Decoding CBDCs: Opportunities and Challenges

In the dynamic realm of digital finance, Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) have gained unprecedented attention from monetary authorities and financial communities during recent years. At Var Meta, we're always eager to dive into new tech trends, especially when they promise to change how we think about money.

Today, we delve into CBDCs, offering a comprehensive analysis of their worldwide deployment, benefits, and challenges from a business perspective. Whether you're a tech enthusiast or just curious, we hope you can gain a clearer picture of CBDCs from this article.

What is a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC)?

Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) is the digital form of a country's fiat currency, issued and regulated by its central bank. CBDCs operate on a digital ledger that can be a blockchain or not, allowing peer-to-peer transactions to be transparently recorded and executed.

Instead of completely replacing existing forms of money, CBDCs are issued as a digital complement to them.

Types of CBDCs

Based on the intended users, CBDCs can be divided into two main types:

• Wholesale CBDCs:

Restricted to banks and financial institutions, wholesale CBDCs are used for high-value interbank payments, cross-border transfers, and related financial transactions.

• Retail CBDCs:

Designed for the general public's use, retail CBDCs enable people and businesses to make daily transactions and receive payments digitally.

Exploring the global progress of CBDCs

According to the most updated data of CBDCs global progress, 46 countries are currently in research stage, 33 in development stage, and 21 in pilot phase. 11 jurisdictions have issued their CBDCs, while many other governments are conducting sophisticated pilot tests and engaging various stakeholders.

Let’s have a quick look at some countries that are actively participating in this digital currency movement:

The Bahamas

The Bahamas was the first country in the world to launch its retail CBDC - the Sand Dollar. The Sand Dollar was piloted shortly after the devastating Hurricane Dorian, as the government sought to send immediate financial aid to citizens across the nation’s many islands.

Australia

In recent years, Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has actively collaborated with key stakeholders to carry out research projects and further evaluate legal and technical requirements of launching a digital Australian dollar (e-AUD). Even though RBA says e-AUD is “likely to be some years away", the country is making considerable progress.

China

China is one of the countries at the forefront of CBDCs development. People’s Bank of China first rolled out the digital yuan (e-CNY) during the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics. As of now, the country has launched e-CNY pilots across 26 cities in 17 provinces, accelerating digital yuan adoption.

Potential advantages of CBDCs adoption

Lower transaction costs

One of CBDCs’ primary benefits is lowering transaction costs for both domestic and cross-border payments. Leveraging digital ledgers, CBDCs enable instant or near-instant transactions on a public infrastructure, streamlining payment process and removing intermediary fees. For businesses, CBDCs present a compelling opportunity to enhance global trade affordability.

From a macroeconomic perspective, CBDCs offer an alternative to costly foreign exchange processes, potentially democratizing access to FDI opportunities and stimulating national economic growth.

Security and transparency

Operating on digital ledgers, CBDCs allow authorities to trace transactions in real time and better detect illicit activities, such as money laundering and terrorist financing. CBDCs are also inherently resistant to counterfeiting, eliminating the risks associated with fake currency notes circulating in the economy.

This not only enhances the overall integrity of the financial ecosystem but also reduces operational risks for businesses by mitigating the chances of fraud and ensuring compliance with regulatory standards.

Stable alternative to cryptocurrencies

The centralized regulation and legal tender status of CBDCs, as opposed to the decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies, provide a reliable store of value for users. This stability ensures that businesses can plan long-term investments and operations without the volatility associated with cryptocurrencies.

For countries where cryptocurrencies are popular, CBDCs could also incentivize citizens to use the local digital currency instead of digital money denominated in foreign currency or crypto assets (IMF, 2023).

Promoting financial inclusion

A 2019 report by Mastercard stated that 607 million people owned a mobile phone but did not have a bank account, most likely due to limited banking infrastructure in remote areas. Banking infrastructure remains an issue in 2024, particularly in rural areas of developing countries.

CBDCs, stored in digital wallets on mobile phones, can provide users with access to formal financial services even without internet connection. For businesses, CBDCs offer the potential to tap into new customer bases, particularly in underbanked regions; fostering a unified and reliable payment system.

Challenges associated with CBDCs adoption

Compromising financial autonomy

The ability of central banks to exert absolute surveillance over citizens’ transactions through CBDCs could introduce reputational risks for businesses. Privacy concerns might deter customers from engaging in digital transactions, affecting their spending patterns of certain goods and services. Of course, this depends on how much the public value confidentiality, and the degree of trust they have in their government.

Additionally, some have raised concerns that government entities could use CBDCs to control citizens' financial activity and execute policy-related decisions (e.g., asset freezing) in arbitrary ways.

Emerging cybersecurity risks

Compared to traditional monetary systems, CBDCs are more vulnerable to cybersecurity risks. Due to their centralized nature, a single breach in the CBDC network might expose sensitive company and customer financial data to cybercriminals, leading to reputational damage and substantial loss.

Regulatory and legal complexities

Legal changes required for issuing CBDCs may necessitate amendments that potentially undermine traditional banks and reshape their role in the new financial landscape.

Furthermore, the development of international agreements for cross-border transactions with CBDCs could introduce complexities in the global trade landscape, presenting significant adaptation challenges for businesses.

Limited digital literacy

Uneven digital literacy rates pose a significant challenge to the widespread positive impact of CBDCs. This is especially true in developing countries, where digital access statistics are skewed towards males, younger individuals, and urban residents.

This digital divide could exacerbate the financial inequalities that CBDCs aim to address. Furthermore, businesses catering to less digitally savvy customer segments may struggle to adapt to a CBDC environment, potentially leaving them behind.

The bottom line

Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) represent a compelling vision for a more inclusive and efficient financial landscape. However, the path to success requires navigating a complex web of challenges, from uneven digital literacy rates to the potential disintermediation of traditional banks.

The design of the CBDC itself would be a critical determinant of a smooth integration, along with robust regulatory frameworks and targeted financial literacy initiatives. A thorough navigation of current macroeconomic conditions would also be crucial for a successful CBDC rollout.

What is your take on CBDCs? Share with us in the comments!

Subscribe to Var Meta TechBriefs for the latest tech trends and industry insights in the realm of Blockchain, AI, Web3, etc.