Data Privacy in the Age of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Large Language Models (LLMs): Navigating Data Deletion and The Right to be Forgotten
Debbie Reynolds
The Data Diva | Data Privacy & Emerging Technologies Advisor | Technologist | Keynote Speaker | Helping Companies Make Data Privacy and Business Advantage | Advisor | Futurist | #1 Data Privacy Podcast Host | Polymath
In today's digital landscape, data creation is accelerating at an unprecedented pace. The rise of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the rapid adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized how organizations operate, offering transformative capabilities in data processing, analysis, and decision-making. However, this surge in data utilization brings significant challenges, particularly regarding Data Privacy and data protection. As individuals have more rights, regulations around the world, like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Europe and various State-level laws in the US, have emerged to safeguard personal data. These regulations often include the right to request data deletion or the right to be forgotten, posing new dilemmas for organizations leveraging AI and LLMs.
The Data Privacy Challenge
Artificial Intelligence, especially through LLMs like GPT-4, processes vast amounts of data to generate human-like text, provide recommendations, and perform complex analyses. Organizations can inadvertently incorporate sensitive, personal, or high-risk data into their training processes. When an individual exercises their right to data deletion or the right to be forgotten, organizations must find ways to ensure that this data is effectively removed from their systems, including any AI models that may have used it.
Compliance with data deletion and the right to be forgotten is complex due to the nature of how LLMs work. These models transform data into a high-dimensional space, making it difficult to trace back and delete specific pieces of information. However, organizations can adopt several strategies to manage these requests more effectively.
Strategies for Managing Data Deletion and the Right to be Forgotten with LLMs
1. Abstinence
The first strategy involves abstinence from incorporating personal, sensitive, or high-risk data into LLM models from the outset. By proactively excluding such data, organizations can mitigate the risk of privacy violations and simplify compliance with data deletion requests. Implementing abstinence requires a proactive approach to data governance and data management. It involves categorizing and filtering data before it is used in training models. While setting up robust data categorization and filtering systems can take some time and resources initially, the ongoing cost and time investment are relatively low. This method is cost-effective in the long run as it reduces the need for complex data removal processes.
Implementation:
Abstinence simplifies compliance and aligns with best practices in Data Privacy and ethical AI development. However, it may limit the richness of the data used for training, potentially impacting the performance and versatility of the models.
2. Suppression
Suppression involves configuring LLMs to suppress the output of personal, sensitive, or high-risk data. This strategy ensures that even if the model has been trained on such data, it is prevented from generating it in any output. Suppression involves developing and maintaining filtering mechanisms to ensure sensitive data does not appear in model outputs. This requires continuous monitoring and updating of the filters to adapt to new types of sensitive information. The initial setup can be complex and resource-intensive, and ongoing maintenance can add to the cost and time commitment. Also, suppression may not be 100 percent effective as data leaks from the model may be expertly prompted.? However, it effectively reduces the leakage of sensitive data, which can save costs related to data breaches and compliance issues.
Implementation:
Suppression helps manage Data Privacy in near real-time and ensures that sensitive information is not exposed through AI outputs. However, it requires ongoing maintenance and refinement of filters to adapt to new types of sensitive information that may arise.
3. Limitation
Limitation focuses on restricting the parameters and scope of what LLMs can do with personal, sensitive, or high-risk data. Limiting the scope and parameters of what an LLM can do with sensitive data involves setting access controls, defining scope limitations, and establishing guidelines for model use. Additionally, it may include modifying the internal parameters of the LLM to restrict its ability to process or generate outputs involving personal, sensitive, or high-risk data. Changing these internal parameters requires expertise in machine learning and an understanding of the model’s architecture, which can be expensive and time-consuming. The initial setup of these controls and parameter adjustments can be moderately time-intensive, but the ongoing cost is moderate as it involves periodic reviews and updates to the access controls, guidelines, and model parameters. This method ensures better control over Data Privacy while allowing organizations to leverage the capabilities of LLMs within a defined framework.
Implementation:
Limitation provides a balanced approach, allowing organizations to leverage the power of LLMs while maintaining control over Data Privacy. It involves setting clear boundaries and ensuring that the model operates within a defined framework prioritizing privacy.
4. Re-creation
Re-creation involves the periodic retraining or updating of LLMs to remove any traces of personal, sensitive, or high-risk data. Re-creation is the most resource-intensive and expensive method involving retraining or fine-tuning the model. This requires substantial computational power, time, and expertise, especially for large and complex models. The cost and time can be significant, particularly if the model needs frequent updates or is trained on extensive datasets. This is the “last resort” and not optimal; however, it can help ensure compliance with data deletion and the right to be forgotten, aligning with regulatory requirements.
