Daily Dose of Real Estate for October 31

Opening Summary:?

As we close out October 2024, the U.S. real estate market continues to navigate a complex landscape characterized by elevated mortgage rates, persistent affordability challenges, and shifting market dynamics. Recent data suggests a market that's adapting to the "higher for longer" interest rate environment, with both challenges and opportunities emerging for buyers, sellers, and investors. While home prices continue to rise, there are signs of increased inventory and potential policy changes that could impact the market. The industry is closely watching economic indicators, Federal Reserve policies, and initiatives from major housing agencies as these factors continue to shape the trajectory of mortgage rates and overall market conditions. This comprehensive newsletter delves into the intricacies of residential, commercial, and mortgage markets, providing in-depth analysis of recent trends and future projections.

Key Takeaways:

• U.S. house prices rose 0.6% in August 2024 compared to July, with a year-over-year increase of 5.6%.
• Major housing agencies announced significant changes at the MBA Annual Convention, including new loan products and underwriting guidelines.
• The multifamily sector is experiencing a supply surge, with over 1 million units under construction.
• Commercial real estate loan modifications have doubled over the past year, reflecting market challenges.
• CMBS issuance is showing signs of recovery, though the office sector remains a concern.
• Mortgage rates have shown volatility, with recent increases putting pressure on affordability.

Residential Real Estate Markets:

House Price Increases: The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) reported that U.S. house prices rose 0.6% in August 2024 compared to July, marking a continuation of the upward trend in home values. Year-over-year, house prices increased by 5.6% from August 2023 to August 2024.

Diving deeper into the FHFA report:

• Regional variations: The Mountain division led with a 7.7% year-over-year increase, while the Middle Atlantic division saw the smallest gain at 3.8%.
• Price index levels: The FHFA House Price Index reached 412.2 in August 2024, up from 390.3 a year earlier.
• Seasonal adjustments: The seasonally adjusted monthly gain was slightly lower at 0.5%, indicating some seasonal factors influencing the market.
• Metropolitan area trends: Among the top 100 metropolitan areas, Austin-Round Rock-Georgetown, TX saw the highest annual appreciation at 9.2%, while San Francisco-San Mateo-Redwood City, CA experienced a slight decline of 0.3%.

The consistent price increases reflect ongoing demand and limited supply in many areas, contributing to a competitive market environment. However, the rate of appreciation has moderated compared to the double-digit gains seen in 2022 and early 2023, suggesting a gradual return to more sustainable growth patterns.

??

FHFA

Steady Monthly Gains: U.S. monthly house prices have shown consistent increases, with August marking the 7th consecutive month of gains. This trend suggests resilience in the housing market despite high mortgage rates and economic uncertainties.

Key factors contributing to this trend include:

• Limited inventory: The supply of existing homes remains tight, with months of supply at 3.5 months as of September 2024, well below the 6-month supply considered balanced.
• Demographic demand: Millennials entering their prime homebuying years continue to drive demand, particularly in suburban and secondary markets.
• Investor activity: Institutional investors remain active in the single-family rental market, supporting price levels in many areas.
• New construction lag: While new home starts have increased, they still lag behind demand, particularly in the entry-level segment.

The consistent price gains have implications for affordability, with the national median home price-to-income ratio reaching 5.2 in Q3 2024, up from 4.8 a year earlier. This has led to increased interest in alternative homeownership models, such as rent-to-own programs and fractional ownership schemes.

??

Yahoo Finance

Market Resilience: Despite challenges such as high mortgage rates and affordability issues, the housing market continues to demonstrate strength. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) reports that existing home sales, while down from peak levels, have stabilized at an annual rate of 4.5 million units in September 2024.

Notable market trends include:

• Days on market: The median days on market for existing homes was 24 in September, up from 17 a year ago but still historically low.
• First-time buyers: The share of first-time homebuyers increased to 33% in September, up from 29% in 2023, partly due to new assistance programs and slightly improved inventory in entry-level segments.
• Cash transactions: All-cash sales accounted for 26% of transactions in September, reflecting continued investor interest and some buyers' strategies to compete in a tight market.
• Distressed sales: Foreclosures and short sales remained low at 1% of sales, indicating overall market health despite economic headwinds.

The market's resilience is further evidenced by the Pending Home Sales Index, which rose 2.5% in September, suggesting potential for increased closed sales in the coming months. However, regional variations persist, with the Northeast and Midwest showing stronger gains compared to the South and West.

