Differences, Similarities, and Complementary Roles of DNP and PhD in Nursing

Differences, Similarities, and Complementary Roles of DNP and PhD in Nursing

Nursing has evolved into a highly specialized profession, with advanced degrees available to support the development of nursing leaders in practice, research, and education. Two prominent doctoral degrees in nursing are the Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) and the Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in nursing. Both degrees prepare nurses for leadership roles, but their focus, outcomes, and contributions to the profession differ. Understanding the distinctions and complementary nature of these degrees is crucial for individuals deciding on the right path and for healthcare systems seeking the right balance of expertise.

The Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) and the Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in Nursing represent the pinnacle of educational attainment in nursing, yet they serve different, albeit complementary, roles in advancing the profession. The need for DNP-prepared and PhD-prepared nurses has grown as the healthcare landscape becomes more complex. This article explores the key differences, and similarities, and how the two doctoral pathways complement each other in transforming nursing practice, education, and research.

Differences between DNP and PhD

Purpose and Focus

The DNP and PhD differ fundamentally in their purpose. The DNP is a practice-focused doctorate designed to prepare nurses for leadership in clinical practice, healthcare systems, and implementation of evidence-based care. It emphasizes translating research into practice, improving patient outcomes, and leading healthcare innovations at the bedside and organizational levels. On the other hand, the PhD is a research-focused doctorate aimed at preparing nurses to conduct original research, generate new knowledge, and contribute to the theoretical foundations of nursing science.

DNP graduates often assume roles such as advanced practice nurses (APNs), clinical leaders, healthcare executives, and policy advocates. Their work focuses on improving healthcare quality and patient outcomes by applying research to clinical settings. In contrast, PhD graduates typically pursue careers in academia, research institutions, or leadership roles where they focus on designing, conducting, and disseminating research to inform practice, policy, and education.

Curriculum and Training

The DNP curriculum centers on advanced clinical skills, systems leadership, and quality improvement methodologies. Students are trained in areas such as healthcare informatics, population health, evidence-based practice, and health policy. A hallmark of the DNP program is the DNP project, which involves implementing and evaluating an evidence-based practice change or quality improvement initiative in a clinical or organizational setting.

In contrast, PhD programs emphasize research methodology, theoretical development, and statistical analysis. PhD students receive in-depth training in qualitative and quantitative research methods, often focusing on generating new knowledge or theories that can later be translated into practice. The culmination of a PhD program is the dissertation, a comprehensive research study that contributes original knowledge to the field.

End Goals

• The end goal for a DNP-prepared nurse is often to assume roles in clinical leadership, such as becoming a chief nursing officer, nurse executive, or clinical educator. They may also serve as advanced practice nurses who implement evidence-based interventions to improve patient care.
• The end goal for a PhD-prepared nurse is to contribute to the advancement of nursing science through research. They often take on roles as professors, researchers, or policy advisors, focusing on generating new knowledge to address healthcare challenges.

Career Outcomes and Contributions

DNP graduates are clinical experts and leaders in healthcare improvement. They are well-positioned to lead multidisciplinary teams, shape healthcare policy, and drive evidence-based practice at the system level. For example, DNP-prepared nurses may design and implement protocols to reduce hospital readmissions or lead efforts to integrate genomic science into clinical practice.

PhD graduates contribute primarily through their research. They are essential for developing the evidence base that informs clinical practice, policy decisions, and educational curricula. PhD-prepared nurses may lead research initiatives on topics ranging from health disparities to the molecular mechanisms of disease, contributing to nursing science and public health.

Similarities between DNP and PhD

Despite their distinct focuses, both the DNP and PhD share several important similarities:

1. Terminal Degrees: Both the DNP and PhD are the highest level of educational attainment in nursing. Graduates of both programs are recognized as experts in their fields, although their expertise is applied in different domains—practice for DNPs and research for PhDs.
2. Evidence-Based Foundation: Both degrees emphasize the importance of evidence-based practice, although DNP programs focus on applying evidence to improve clinical care, while PhD programs focus on generating the evidence that informs that care.
3. Leadership and Advocacy: Graduates from both pathways are prepared for leadership roles. DNPs lead clinical teams and healthcare systems, whereas PhDs often lead research teams, academic programs, and policy initiatives.
4. Contribution to the Nursing Profession: Both degrees contribute to the advancement of nursing as a profession. DNPs contribute by implementing research findings into practice, while PhDs generate the research that underpins best practices in nursing.