Implementation:
Balancing Innovation and Privacy
Integrating AI and LLMs into various sectors brings unparalleled opportunities for innovation and efficiency. However, it also necessitates carefully balancing leveraging these technologies and safeguarding Data Privacy. Organizations must adopt a proactive and comprehensive approach to Data Privacy, incorporating strategies like abstinence, suppression, limitation, and recreation to navigate the complexities of data deletion and the right to be forgotten.
Compliance with regulations such as GDPR and State-level laws in the US is not just a legal obligation but a trust-building measure. Organizations that commit to Data Privacy can enhance their reputation and build stronger relationships with customers and stakeholders.
Advancements in AI and machine learning technologies can also address Data Privacy challenges. For instance, techniques like federated learning, where models are trained across multiple decentralized devices without transferring data to a central server, and techniques to "ablate" data or have the models "unlearn" information can help mitigate privacy risks in the future.
Beyond regulatory compliance and technological solutions, ethical considerations are crucial in Data Privacy. Organizations must prioritize transparency, fairness, and accountability in their AI practices. This includes being transparent about how data is used, ensuring that AI systems do not perpetuate biases or discrimination, and being accountable for the impacts of AI on individuals and society.
Data Privacy remains a paramount concern as we continue to navigate the age of AI and LLMs. The right to be forgotten and data deletion requests pose significant challenges for organizations leveraging these technologies. Organizations can effectively manage these requests and ensure compliance with Data Privacy regulations by adopting abstinence, suppression, limitation, and recreation strategies. Balancing innovation with privacy protection is essential for building trust and maintaining the ethical use of AI. As technology evolves, so must our approaches to safeguarding personal data in this ever-changing digital landscape, which will help organizations make Data Privacy a business advantage.
Debbie Reynolds "The Data Diva" Keynote Addresses
I'm thrilled to extend my heartfelt thanks to Volkswagen Credit, USDA, Ally Financial, National Grid, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Northwestern Mutual, PayPal, Coca-Cola, FRTIB, Hewlett Packard Enterprises, WestRock, Capital Group, Johnson & Johnson, Uber, S&P Global, FDIC, DHL Supply Chain, The Erikson Institute, and Rubrik for the privilege of being your Keynote Speaker. Your commitment to innovation and excellence is inspiring, and I'm honored to have contributed to your events.
The Pact Data Privacy Trust Framework
Debbie Reynolds, "The Data Diva," launched the PACT "Data Privacy" Trust Framework & Scorecard. This Framework can evaluate regulatory and business risk and the Trust of individuals around "Data Privacy". This is a gut check for organizations of all sizes to rate and triage their "Data Privacy" challenges. This Framework addresses Purpose, Alignment, Context, and Transparency. Watch this video to learn the basics as Debbie Reynolds explains the PACT Data Privacy Trust Framework & Scorecard in 6 minutes.
Visit our website to learn more about the PACT Data Privacy Trust Framework & Scorecard.
Do you need a Data+Privacy+Technology Workshop? Here are the top ten most requested Data Privacy Workshops for 2024:
Each 120-minute workshop structure includes:
Materials Provided:
?? “The Data Diva” Talks Privacy Podcast Hits 250,000 Downloads! ??
?? I am thrilled to announce that Debbie Reynolds and "The Data Diva" Talks Privacy podcast has reached a major milestone - 250,000 downloads as of May 2024! ??
?? I want to thank our amazing listeners from over 113 countries and 2,407 cities worldwide. Your support and enthusiasm have been nothing short of extraordinary! Also, I want to recognize The Data Privacy Advantage Newsletter's 12,390+ subscribers who faithfully read, comment, and share our work. ??????
Did you know that "The Data Diva" Talks Privacy podcast has listeners in 113 countries and 2,407 cities and is ranked globally in the top 2% of podcasts? Here are more of our accolades:
Watch a video short of our podcast on Tuesday, June 11, 2024, The Data Diva E188 -? Arielle Garcia, Founder, ASG Solutions, Privacy and Data Ethics, Responsible Media & Tech. Here is a sneak preview of our Data Diva Podcast guests:
Don't miss the new weekly episodes of "The Data Diva" Talks Privacy Podcast, so listen and subscribe.
The Data Diva Talks Privacy Podcast offers podcast sponsorships. Each level reflects a different degree of involvement and support for the podcast, catering to a wide range of sponsors from different sectors of the privacy community. If your organization is interested in exploring podcast sponsorship, please contact us!
