Do we have a new manager crisis coming?
Dacia Faison-Roe
Interim Chief Human Resources/People/Talent Officer | Consultant ? Advisor ? Coach
In the past few weeks, I've talked to a number of clients who said "oh hell no" to the idea of making the leap into management. And these were folks who had that leadership mojo, that EQ, that empathy, and even the desire to develop others. And still, they were not interested in a formal role doing it.
So got me thinking; why are folks dodging management roles like it's a career ending decision?
My take? The traditional appeal of climbing the corporate ladder to secure a management position is losing its luster for many professionals. They're spotting the signs that being a manager isn't a cakewalk—it looks more like a marathon with hurdles. And here's the twist: a lot of those hurdles are because the leaders at the top, who are choosing the next generation of managers, often ascended based on their technical skills, not their leadership chops. It's like a game of musical chairs where no one taught the players how to dance.
领英推荐
Now, these new managers aren't just expected to lead; they're also expected to carry on with their previous job responsibilities. That's not just unfair, it's unworkable. It's akin to asking someone to paint a masterpiece while also baking a soufflé—both tasks demanding full attention, but when juggled together, likely to end in a mess.
We need to stop the cycle of untrained leaders perpetuating more of the same. It's about time we clear the decks for new managers, giving them the real opportunity to lead, free from the shackles of their former roles. Proper training, support, and space to practice leadership should be the norm, not the exception.
So, let's take a fresh approach. Let's mentor potential leaders early on, give them room to learn and grow, and when they're ready to take on a management role, let's allow them to dedicate themselves fully to it. By doing this, we can build a robust, supportive management culture that's not just about maintaining the status quo, but about fostering genuine growth and success for everyone involved.
Vice President Sales & Marketing at Arrow Home Products
1 年As experienced managers retire most companies don’t have a succession plan in place. It’s a daunting scenario to take on a management role replacing someone who has been doing it well for so long. I totally get the reluctantace and organizations need to do better building their employees up so they are eager to leap into management
Reimagining how we teach and learn | Nurturing the things that make us human | Conscious Communication Creator and Speaker | Public Speaking Expert | Travel Educator | Award-winning Lecturer | Advocate for Rest
1 年Excellent questions and observations, Dacia. Thank you for sharing your experience and expertise with us. Something that I talk with my students about in the classroom is the idea that perhaps we also need to be teaching followership. In other words, what types of behaviors and skills tend to be the most effective in supporting leaders? Effective followership seems to be an essential foundation for a successful leader. Mid-level managers can get squeezed between a lack of support from top leadership and a lack of support from those that work for them. Our USA culture seems to glamorize leadership roles. Perhaps this is connected to our value of individualism. In addition to being able to lead, perhaps we should be asking if people also know how to follow/support? What are your thoughts about followership in relation to this potential new manager crisis you’ve observed?
Internal Communication Director and Strategist | Business and Sustainability Comms | Mentor | Do Radio | Cohost Navigating Disruption pod | Ex Apple | 20 yrs Listed Company Experience (18 in house)
1 年and mentor some already in role who still believe they need to control everything... there's a lot of that around still sadly.