Complementary Roles of DNP and PhD

The roles of DNP- and PhD-prepared nurses are complementary, and the collaboration between the two is critical to the future of nursing and healthcare. The DNP focuses on applying research to improve patient care and system outcomes, while the PhD generates new knowledge that informs clinical practice and policy. Together, they create a cycle of knowledge generation and application that advances the field of nursing.

For instance, a PhD-prepared nurse researcher may conduct a study on improving patient outcomes in heart failure, identifying new interventions. A DNP-prepared nurse leader could then implement these findings in clinical practice, evaluate their impact, and refine protocols based on real-world outcomes. This synergy between research and practice ensures that healthcare evolves in response to the latest scientific discoveries and patient needs.

Additionally, the collaboration between DNP and PhD-prepared nurses can lead to policy advocacy that bridges the gap between research and practice. While PhD-prepared nurses may produce evidence supporting healthcare reforms, with their clinical expertise, DNP-prepared nurses can champion the implementation of these reforms in healthcare systems.

• From Research to Practice PhD-prepared nurses generate new knowledge and evidence through research, while DNP-prepared nurses translate this evidence into clinical practice. The PhD nurse may study the effectiveness of a new intervention for managing chronic illness, and the DNP nurse would implement this intervention in clinical settings, evaluate outcomes, and make recommendations for improvements. This collaboration between research and practice enhances the overall quality of care in the healthcare system.
• Healthcare Leadership DNP nurses often lead quality improvement initiatives, develop healthcare policy, and implement system-wide changes. PhD nurses, in turn, contribute by conducting research that informs these policies and initiatives. For example, a PhD nurse may study the impact of nurse staffing on patient outcomes, while a DNP nurse might lead efforts to change staffing models based on this research.
• Education and Mentorship Both DNP and PhD nurses contribute to the education of future nurses. PhD-prepared nurses often serve as faculty in research-intensive universities, teaching and mentoring students in research methods and theory. DNP-prepared nurses, meanwhile, may teach in clinical programs, mentoring nurse practitioners and clinical leaders. Together, they ensure that the next generation of nurses is well-prepared for both practice and research.

Conclusion

The DNP and PhD in nursing are distinct but equally important degrees that contribute to the profession in unique ways. The DNP emphasizes clinical practice and leadership, focusing on the application of research to improve patient outcomes. The PhD focuses on generating new knowledge through research that informs practice, policy, and education. Both degrees are necessary to advance the profession of nursing and to meet the growing complexity of healthcare. Together, they form a powerful partnership in addressing today’s healthcare challenges, advancing patient care, and shaping the future of nursing.

References

• American Association of Colleges of Nursing. (2006). The Essentials of Doctoral Education for Advanced Nursing Practice. Retrieved from https://www.aacnnursing.org
• American Association of Colleges of Nursing. (2020). PhD in Nursing Pathway to Excellence. Retrieved from https://www.aacnnursing.org

• American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN). (2022). The Essentials: Core Competencies for Professional Nursing Education. Retrieved from https://www.aacnnursing.org
• Brown, M. A., & Crabtree, E. K. (2019). DNP and PhD nursing programs: A comparison of career outcomes. Journal of Nursing Education, 58(4), 212-219. https://doi.org/10.3928/01484834-20190321-03
• DeNisco, S. M., & Barker, A. M. (2015). Advanced Practice Nursing: Evolving Roles for the Transformation of the Profession. Jones & Bartlett Learning.
• Dreher, H. M., & Glasgow, M. E. (2011). Role Development for Doctoral Advanced Nursing Practice. Springer Publishing Company.
• Dreher, H. M., & Glasgow, M. E. (2017). Role of the Doctor of Nursing Practice in Nursing Education and Leadership. Nursing Administration Quarterly, 41(1), 29-36. https://doi.org/10.1097/NAQ.0000000000000192
• Melnyk, B. M. (2018). DNPs and PhDs: Complementary, not competitive. American Journal of Nursing, 118(7), 9. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NAJ.0000541436.76201.e3
• Zaccagnini, M. E., & Pechacek, J. M. (2021). The Doctor of Nursing Practice Essentials: A New Model for Advanced Practice Nursing (4th ed.). Jones & Bartlett Learning.

?