In addition, and by popular demand, we have expanded our Influencer offerings to include:
Many thanks to "The Data Diva" Talks Privacy Podcast Sponsor and Privacy Visionary, Smartbox AI, for sponsoring this episode and supporting our podcast. Smartbox.ai, named British AI Company of the Year, provides cutting-edge AI, helps privacy and technology experts uniquely master their Data Request challenges, and makes it easier to comply with Global data protection requirements, FOIA requests, and various US state privacy regulations. Their technology is a game-changer for anyone needing to sift through complex data, find data,? and redact sensitive information. With clients across North America and Europe and a major partnership with Xerox, Smartbox.ai is bringing their data expertise right to our doorstep, offering insights into navigating the complex world of global data laws. For more information about Smartbox AI, visit their website at https://www.smartbox.ai.
Do you need a Data Diva Exclusive? Courtesy of Data Diva Media and "The Data Diva," in cooperation with our podcast's generous supporters, I am happy to share some valuable exclusives with our newsletter subscribers.
领英推荐
Many thanks to "The Data Diva" Talks Privacy podcast supporter Integral, a group that is revolutionizing health data compliance. Top tech and pharma leaders trust Integral's Privacy Workbench platform to simplify and speed up the expert determination process, ensuring compliant de-identification of sensitive datasets. No more guesswork about privacy risks or remediation options—Integral’s continuous monitoring keeps your data consistent and secure. Curious to streamline your data collaboration efforts? For more information about Integral, visit their website's Data Diva Link: https://why.useintegral.com/thedatadiva
Welcome Data Diva Subscribers to a special Data Diva Offer by Duality!
Claim your Complementary Duality Privacy Enhancing Technology evaluation. One AI Architect from a Fortune 100 company said, "Duality is far more elegant, secure, and valuable than anything we’ve come up with." As privacy advocates, Duality offers free evaluations to identify the most useful PETs for you or your clients today. You'll get access to our security, privacy, IT, and data science experts, a guided overview of privacy technologies tailored to your needs, and a customized workflow based on your use cases. Access this offer here:?
At 360ofme, we're thrilled to announce the upcoming launch of our new Companion Products: Privacy Policy Co-pilot and Enterprise Privacy Pulse. Privacy Policy Co-pilot is an AI-driven tool that analyzes and grades your privacy policies, providing actionable improvement suggestions to boost customer trust. Enterprise Privacy Pulse lets organizations complete a self-assessment to evaluate their privacy practices and receive personalized insights for enhancement. Currently, in beta, we invite you to sign up and be among the first 100 registrants to enjoy a 25% discount. Email 360ofme to take advantage of this offer at [email protected]
Many thanks to our Award-winning podcast sponsor, Safeguard Privacy, for offering a "Data Diva" exclusive offer! Get 15% off the first year of Safeguard Privacy compliance software using the code: DATADIVA15%
Courtesy of August 2022 Data Diva Podcast Guest Gal Ringel and Mine PrivacyOps, we are pleased to offer an exclusive discount to organizations. Thank you to our sponsor, Mine Privacy Ops, The first platform dedicated to handling Data Privacy operations while placing consumers and user experience at the center. #1 highest-rated Data Privacy Management Software, the #1 highest-rated DSR/DSAR Software, and the #1 highest-rated Sensitive Data Discovery Software in the industry on G2, the leading business software and services reviews platform. Use Mine PrivacyOps as your organization's Data Privacy management solution and receive a 20% discount on DSR, Data Mapping, and ROPA modules.
*To get the discount, contact [email protected] and add?Datadiva20 to the subject line.
Technics Publications?has graciously offered a Data Diva Promotion. Anyone who uses the coupon code?TheDataDiva?receives 20% off. The Promotional code is good for all books on the website, except DMBOK books. Visit the Technics Publications website now to take advantage of this off.
Need a publication discount on Data Privacy books and digital products? Purchase any products (including Data Privacy books) from the Manning Publications website, and you can use?The Data Diva's permanent 35% discount code (good for all our products in all formats) using the following code at checkout: poddatadiva22
Need a VPN, Internet Controls, and Virus Protection? Data Diva Podcast alumni guest for episode 60, Brad Hawkins, CEO of SaferNet,?has a special offer!?SaferNet provides a very easy-to-use 3-in-1 device-level Cyber Safety protection solution, including an award-winning VPN, Internet Controls, and Virus Protection. SaferNet is ideal for individuals and small to medium-sized businesses who want reliable data protection. "The Data Diva" herself loves the product!?Go to https://www.safernet.com/ and buy an annual SafeNet plan for 25% off, which can be paid monthly or annually using the case-sensitive code:?datadiva
Need a Privacy-Friendly Internet Browser extension? Data Diva Podcast alumni guest for episode 28, Kelly Finnerty, Director of Brand and Content at Startpage, has a special offer! If you want more control over your Data Privacy and less behavioral tracking while surfing the Internet, look no further.
