Discipline or Motivation?

Discipline or Motivation?

I recently heard one of those special-forces-turned-motivational-humans say something about getting over the idea of everything being done because of motivation and just doing things because you are disciplined.

I think it's a fascinating idea because for years, probably decades, I've heard a ton about motivation. Motivating others, motivating your team, motivating your colleagues, motivating yourself.

There was a lot of talk about motivation vs. being lazy, and how most people who were perceived as lazy weren't lazy, they just weren't motivated.

This idea of replacing motivation with discipline has had me thinking for the last few weeks.

Actually, since I did my Pluralsight course titled Prioritizing Tasks and Managing Time for Greater Productivity , I've thought about this stuff. But most recently I've been thinking about the "why" of productivity.

I've come down to this, at least for me: what I do, the progress I make, the tasks I work on, will sometimes be driven by motivation and sometimes by discipline.

In 2006, when I got laid off (and started My Big Fat Failed Job Search), I found that as a job seeker I was motivated to get out of that status, but the job search tasks were so dreary that they required a lot of discipline.

When I started JibberJobber, this web business that I was going to sell for a gazillion dollars one day, I was driven by motivation. I didn't need any discipline... I was so anxious to get stuff done I never had to tap into discipline.

I'm at a different stage of my life now, though. I'm not in startup, scrappy, what's-the-future going-to-be mode. I've built processes and systems and programs that are humming along. My finances are much better than when I was unemployed. I'm older and have *some* of the maturity and wisdom that comes with age.

Where I was once motivated by changing the world, I'm now more motivated by figuring out my physical and mental health, and enjoying the fleeting moments I get with my growing kids. I won't get any of that (health or precious family time) back, even if I do get a gazillion dollars down the road.

My motivation is to enjoy the present and build health so I can enjoy more of the future even as I age.

Sometimes that gets in the way of the mundane work tasks I have. My motivation for some of those mundane tasks has waned, which is where discipline kicks in. There are plenty of things I don't want to do during the day, but they need to get done. I especially want to get them done before they go from not important to urgent... I don't like living in Quadrant I.

And so here I am. I need to have a meeting with myself and figure out what my motivations are. I have had a big "why," and that's great, but it might be shifting... maybe that's why my motivation has been feeling empty.

Discipline is great. It's necessary because not everything that has to get done will be driven by motivation. Sometimes you have to do hard, boring things. But when you do things because you feel motivated, that's on another level. That's the level I want to get on.

What do you think about motivation and discipline? More importantly, how are you doing with your motivation? Do you need a reevaluation and readjustment? If so, that's okay.

We have different seasons and circumstances in life and when those change, we need to make changes.

Sachin Deshpande

Founder @ Qualitas IT | Outsourced Product Development | HR Domain Specialists | Analytics | SAAS architecture expertise

2 年

Truly an insightful post!. I would like to add here another quality/emotion which is?"a sense of responsibility or duty". Many a times you also do things just out of a sense of responsibility or duty like towards your family, friends, profession, society, nature and so on.

回复
Paul A. Phillips, MBA ?

Tech & Operations Visionary | Advancing Tech & Ops | Delivering Financial & Operational Impact

2 年

Jason Alba, this is right on target! I think it speaks to the bigger issue of how we sometimes grab on to a principle or theme (motivation, in this case) and we apply it where it doesn't always belong (areas that should be covered under "discipline"). I am sure that I have excused my own inaction, attributing it to lack of motivation - but truly, I wasn't disciplined enough. Thank you for this article!

回复
Robbie Sewell, MHS, ACRW, ACCS

Career Storyteller ? Resume & Profile Writer ? Brand Strategist ? Former Recruiter ? Specializing in Healthcare Leadership ? Request a 30-Minute, Complimentary Discovery Call: [email protected]

2 年

Two things here really resonate with me. First is building health (rather than wealth, I presume). I love being a gym rat, watching my strength and balance grow more certain every day. I carve out time every morning for a 1.5-hour workout. Then there's the recognition of the seasonality of our lives. Changing to accommodate the season is DIFFICULT but inevitable. It was good to read I'm not alone in feeling about this.

darcy bevelacqua

I help Marketing & Sales Executives over 50 persue fulfilling careers /jobs??Resume writer ??LinkedIn updates ??Interview Coaching ?? Networking ??Salary Negotiations ??Personal Branding ??Networking ??Storytelling

2 年

I think we need both motivation and discipline. There are days we are motivated and days we just do things because we know they need to get done. Everyone has to balance their time -with their priorities.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jason Alba的更多文章

  • Career Pivots

    Career Pivots

    When I was young I had my whole career planned out. I didn't expect any deviation from the plan.

    1 条评论
  • ChatGPT and the Job Search? I Guess So!

    ChatGPT and the Job Search? I Guess So!

    I'm going to point you to a blog post I just wrote, but before that you should know that I'm not suggesting that…

    4 条评论
  • The Path to Success: Getting Help

    The Path to Success: Getting Help

    Years ago I heard the most successful companies were those with two cofounders. I bypassed that advice and started…

    2 条评论
  • Absolutely Discredit Yourself

    Absolutely Discredit Yourself

    I have two stories to share this morning. First, I was a new programmer working as an intern at Simplot, which is one…

    7 条评论
  • How You Can Protect Culture

    How You Can Protect Culture

    Over at the Snowfly blog I write a lot about organizational culture, mostly to managers, leaders, owners, etc. A recent…

    1 条评论
  • I Hurt My Elbow

    I Hurt My Elbow

    Firstly, do not worry about me or my elbow. I have not started a gofundme and if you saw me you would have no idea my…

    2 条评论
  • What About a Personal Recession?

    What About a Personal Recession?

    I lost my job in 2006. You know what was happening in '06? Nothing bad! The economy was great.

  • What's the Best Career Advice You've Heard?

    What's the Best Career Advice You've Heard?

    I love learning from others. I love sharing what I learn.

    4 条评论
  • Your Circle of Influence

    Your Circle of Influence

    What I can't control: The FAA shutting down airlines on 1/11/2023 because their infrastructure broke. Southwest…

    3 条评论
  • 5 Important Things to do In the Job Search When Everyone Is on Vacation

    5 Important Things to do In the Job Search When Everyone Is on Vacation

    As a job seeker, I hated hearing that you can't job search during the holiday months. Supposedly, everyone is on…

    3 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了