The Dangerous game that could cost you Everything!

In continuation of last week’s article on fraud, let’s tackle a controversial question head-on: What happens if you don’t report fraud? Or worse—if your company covers it up without investigating? Having spent 23 years in compliance, I've seen how the fallout from such decisions can snowball from internal whispers to full-blown corporate disasters.

Today, we’ll explore the kinds of fraud that need to be reported under IFRS standards and the Companies Act, 2013, and what happens when companies fail to take action—especially in the eyes of the law.

Why Timely Fraud Reporting Matters

Picture this: an internal audit reveals suspicious activity—mismanaged funds, inflated purchase orders, or phantom vendors. Rather than raising a red flag, management decides to sweep it under the rug, thinking they’ll avoid a scandal. But what happens when the cover-up is exposed months later? The damage isn’t just to the bottom line—it’s to the company’s very credibility.

In listed companies, failing to report fraud isn’t just unethical—it’s illegal. Transparency isn’t just a nice-to-have; it’s a legal obligation. And the consequences of avoiding it can range from hefty fines to the very public destruction of the company’s reputation.

What Fraud Needs to Be Reported?

Over the years, I’ve worked closely with key business leaders and directors to ensure that everyone understands the types of fraud that must be reported—no exceptions, no excuses. Here's what the law demands:

Under IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards):

• Financial Statement Fraud: Manipulating the books to hide losses or inflate revenues—this is a ticking time bomb. Misreporting financial results not only misleads investors but also violates IFRS requirements, leading to restatements and, often, regulatory action.
• Asset Misappropriation: Whether it's theft, embezzlement, or misuse of resources, any act that impacts the financial statements has to be disclosed.
• Weak Internal Controls: If there’s a material weakness in the company’s internal controls that could lead to fraud, it has to be reported.

Under the Companies Act, 2013:

• Procurement Fraud: In distribution-heavy industries, procurement fraud—like inflating vendor contracts or receiving kickbacks from suppliers—has to be reported under Section 143(12).
• Bribery and Corruption: Any corrupt practices must be immediately reported, with severe consequences for those involved.
• Tax and Financial Misrepresentation: If the company is hiding its financial standing or evading taxes, failure to report this fraud can lead to significant fines, even criminal charges.

The Role of KMPs and Directors: Your Head’s on the Block

Let me be crystal clear: if you’re a KMP or a director, you’re personally responsible for reporting fraud. Turning a blind eye isn't just risky—it’s illegal. And in the event of a cover-up, the consequences aren’t just for the company; they’re for you too.

• Personal Liability: Under Section 447 of the Companies Act, directors and KMPs can face up to 10 years imprisonment for their role in hiding or failing to report fraud.
• Disqualification: Directors can be barred from serving on any boards for up to five years.
• Reputational Fallout: Once news breaks of a cover-up, the reputational damage can destroy careers and companies in one swoop.

Consequences of Not Investigating Fraud

In my experience, choosing not to investigate fraud or intentionally hiding it leads to consequences that can far outweigh the initial problem. For listed companies, the risks are magnified—both under Indian law and IFRS standards.

Legal Consequences Under Indian Law

• Prison Time: Directors and KMPs can face up to 10 years of imprisonment for fraud under Section 447 of the Companies Act. And if the fraud involved public money, the penalties are even harsher.
• Financial Penalties: Beyond prison time, there are steep financial penalties, including disqualification from serving as a director or auditor.
• Stock Market Impact: Failing to disclose fraud in a listed company can lead to SEBI penalties and a collapse in stock value.

Global Fallout: IFRS and Financial Integrity

• Fraudulent financial reporting requires restatements under IFRS, which can result in lawsuits, penalties, and long-term damage to investor confidence. I've seen companies lose investor trust overnight, simply because they failed to report a small fraud that escalated.

The Cost of Covering Up Fraud

Let me share a real-world example. A company I once worked with uncovered a procurement fraud that had been going on for years. Instead of investigating it immediately, the leadership chose to delay action, hoping it would quietly go away. It didn’t. By the time the fraud was discovered, it had grown into a massive issue—leading to major financial losses, stock price collapse, and high-level resignations.

And the damage didn’t stop there. The reputation of the company took a permanent hit, with media coverage highlighting the fraud and the cover-up. Restoring trust after such a scandal? Almost impossible.

Proactive Investigation: The Key to Prevention

In my role as a compliance officer, I work closely with business leaders, finance teams, and auditors to ensure we have robust controls in place to detect fraud early. Early detection is critical. If we catch fraud before it escalates, we have the chance to mitigate the damage and protect the company’s reputation.

Hiding Fraud Will Destroy You

If you take one thing from this article, let it be this: not reporting fraud is far more dangerous than dealing with the consequences of the fraud itself. The longer you wait, the more catastrophic the outcome. Whether you’re a KMP, director, or part of the compliance team—transparency is your greatest weapon. The cost of hiding fraud will destroy not just your company, but your career as well.

So, the next time you’re faced with fraud, think carefully. Will you report it and deal with the fallout responsibly, or will you hide it—and risk everything?

?