Does Increasing Pay Cure Career Burnout?
Jen Johnson, PhD
I help organizations reduce #burnout so they can increase employee retention and work satisfaction.
I recently saw a LinkedIn post discussing how important pay is when it comes to on-the-job happiness. The post purported that increasing pay would eliminate burnout. While I agree that pay could be a driver of burnout in your organization, it’s not the sole determining factor in terms of burnout prevention or mitigation.
Make no mistake: pay is definitely a strong variable that can drive burnout. When we’re paid a living or thriving wage, we feel appreciated and can maintain a quality of life that reduces a lot of stress. However, I work with successful executives who are burned out — all while being paid exceedingly well.
If pay was the only variable to be considered when examining how satisfied we are and the state of our well-being at work, these executives would be in the clear with regard to burnout. The fact that they aren’t reflects there is more going on than just pay - and that’s what research tells us as well.
We already understand things like PTO, pay, work location, hours, and flexibility can impact how one feels about the work they do and the company with which they do it. But these are not the only factors that impact organizational or personal burnout.
Initially, I wondered if the right questions were being asked in this particular work survey that they referenced. But what I realized is it’s not the actual questions that are the issue in this particular case — it’s how results are broadly being interpreted. We can’t jump to conclusions that say pay resolves burnout when the questions are not intended to measure burnout.
We need to acknowledge something: burnout and happiness are not opposites. You can be unhappy, but not burned out. They are two different human experiences that should be addressed independently. It’s tempting (and seems like a good move) to rally support around increased pay based on the data from this particular survey because it does need to happen in many industries. I’m not negating that.
"We need to acknowledge something: burnout and happiness are not opposites. You can be unhappy, but not burned out."
But I think it’s self-defeating to interpret data to say something it isn’t actually saying. If we interpret data about happiness to mean “not burned out,” it gives us a scapegoat for addressing the issues that are equally, or even more so, responsible for burnout in our organizations and personal lives. It gives companies license to not address other very important issues because they’ll say “the large survey at X business showed pay is of primary importance.” It IS important, but it’s not the whole picture.
One of the first conversations we have when a company hires me is something to the effect of, “This is good data AND you aren’t asking the right questions if your goal is to mitigate burnout.” That’s because we have to be careful with how we interpret data.?
领英推荐
"This is good data AND you aren't asking the right questions if your goal is to mitigate burnout."
For example, I prepared a proposal for an organization that had data that reported that 97% of employees were stressed at work. In my head I thought, “Everyone is stressed at work! The President of the United States is stressed. The guy that pumps my gas in New Jersey is stressed. My barista is stressed. The guy who takes tickets at the Frisco Roughriders game is stressed. I’m stressed!”
What I said was “That is interesting data, AND it’s not helpful data. Eliminating stress completely is not possible or helpful because healthy stress has a purpose. Let’s start by gathering data that is going to tell us specific drivers of burnout and stress in your company - drivers that could be mitigated or eliminated.”?
You could work in the most healthy workplace on the planet and still feel stress because stress is a normal experience. It’s what causes stress and whether we are equipped, or have the power, to address the problem that triggers the stress that impacts us.?
In order to navigate organizational burnout, we need to dig deep to uncover multiple drivers — and those will look different for every organization.
Dialing in and determining the key drivers of burnout for you and your teams is the first step toward formulating a plan. From there, we can build a custom strategic plan that can be implemented within your organization.
Now, I’d love your feedback. What drivers of burnout are you seeing in your organization that may not be represented in the data you’ve already gathered? DM me! Once we can hone in on that, we can work together to find your resolution.
For more thoughts and strategies related to organizational burnout, subscribe to this LinkedIn newsletter, connect with me, and click that bell so you don’t miss a thing!
If you’re interested in talking with me face to face (virtually), book an initial connection call. I want to get to know you as a human and as a professional.
Let’s figure out how I can guide your organization towards long term health to protect the outcomes you care about, while also supporting the people who make those outcomes possible.
#burnout #organizationalburnout #HR #humanresources #worksatisfaction #employeeretention #stress #research #learninganddevelopment #burnoutinbusiness #corporate burnout
?? Want explosive growth with AI & Analytics? ?? | Digital Transformation expert ??? | Empowering growth & impact for biz & Nonprofits ?? | Led $15B FP&A ?? | 56 patent pending inventions in AI & BI ?? 20M+ Impressions
1 年Hey Jen Johnson, PhD, it's always fascinating how some studies suggest throwing money at a problem like burnout can fix it. I guess if we could pay our bills in "wellness dollars," that might work! ?? On a serious note, while a raise can certainly ease some stress, true burnout often needs more than just a paycheck boost. It's like trying to put out a wildfire with a water pistol. We need a whole toolkit of strategies, from self-care to a supportive work environment. So, cheers to your bi-weekly newsletter, where we can navigate the burnout maze together! Let's keep exploring the real solutions beyond the paycheck.
? I had another thought come to mind, Jen, When I saw your comment on my post this morning, I wanted to check if you had posted, and when I saw this post it came back to my mind! Sometimes increasing pay can actually have the effect of accelerating burnout, and that's almost always the case when someone does not like their job, and even more so in a toxic situation. Picture this: your supervisor(s) is challenging to deal with and is often unreasonable. You feel unfulfilled in your role and dread going to work, but every year they keep giving you significant compensation increases. You feel a greater sense of obligation as a result, and perhaps an increasing feeling of obligation. But the harder you work, the less you feel appreciated, and that may even bring about guilt. As I directly work with dozens of different companies of all different sizes, I've seen this play out several times. I've also seen organizations decimated by it. I've found that compensation is crucial to attracting talent, and while the right and smart thing to do is to maintain at least a competitive comp structure for existing employees, there are many other factors that take precedence. Sorry for the post-on-post crime... ?? ?? ??
Middle Eastern Business and Culture Specialist | Senior Strategic Adviser | Board Member | Keynote Speaker
1 年Burnout can definitely not be cured with money. There are lots of other things that will make a difference.
Helping Big Dreaming High Achievers Turn Avoidance Into Acceleration | Accountability Without Angst | LinkedIn Top Voice | Goal Getters Club | DIY Influence Mindset Mentor
1 年Increasing pay is certainly nice, but after the new level becomes your norm, you're right back to the burned out feelings again. And if more pay was the answer, we wouldn't have burned out C-Suiters out there, right? Great question, Jen!
? This can be compared to being fatigued from too much exercise and not having enough recovery time, Jen. No matter how good of a physical condition someone is in, if they exert themselves too much, breakdown and injury are the inevitable results. Our minds need time to heal and recover as well. Sleep plays a crucial role in this, as does nutrition and exercise for that matter. And if we don't give our minds that time and make those allowances, mental fatigue and injury will occur, and diminish our efficacy in the process. Great article, my friend!