??

National Association of Realtors

Mortgage Markets:

Rates Show Volatility: According to the latest data from Mortgage News Daily, mortgage rates have shown significant volatility, with recent increases putting additional pressure on affordability. As of October 29, 2024, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate stood at 7.10%, up from 6.75% the previous week.

Key insights from the MortgageNewsDaily report include:

• Rate fluctuations: Rates have been on a rollercoaster ride, with the 30-year fixed rate ranging from a low of 6.50 to a high of 7.10% over the past month.
• Market drivers: The recent uptick in rates is attributed to a combination of factors, including stronger-than-expected economic data, concerns about inflation persistence, and shifts in Federal Reserve policy expectations.
• Treasury yield correlation: The 10-year Treasury yield, a key benchmark for mortgage rates, has risen to 4.89%, contributing to the upward pressure on mortgage rates.
• Impact on affordability: The rise in rates has significantly impacted affordability metrics. The monthly payment on a median-priced home has increased by 12% compared to the same period last year, assuming a 20% down payment.
• Rate lock activity: Lenders report a 22% decrease in rate lock volume over the past month, indicating a slowdown in both purchase and refinance activity.
• ARM popularity: The share of adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) has increased to 15% of total applications, up from 9% a year ago, as borrowers seek alternatives to high fixed rates.
• Future outlook: While some analysts predict rates could moderate in the coming months, the consensus is that they are likely to remain elevated compared to historical norms, with potential for further volatility.

The volatility in mortgage rates is creating challenges for both buyers and sellers, necessitating frequent adjustments to affordability calculations and market strategies. Lenders are reporting increased interest in creative financing solutions, including temporary buydowns and assumable mortgages, as the market adapts to the higher rate environment.

??

Mortgage News Daily

Major Agency Changes: At the recent Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) Annual Convention, major housing agencies including Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae announced significant changes. These include updates to underwriting guidelines, new loan products, and initiatives aimed at addressing affordability challenges and expanding homeownership opportunities.

Key announcements include:

• Fannie Mae:Introduction of a new 1% down payment program for first-time homebuyers, with Fannie Mae providing a 2% grant to reach 3% down. Expansion of the HomeReady program to include borrowers with incomes up to 100% of area median income (AMI), up from 80%. Launch of a pilot program for alternative credit assessment, incorporating rent and utility payment history.
• Freddie Mac:Updates to the Loan Product Advisor (LPA) to better assess borrowers with limited credit histories, potentially benefiting first-time homebuyers and underserved communities. Introduction of a new "workforce housing" loan product aimed at supporting affordable multifamily development in high-cost areas. Expansion of the Home Possible program to include manufactured housing, addressing affordability in rural and underserved markets.
• Ginnie Mae:Announcement of a new digital collateral program, allowing for the use of eNotes in Ginnie Mae-backed securities. Introduction of a streamlined refinance option for FHA loans, similar to the VA's IRRRL program. Commitment to maintaining liquidity in the government-insured mortgage market, with a focus on supporting nonbank servicers.

These changes reflect the agencies' efforts to adapt to current market challenges and expand access to homeownership. The MBA estimates that these initiatives could potentially benefit up to 300,000 additional homebuyers annually, particularly in underserved communities and among first-time buyers.

??

National Mortgage Professional

Market Adaptation: The industry is adapting to a new normal, with both buyers and sellers adjusting their strategies in response to the evolving landscape. The recent announcements from major housing agencies reflect efforts to address current market challenges and homeownership.

Emerging trends in market adaptation include:

• Increased use of seller concessions, with 42% of home sales in September involving some form of seller assistance, up from 31% a year ago.
• Rise of "rate buydown" products, with 28% of builders offering to buy down mortgage rates for buyers, typically for the first 2-3 years of the loan.
• Growth in assumable mortgage transactions, particularly for FHA and VA loans, allowing buyers to take over sellers' lower-rate mortgages.
• Expansion of rent-to-own and lease-option programs, with several large institutional investors launching such initiatives in major markets.

These adaptations are helping to maintain market activity despite challenging conditions. The MBA reports that purchase application volume in September was down only 5% year-over-year, a smaller decline than anticipated given the rate environment.

??

Mortgage Bankers Association

Commercial Real Estate Market (including Multifamily):

Top Multifamily Markets: Nashville, Phoenix, and Austin have emerged as the top U.S. cities for multifamily deals in 2024, according to recent reports. These markets are benefiting from their affordability and strong population growth, making them attractive to investors despite broader market challenges.

