Dark Empathy in Leadership: The Hidden Danger and How to Protect Yourself

As an executive leadership coach, I’ve had the privilege of working with high-level leaders across various industries, helping them unlock their potential and build more effective teams. However, there’s a growing issue I’ve seen more frequently in recent years, one that often goes undetected but can cause significant damage to both individuals and organizations. I’m talking about dark empathy in leadership.

Dark empathy is a term that refers to the ability to understand and manipulate the emotions of others for personal gain. Unlike true empathy, which fosters connection, trust, and positive influence, dark empathy is used to exploit or control people. It’s a subtle, toxic form of manipulation that can be difficult to detect but incredibly damaging when it’s present in leadership.

What Does Dark Empathy Look Like in Leadership?

I’ve encountered leaders who demonstrate traits of dark empathy in various ways, and I’ve watched it unfold in coaching and training sessions. Often, it begins innocently enough, with leaders displaying strong emotional intelligence. They are excellent at reading the room, understanding people’s needs, and knowing what motivates them. But the difference is in how they use that knowledge.

Here are a few signs of dark empathy in leadership:

1. The Charismatic Manipulator

These leaders are incredibly likable, even magnetic. They know exactly how to connect with others, make them feel understood, and gain their trust. However, their intentions are not as benevolent as they may seem. For example, I once worked with a senior leader who used their charm to gain loyalty from their direct reports—but behind the scenes, they used their understanding of people’s vulnerabilities to control outcomes, often pitting colleagues against each other to maintain their own power.

2. The Emotional Puppet Master

Some leaders use their keen understanding of emotions to pull the strings of others. They can sense when someone is vulnerable, frustrated, or insecure, and they manipulate those feelings for personal gain. A client of mine shared how their boss would use subtle guilt-trips, invoking personal stories of hardship or sacrifice to make employees feel indebted, ensuring compliance in ways that were emotionally coercive, not supportive.

3. Exploiting Empathy for Political Gain

Leaders with dark empathy can be experts at playing office politics. They align themselves with certain people, gain their trust, and then use that influence to further their own agenda. This can look like mid-level managers using their close relationships with their team members to gather private information, which they would then leverage to position themselves more favorably with upper management.

How to Avoid Becoming a Dark Empathic Leader

As a leader, it’s easy to fall into the trap of using empathy as a tool for control—especially when you’re under pressure or feel your position is threatened. Here’s what I’ve learned through my coaching sessions about how leaders can avoid crossing that line:

1. Practice Self-Awareness and Integrity

One of the first steps in ensuring you don’t fall into the trap of dark empathy is developing self-awareness. This means regularly reflecting on your motivations and actions. Ask yourself: Am I seeking to understand this person so I can help them, or am I seeking to manipulate them for my own gain? It can be hard to discern at first, but consistently checking in with your core values and holding yourself to a high standard of integrity can help prevent you from slipping into unethical behavior.

2. Embrace Authentic Vulnerability

True empathy requires openness and mutual respect. Dark empathy, on the other hand, thrives on using others’ vulnerabilities against them. As leaders, we need to embrace vulnerability ourselves. Share your challenges honestly with your team—this helps build trust and reduces the temptation to use others’ emotions for personal gain. Leaders who are authentic in their vulnerability are more likely to foster an environment of empathy that is genuine, not manipulative.

3. Encourage Open Communication and Psychological Safety

When employees feel they can speak up without fear of retaliation, it’s much harder for dark empathic leaders to exploit them. Building a culture of psychological safety is essential. Ensure your team feels comfortable expressing their opinions, asking for help, and even disagreeing with you. By fostering open communication and mutual respect, you prevent the kinds of subtle emotional manipulation that can emerge under a leader’s control.

4. Set Clear Boundaries

Dark empathy often thrives in environments where boundaries are unclear or weak. As a leader, it’s important to set clear professional boundaries with your team. While you can show empathy, you should never cross the line into over-identifying with employees or using their personal situations to manipulate them. This requires clarity, consistency, and a commitment to ethical leadership.

How to Deal with a Dark Empathic Leader

If you suspect that you’re working for—or with—a dark empathic leader, it’s crucial to act with caution and strategy. Here are some approaches I’ve shared with clients who have been in such situations:

1. Document Your Interactions

If you’re dealing with a leader who uses dark empathy for manipulation, documenting your interactions can be a vital tool. Keep records of any conversations or behavior that feels coercive, manipulative, or emotionally exploitative. This documentation can be useful if you need to report the behavior to HR or if it escalates into something more serious.

2. Set Emotional Boundaries

One of the hardest parts of working with a dark empathic leader is maintaining your emotional boundaries. They may try to guilt-trip you or use emotional manipulation to get you to comply with their agenda. It’s important to recognize these tactics and resist falling into them. Develop the habit of pausing before responding, and give yourself the space to evaluate whether your actions are aligned with your values or being influenced by manipulation.

