Is DEI Really that Radical?

Is DEI Really that Radical?

DEI work is under attack, most clearly in the USA, with critics getting louder and louder following Trump's re-election. Mark Zuckerberg has had Meta roll back DEI initiatives, and called for more"masculine energy" in the business world, whatever that is. Amazon and others too are pulling out of DEI work, removing policies from its website that state their allyship with Black employees. The Ford Motor Company has also announced they are ending their DEI programmes.

Meta has deliberately removed all sanitary products from men's bathrooms, this is something that is being done to target trans men, there is no other reason for it. Why are trans people so scary to some?

Vice President Kamala Harris was criticised by Republicans as being "just a DEI hire", a sneering insult they also used against some of the leadership of the LA firefighters. Using DEI as a pretext to attack people involved in defending LA from wildfires is pretty low.

Right wing groups started a campaign to get Costco to stop its work in this area too, directly going for Board members. But Costco resisted, and said they stood by their DEI work for good business reasons. And if you have worked in this field, you know the business case for DEI work is strong.

This move is coming from the far right of politics, a far right that is now in power in a number of countries. This should concern us, both as DEI practioners and as human beings.

Even here in Aotearoa New Zealand last year ACT leader David Seymour criticised the Treasury for advertising for a D&I manager, saying it was not their core business. With his lack of experience in the workforce let alone in central banking it's hard to know what basis he makes his argument on.

DEI is actually good for capitalism, that's thing I find so bizarre. We know from data that organisations with great inclusive cultures retain staff better, attract high quality people, and happy staff are more productive.

So why does these Far Right parties seem to fear us so much?

We do aim for change, that's true, trying to make sure that those who have intentionally or otherwise been left out of the tent get to come inside. This threatens people who are used to being in power, and only seeing people like themselves in power. They think this is normal and natural, and find the change unsettling. They are so worried about losing out, they don't see the advantages coming their way from a richer and more diverse world.

There is also something nasty and bullying about these reactions. And bullies need to be opposed whenever they show themselves.

Hemingway wrote "Fascism is a lie told by bullies". Working in this field means we need to stand for the truth, and stand up to the bullies who are making themselves known. #DEI #Diversity #Inclusion



Fiona M. Hewitt

I provide tailored, affordable recruitment services to SMEs, Startups and Not for Profit Organisations.

1 个月

Great post Michael. Just like 'woke', DEI seems to have been co-opted by a certain fringe element who have run out of ways to express their inability to comprehend that society represents a broader demographic than them. It's a mix of fear of the (deliberate) unknown and refusal to learn.

Erin Rapley

Consultant @ Kerridge & Partners

1 个月

What a weird weird time. Great article Michael, thank you!

Candice Collier

Managing Director | Enabling teams to collaborate for impact

1 个月

Well said Michael. It’s been an interesting read across multiple media about the recent pullback on DEI initiatives. While reasons may resonate with certain groups, many who actually know the value in investing in the human side of business, highlight that DEI is not just about social justice—it is a driver of innovation, better collaboration and therefore success Retrenching from these efforts sends a message that inclusion is expendable, which can erode trust from the very people these companies rely upon - customers, employees and stakeholders. The challenge lies in reframing the narrative to demonstrate the tangible benefits and keeping the conversation productive. So much more to do Michael - the world needs your voice ??

Cheuk Ho Yin (Yee-On)

DEI advocate | Project Management Professional (PMP)? | Social Innovation | Facilitator | Life Coach

1 个月

When I first heard about DEI rollback I found it weird too, as DEI is good for businesses. I used to think that everyone will be supportive to anything that brings more money. Now you mentioned a good point: "people in power are afraid of losing out." Apparently the power of fear is greater than the power of money...

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Michael Stevens的更多文章

  • Box-Ticking or Quality Improvement?

    Box-Ticking or Quality Improvement?

    DEI programmes where organisation are given lists of goals to meet are common, but I have often heard that compliance…

  • How Dangerous are DEI Programs?

    How Dangerous are DEI Programs?

    There have been more and more pot-shots fired at the concept of DEI over the last months. From Donald Trump calling…

    5 条评论
  • D,E, & I - Putting Words Into Action

    D,E, & I - Putting Words Into Action

    There is a a lot of talk about Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (D,E, & I), but how much action is there? How can you…

    18 条评论
  • Inhuman Resources

    Inhuman Resources

    In the last few weeks I've had two good friends who have applied for skilled managerial roles, both been given a…

    2 条评论
  • How Do We Change Culture?

    How Do We Change Culture?

    The recent revelations about the war crimes committed by the Australian military's elite SAS force are shocking and…

  • Diversity & Inclusion: Not Just a Paper Tiger

    Diversity & Inclusion: Not Just a Paper Tiger

    The recent reporting that the US State Department has suspended all Diversity and Inclusion work, due to opposition…

    4 条评论
  • Now More Than Ever...

    Now More Than Ever...

    As so many organisations are shedding staff and cutting back, it might seem that a focus on creating inclusive and…

    1 条评论
  • The Benefits of being a Values-Driven Organisation

    The Benefits of being a Values-Driven Organisation

    I remember the first time I saw a corporate values statement. It was in the early 90s, and I was living in Istanbul; I…

    6 条评论
  • Change and Resistance

    Change and Resistance

    You can never guarantee perfection, but we think you can be pretty sure of improvement. I have been thinking about this…

    5 条评论
  • The Rainbow Tick is Growing !

    The Rainbow Tick is Growing !

    You might have noticed over the last few weeks we've added a few new members to the network. We've been able to certify…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了