Install Startpage Privacy Protection Extension for Chrome and Firefox: Install the link here
The Ultimate Easy Peasy Guide to Dependable DPIAs by Jamal Ahmed
Introducing: The Ultimate Easy Peasy Guide to Dependable DPIAs by Jamal Ahmed, a previous "Data Diva" Talks Privacy Podcast alumni.?Data Privacy isn’t just about protecting information; it’s about safeguarding trust, ensuring ethical responsibility, and preserving brand reputation.
Are you finding it challenging to navigate the complex world of Data Protection Impact Assessments (DPIAs)? Worry no more!
Jamal has developed the guide that takes the mystery out of DPIAs and puts YOU in control. Welcome to The Ultimate Easy Peasy Guide to Dependable DPIAs, your comprehensive guide to a confident data protection strategy.
Use the discount code “DataDiva” for 70% off this digital product.
See our recently featured five-minute videos on Data Privacy from The Data Diva:
Do you want to see more original video content on emerging Data Privacy topics? Subscribe to our YouTube channel to get notified about each week's new video.
Many thanks to the press organizations and reporters who seek my commentary on important events around Data Privacy. Also, here are links to some of my other media collaborations. Here is a collection of a few of my 2023-2024 media mentions and collaborations:
”With more data from humans and the rapid adoption of AI technologies, organizations will need to think about Data Privacy as a business problem and a business risk.” – Debbie Reynolds fo VPNRanks Article
Please see our website media mention section for a full list of media mentions.
Need a Keynote Speaker on "Data Privacy", Data Protection, and Technology issues? View our keynote speaker page for popular talks and topics. Ready to speak to "The Data Diva" about your speaking event? Fill out our speaker request form and Schedule a call now.
Do you need more Data Diva Events?
Want to know where "The Data Diva" is speaking next?
We're excited to announce the launch of Pamela Isom's new podcast, "AI or Not," produced by Data Diva Media! Tune in on Tuesday, June 11, 2024, for an engaging and enlightening experience. Guest #1 will be Debbie Reynolds, "The Data Diva" in episode one!
"AI or Not" is the podcast where digital transformation meets real-world wisdom. Hosted by Pamela Isom, a seasoned leader with over 25 years of experience in guiding businesses through digital disruption and transformation, this show explores the intersection of artificial intelligence, innovation, cybersecurity, ethics, and technology. With awards recognizing her as a change agent and digital disruptor, Pamela brings a wealth of knowledge and insight to the table.
The show demystifies the complexities of AI and emerging technologies, shedding light on their impact on business strategies, governance, product innovations, humanity, and societal well-being with esteemed guests from around the globe. Whether you're a professional seeking sustainable growth, a leader navigating digital ethics, or an innovator striving for meaningful impact, "AI or Not" offers insights, experiences, and discussions to illuminate your path in the digital age.
Data Diva Media is a media production operation providing?world-class video and podcast editing services.
Our Media Services include:
Ready to start your media project with "Data Diva" Media? Visit our Data Diva Media Website Page for more details and to schedule a meeting with the "Data Diva" Talks Privacy Podcast
Our LinkTree
Professor of Dental Public Health | Associate Dean, Academic Affairs at International Medical University | Certified Coach | EdTech Enthusiast
6 个月Very helpful.
Thank you for the interesting insight. It is also worth mentioning the problem of EFFECTIVE data deletion. Unfortunately, many IT specialists, even in large organizations, disregard the topic of irreversible data destruction. And remember that this can lead to its uncontrolled leakage
EIPACC registered Data Protection Professional ISO 27701| C-DPO| PbD Intermediate| PrivacyOps| Privado Technical Privacy Expert| BigID Privacy Professional| Certified in Data Breach Management| LLM- IPR and Tech Law
9 个月Very informative!
vCISO, Security Practice Leader and HITRUST Assessor with Healthcare Experience at Assured SPC
9 个月Really great article Debbie. Thank you for sharing
A licensed (Illinois) CPA, with extensive experience in conducting risk and internal controls assessments. Frameworks covered includes (but not limited to), NIST CSF, NIST 800-53, MARS-E, FedRAMP and CSA CCM.
9 个月Great advice!