3. Seek Support

Don’t isolate yourself in a toxic environment. Find colleagues, mentors, or an executive coach to help you navigate the situation. Sometimes, simply knowing that someone else understands what you’re going through can provide the strength and clarity you need to address the issue. You’re not alone in this.

4. Escalate When Necessary

If a dark empathic leader’s behavior crosses into harassment or becomes truly harmful, it’s important to escalate the situation to HR or higher management. Addressing it early can help prevent it from getting worse. Make sure to present factual information and examples to support your case.

Conclusion: Leading with True Empathy

Dark empathy is a hidden danger that can undermine trust, morale, and performance within teams. As leaders, we have a responsibility to use our understanding of others’ emotions to uplift and guide—not control or exploit. Over time, true empathy will always yield better results than manipulation, because it builds genuine relationships and fosters loyalty and trust.

In my work with executives, I’ve seen leaders who successfully shift from dark empathy to genuine empathy and watch their leadership effectiveness skyrocket. When we use our emotional intelligence responsibly—always with integrity and self-awareness— we create stronger, healthier teams and a more sustainable path to success.

If you’re a leader, take a moment to reflect on how you’re using your emotional insight. Are you seeking to uplift others, or are you unintentionally using their emotions for your own benefit? As a coach, I’m always here to help leaders find their way back to authentic, impactful leadership. I also offer workshops for organizations interested in creating healthy leadership dynamics. Reach out to explore how we can work together!

I hope this article helps you understand the importance of genuine empathy in leadership and how to recognize, avoid, and deal with dark empathy in others. If you’ve encountered dark empathy in your leadership journey or in your work environment, I’d love to hear about it and share more insights in the comments. Let’s keep the conversation going!

If you're intrigued by the concept of dark empathy and how it shows up in leadership—and even in our daily interactions—I highly recommend checking out my latest article . I dive into the subtle yet powerful ways dark empaths operate and share practical insights on how to spot them, whether in the workplace or your personal life. In addition to my own experiences working with leaders, I’ve also linked to an informative piece by BetterUp that goes deeper into the traits of dark empaths and offers actionable strategies for managing these dynamics. It's essential reading for anyone looking to build healthier, more authentic relationships both at work and beyond.

?? Read the full article here https://www.betterup.com/blog/dark-empath for more information on how to identify and protect yourself from dark empathy.

Read my article on emotional lability , the experience of unpredictable, exaggerated emotional responses like crying or laughing without control. It can be caused by stress, trauma, mental health issues, or medical conditions. Recognizing it is key to understanding how to manage it, often through emotional regulation techniques and therapy. By building emotional resilience, people can better handle emotional swings and improve their overall mental well-being. For deeper insights, visit the full article here .

6 Types of Work Styles and How to Find Yours:

Are you ready to transform the way you work? This article delves into the diverse work styles that shape our professional lives and how understanding them can lead to greater productivity and satisfaction. From flexible work environments to collaborative strategies, this piece explores how recognizing and adapting to different work styles can enhance team dynamics and drive personal success. If you’re looking to optimize your work habits and foster better interactions with colleagues, don’t miss this insightful read. Discover how to tailor your approach for maximum impact and find your ideal work style: https://www.betterup.com/blog/work-styles

Why You Feel A Sense of Impending Doom and How to Sooth it:

In our fast-paced world, it's all too easy to feel overwhelmed by a sense of impending doom, where every challenge seems like an insurmountable obstacle. This article addresses this pervasive feeling head-on, offering insightful strategies to help you overcome anxiety and turn those looming fears into actionable opportunities. Discover practical tips to reframe your mindset, build resilience, and harness uncertainty as a catalyst for personal and professional growth. Don’t let fear hold you back—read the full article and empower yourself to face challenges with confidence and clarity: https://www.betterup.com/blog/impending-doom

Unmasking Colorism: An Urgent Keynote for Hispanic Heritage Month

Book my impactful keynote presentation, "Colorism and Intersectionality in the Latino Community."

Colorism, the discrimination based on skin tone, is a legacy of colonialism that continues to shape everything from beauty standards to career advancement for Latinos. While diversity efforts typically focus on increasing representation across race and ethnicity, the unique challenges faced by Black and Afro-Latino professionals often fall through the cracks.

Drawing on my own experiences navigating predominantly white institutions as an Afro-Latina, as well as the stories of other women of color in the workplace which I share in my award-winning book, Leadership is a Responsibility , I shine a light on the complex intersections of race, color, and identity within the Latino diaspora. This keynote help attendees learn how colorism manifests in corporate settings through biases, microaggressions, and barriers to leadership.

To book Dr. Capellan for your next event, contact her at [email protected] .