!)
Marie Wiese
CEO @ Marketing Copilot | Microsoft MVP | Revenue Leader | Author | Speaker | Podcaster
Love, Sales, and the Art of Not Coming on Too Strong
Today is Valentines Day, so let’s talk about relationships — the romantic kind and the business kind.
Imagine this: You meet someone at a coffee shop. You hit it off. Conversation flows, they laugh at your jokes, and there’s a real connection. Then, as they take their last sip of coffee, you slide a diamond ring across the table and say, “Marry me?”
Creepy, right?
Yet, this is exactly how many businesses approach sales and marketing. They meet a prospect, get a whiff of interest, and immediately go in for the hard sell. They propose on the first date. And just like in romance, that never ends well.
?
The Problem With Rushing the Sale
We’ve all been on the receiving end of this kind of aggressive selling. Maybe you downloaded a white paper, watched a webinar, or clicked on an ad, and suddenly, you’re bombarded with emails and calls.
“Are you ready to buy?”
“What’s stopping you from making a decision today?”
“Let’s hop on a quick call!”
...Relax, buddy. We just met.
Sales is about timing. Just like dating, the goal is to nurture trust, build rapport, and offer something of value before asking for a commitment. Pushing too hard, too soon, only makes people want to run in the opposite direction.
?
The Three Types of Prospects (a.k.a. Relationship Stages)
Every prospect falls into one of these three categories:
The challenge? People move between these categories all the time. Your job is to nurture those in the middle and make it easy for them to slide into the “Ready to commit” category when the time is right.
?
How to Woo (and Win) Your Prospects
So, how do you build relationships that convert without scaring people off? Here’s your marketing and sales dating guide:
1. Be Interesting, Not Pushy
Nobody likes a date who talks only about themselves. The same goes for brands. Instead of constantly pitching your products, offer value. Share insights, solve problems, and give people a reason to keep engaging with you.
If all you do is sell, people will tune you out. But if you educate, entertain, or inspire, they’ll come back for more. The best relationships — business or personal — are built on genuine connections.
2. Know When to Make a Move
Great marketers watch for buying signals. If someone is consuming multiple pieces of content, visiting pricing pages, or engaging with emails, they might be ready for the next step. But don’t assume — give them a nudge, not a shove.
A well-placed email with a relevant case study or an invite to a webinar can go a long way. Think of it as the equivalent of asking, “Would you like to go out again?” rather than showing up at their house with a U-Haul.
3. Make It Easy to Say Yes
If you’re going to ask someone on a second date, you wouldn’t demand they sign a 10-year contract first. The same applies in business. Offer low-commitment ways to engage like free trials, webinars, or strategy calls before asking for the sale.
People don’t want to feel trapped. The easier you make it for them to take the next step without pressure, the more likely they’ll move forward.
4. Respect the ‘Not Right Now’
If a lead isn’t ready, that doesn’t mean it’s a no forever. Stay top of mind with relevant content and helpful touch-points, but don’t harass them. Otherwise, you’ll end up blocked faster than a bad date.
Instead of endless follow-ups, consider an email nurture sequence, a monthly newsletter, or periodic check-ins with valuable insights. You don’t need to be in their inbox every day, just enough so that when they are ready, you’re the first name they think of.
?
The Marketing Copilot Growth Formula: Your Relationship Guide to Sales Success
The best marketers and salespeople don’t chase. They attract. They nurture. They build trust over time.
If you’re ready to stop scaring off leads and start turning prospects into long-term customers, download our Marketing Copilot Growth Formula Guide. It’s your step-by-step blueprint for creating content that engages, nurtures, and converts (without coming on too strong).
Because in sales and in love, the right approach makes all the difference.
?
P.S. If this resonated with you, hit the subscribe button and stay tuned for next month’s Deep Thoughts — where we’ll tackle another sales and marketing truth that nobody wants to admit (but everyone needs to hear).
Until then, keep it cool. And don’t propose on the first date.
?
Mike Francis Insurance and Financial Services at Desjardins General Insurance Group
3 周Ok, have to chime in. When I was new to b2c sales (20 years ago), I was introduced to a sales program where they presented a “contract” at the beginning of the presentation. They suggested we have our “suspect” commit to “yes” or “no” and “let me think about it” was not acceptable. The whole premise made my skin crawl then as it would now. Onward.