Don't blame the judge!
Pilot Super block - Photo: author

Don't blame the judge!

Last week, a court in Barcelona rules that the city’s super block program is unlawful. The response was immediate. Many blamed ‘dirty games’, a battle between political parties and the incompetence of the judge to be responsible for the loss of the lovechild of many urbanists in the city and beyond. Doom scenarios were painted on the wall, arguing that Barcelona has been set back by 20 years.

Looking at the ruling reveals that most of this is overexaggerated or plain wrong. An association of local businesses had asked the court to verify if the way the program for the super blocks was set up was in accordance with planning legislation. They argued that their businesses were adversely affected by the downgrading of the street. The way this project was implemented was done not using the formal planning path – changing the city masterplans street type designation – but by securing the consent of the authority concerned with the city masterplan. This lawfulness of the latter was questioned by the court.

Photo: Author

Why did they not simply change the masterplan then? Because it is more complicated and time-consuming. It involves formal processes that also include consultation processes and was deemed impossible to do. For the very same reason, in recent years, the practice of bypassing formal masterplan changes by consent by the masterplanning authority have become common practice. I find this a problem. Not only do these workarounds undermine the authority of statutory planning processes, they also exclude the local population of getting involved. Whether justified or not, I can understand the concerns of the local businesses and while some businesses might profit from a pedestrianized street, others might suffer by a decrease in vehicular access.

In the spring of this year, I have been visiting the first pilot for the super block. Like many others, I was impressed like many others by the initiative and the boldness Barcelona was showing when embracing this systemic change in its block city structure. But when seeing the first results, my enthusiasm vanished. The newly pedestrianized intersection and the neighbouring streets had turned into a tourism theme park: junk food and knickknack all over the place. And at night it had turned into one big bar. Judging some comments by local residents reveal, that there are people that would not mind getting the street with traffic back. One of the reasons for the hustle and bustle might be that as a pilot project is simply is one of a kind, and it is fair to assume that people would be more distributed if more of the super blocks would be established. But change in use of the street remains and is something that deserves a broader debate – another reason not to bypass statutory consultation processes.

Barcelona is not the only city where pedestrianization initiatives have been halted by courts. Berlin’s Friedrichstrasse that the former government wanted to transform into a pedestrian zone saw a similar fate – interestingly, with the same parties and the same mistakes by the planning authorities involved.

What we can learn from that is that great ideas need solid processes for their implementation. As urban planners and designers, we should avoid prioritizing seeing our lovechild materialize over going through the – at times tiring – planning and approval processes. They ensure legal safety, where public involvement is statutory they involve the public, the business community, and they ensure a degree of permanence since any change will also require another mandated process. We should not blame judges, but we should praise them for reminding us that we should stick to our own standards.


This and many other articles can be found on THE DAILY URBAN DOSE

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Markus Appenzeller的更多文章

  • Today’s vision can be tomorrow's myopia

    Today’s vision can be tomorrow's myopia

    Eight years ago Saudi Arabia embarked on a highly ambitious process to profoundly change the country within a short 15…

    6 条评论
  • Why is German street scape so ugly? And what is different elsewhere.

    Why is German street scape so ugly? And what is different elsewhere.

    For two weeks, I have been hiking in Germany with my sons. For once, not being in a car or on a bike but solely…

    5 条评论
  • The Serpentine Pavilion 2024 - a 'Human Roundabout'

    The Serpentine Pavilion 2024 - a 'Human Roundabout'

    This week, I had the pleasure of attending the opening of this year’s serpentine pavilion by Korean Architect Minsuk…

    1 条评论
  • ‘The Line’ turned into ‘The Dash’

    ‘The Line’ turned into ‘The Dash’

    What that could mean to urbanism in Saudi Arabia Last week, news outlets reported about the cutting back of ‘the Line’,…

    5 条评论
  • The Bubble has a BIG hole - and now?

    The Bubble has a BIG hole - and now?

    Since more than twenty years i am regularly coming to China, and ever since I went there for the first time, there have…

    4 条评论
  • Shadow and Wind vs. the Space Station - future life in extremely hot climate

    Shadow and Wind vs. the Space Station - future life in extremely hot climate

    Four degrees are what scientists predict the temperature will rise in the Middle East by mid-century[i] - twice the…

    1 条评论
  • What Doxiadis got wrong in Riyadh

    What Doxiadis got wrong in Riyadh

    and how to fix it I have to make a disclaimer upfront: I am a great admirer of Constantinos Doxiadis, a Greek urban…

    24 条评论
  • The state of urban play in Saudi Arabia

    The state of urban play in Saudi Arabia

    This article and many more on current urban topics can be found on THE DAILY URBAN DOSE The world is part baffled, part…

    21 条评论
  • The Little Red Book

    The Little Red Book

    Rediscovering urban China after Covid Since more than 20 years, I have been travelling to China several times a year…

  • A small, flat piece of earth

    A small, flat piece of earth

    I am not a Dutch citizen, and therefore I am not allowed to vote in the Netherlands - unfortunately. I am also not…

    12 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了