DEI - Didn't Earn It
Joshua Jones
Director of Content Marketing & Development @ ERE | Connecting Talent Leaders & Driving Innovation in Recruiting
I’ve titled this “Didn’t Earn It” because lately it’s a phrase I'm seeing/hearing thrown around by people who seem to have peaked in high school—those born on third base but convinced they hit a triple, the mantra of those already RSVPing for the Spring 2025 DEI Deflection Summit happening at a conference center near you. It’s often wielded by those oblivious to their own unearned advantages, dismissing those who’ve had to overcome systemic barriers—as if hard work alone guarantees a level playing field. Spoiler: It doesn’t.
I’ve been thinking a lot about DEI lately, because in today’s political climate, I’m once again seeing people feel empowered to exclude, to gatekeep, to discriminate, and to dehumanize.
This reflection has taken me down memory lane, thinking about my career—one that has been anything but conventional.
I got my first job at 14 by lying about my age. By 15, I was steadily working part-time because if I wanted things—CDs, clothes, even haircuts—I had to figure it out myself. Meanwhile, I was surrounded by people who seemed to have it all handed to them: new cars at 16, country club memberships, parental bailouts into their 20s and 30s, and so on.
I earned my college degree at 26, a journey delayed because I became a father at 20 and had to work full-time to support myself and my family. I vividly remember one of my first interviews as a recent grad.
The interviewer asked me if I could juggle—literally. I was handed three baseballs and told to perform. After that they sized me up by asking, “What kind of car do you drive?”
In that moment, it felt like I wasn’t being taken seriously. “I drive a Trans Am,” I said. When asked why I answered defiantly: “Because it’s f’ckin badass.”
Somehow, I got the job. But I often wonder—what would have happened if I’d driven my very first car to that interview? That beat-up, primer grey 1988 Toyota Corolla that I struggled to keep running.
What if I hadn’t been able to afford a haircut? Or if my teeth hadn’t been perfect because dental care was a luxury I couldn’t afford?
A week into my first real recruiting job our team was told we’d soon be taking a company photo. Men would be required to wear suits and jewel-colored ties. I didn’t own a suit, let alone a jewel-colored tie. Panic set in, but my mom saved me. She took me shopping so I could fit into a workplace that often felt like it wasn’t made for me.
I’d drive my Arctic White 1998 Trans Am with its loud aftermarket exhaust into a garage filled with BMWs and Audis. The roar of its V8 motor would set off car alarms on those luxury vehicles. My car didn’t have any type of theft prevention, but it was fast, and it was mine, and I’d earned it fair and square.
Still, I felt like an outsider. An imposter.
But here’s the thing about imposter syndrome: it isn’t always internal. It’s often systemic. It’s not just a feeling; it’s a reflection of inequities—a constant reminder that the playing field isn’t level.
I’ve earned nearly every single thing I have. Many people haven’t had to.
And that’s the real kicker about “DEI.” It isn’t always about race, or gender, or sexual orientation. Often, it’s just as much about socioeconomic circumstances. If you went to the dentist every six months as a kid, if you were able to participate in band or sports, or other extracurricular activities, if you attended summer camp, or went skiing every winter, if you never had to worry about money for gas, car insurance, or a haircut—then you probably started from a point far ahead of many people around you.
My last name is Jones. My mother’s side of the family is from Mexico. Growing up, I never felt like I belonged. I felt like the white side of my family thought I was some weird brown kid, but also felt that the Mexican side thought I was a goofy white boy.
I’ve been called “Coconut” more times than I can count. I’ve often felt “white-passing,” but every now and then, I’m reminded that I’m not.
Like recently, when I was in a car with industry friends, and we took a wrong turn into a sketchy area. Jokes were made about the potential safety risks of stopping at some of the establishments we passed, and someone remarked, “Josh, you’re brown enough—you’d probably be okay.”
I laughed. I wasn’t offended. In fact, I felt seen. But there it was again—that reminder:?You’re not like us, are you?
So, if you’ve ever felt like you didn’t belong—like you had to fight twice as hard to be taken half as seriously—I see you.
And I’ll keep fighting to make sure someone like you?does?belong.
?
Talent Acquisition | Career Coach | Content Creator
3 个月I’m delayed in commenting on this beautiful piece. I wanted to give this article the praise it deserves. As a DEI professional that’s not currently practicing DEI, I’ve yearned for someone, anyone, to socialize the REAL current state of DEI and what many of us feel. I see a lot of masking and hiding but not the REAL! This is the best article I have read on LinkedIn all year. I haven’t seen this level of genuine sentiment, candor and humanity! I wanted to share a few of my favorite quotes from the article in my comment but I quickly realized that I would be quoting the entire article. I love that you called out the hypocritical DEI detractors, who are entitled and have been handed most of what they have. It’s disingenuous for detractors to tell the marginalized people who didn’t start on 3rd base to pull themselves up by the bootstraps when they’ve been given at every turn. The entitled love to say, “all you need to do is work hard” and are completely unbothered by the systemic barriers that exist for others. I love this article! I will share it and re-read it! This is storytelling at its finest! Thank you for your candor and courage!
Driving growth: Go-to-marketing leader that integrates Product Marketing, Demand Generation, Strategic Communications, and Sales Enablement into strategy
3 个月Wow Josh, brilliantly written. Thank you for sharing. No one knows anyone’s story. Just because someone looks a certain way, doesn’t mean anything. We all judge books by their covers. Maybe it’s time to read the book!
Marketing Technologist
3 个月I too had a 1998 Trans Am with a 6-speed. It was the fastest car I have ever owned. DEI is so weird. I will never be able to confirm but I have been passed over many times for being a regular white guy with below a masters degree. No matter what the story, we are blessed to be where we are and have been placed with meaning in this position. We bring a different past than anyone else and what we can do is the most unique gift from experience in the universe.
Career Advisor / Sourcing Technical Recruiter
3 个月Whatever happened to being judged on the content of one's character rather than by the color of their skin? Do we really believe we can fight racism with more racism? And if I might make a simple mistake at work, will my colleagues secretly think it's because I was a DEI hire and didn't land the position on my own merit?