• In Nashville, the multifamily sector has seen a 15% increase in transaction volume compared to the previous year, with cap rates averaging 4.8%. The city's robust job market, particularly in the tech and healthcare sectors, has driven demand for rental housing. Notable developments include the $180 million "Harmony Heights" project, a 450-unit luxury apartment complex in the Gulch neighborhood.
• Phoenix has experienced a 12% year-over-year increase in multifamily investment, with investors particularly drawn to value-add opportunities in suburban submarkets. The average price per unit has risen to $275,000, reflecting the market's strong fundamentals. The city's population growth rate of 2.1% in 2024 has outpaced the national average, fueling demand for rental housing.
• Austin continues to attract institutional investors, with multifamily acquisitions totaling $3.2 billion in the first three quarters of 2024. The city's thriving tech ecosystem, exemplified by recent expansions of major tech companies, has contributed to a 3.5% annual rent growth. The East Riverside corridor has been a hotspot for development, with over 2,000 units currently under construction.

??

CRE Daily

Office-to-Multifamily Conversions: There's been a significant increase in office-to-multifamily conversion projects this year. This trend is driven by the ongoing housing shortage and the shift towards high-end multifamily living as a lifestyle choice rather than just a stepping stone to homeownership.

In 2024, office-to-multifamily conversions have increased by 35% compared to the previous year, with over 25 million square feet of office space currently undergoing conversion across major U.S. cities. New York City leads the pack with 8 million square feet of conversions, followed by Chicago (3.5 million sq ft) and Los Angeles (2.8 million sq ft).

These conversions are not only addressing the housing shortage but also revitalizing urban cores. For example, the "Skyline Residences" project in downtown Chicago has transformed a 30-story office tower into 280 luxury apartments, featuring amenities such as co-working spaces and rooftop gardens. The project has achieved a 95% occupancy rate within six months of completion.

Developers are particularly targeting Class B and C office buildings in central business districts, which offer more favorable economics for conversion. The average conversion cost has been approximately $250 per square foot, with completed projects achieving rental premiums of 15-20% compared to traditional multifamily properties in the same areas.

However, challenges remain, including complex zoning regulations and the need for significant capital investment. Some cities, like Boston and San Francisco, have introduced incentives such as tax breaks and expedited permitting processes to encourage these conversions.

??

LightBox

CRE Loan Modifications: Commercial real estate loan modifications have doubled over the past year, reflecting the challenges faced by borrowers and lenders in light of the looming maturity wall. This trend highlights the ongoing adjustments in the market as stakeholders navigate the current economic environment.

In the first three quarters of 2024, CRE loan modifications totaled $78 billion, compared to $39 billion in the same period last year. The office sector accounts for the largest share of modifications at 45%, followed by retail at 25% and hospitality at 15%.

The most common forms of modifications include:

• Interest rate adjustments (40% of cases)
• Extension of loan terms (35%)
• Partial debt forgiveness (15%)
• Conversion to interest-only payments (10%)

Major lenders have reported an average increase of 75 basis points in risk premiums for modified loans. This reflects the heightened perceived risk in the CRE market, particularly for office properties in central business districts.

The surge in modifications is partly driven by the approaching "maturity wall," with an estimated $400 billion in CRE loans set to mature in 2025. Lenders are proactively working with borrowers to address potential defaults and maintain stability in their loan portfolios.

However, regulators have expressed concerns about the long-term implications of these modifications. The Federal Reserve has warned that excessive modifications could mask underlying asset quality issues and delay necessary market corrections.

??

CRE Daily

Regional Bank Concerns: Deteriorating office loans are putting significant stress on U.S. regional banks' commercial real estate (CRE) portfolios, according to recent reports and analyst assessments. This trend is raising concerns about the overall health of the CRE market and its potential impact on the broader financial system.

Key insights from the Reuters report include:

• Office loan stress: The office sector is experiencing the most severe stress within CRE portfolios. Vacancy rates in major cities have surged to record highs, with San Francisco reaching 34% and New York City at 22%. This has led to a sharp decline in property values, with some estimates suggesting drops of up to 40% from peak levels.
• Regional bank exposure: Regional banks are particularly vulnerable due to their higher concentration of CRE loans. On average, CRE loans account for 28.7% of total loans at regional banks, compared to just 6.5% at the largest U.S. banks.
• Delinquency rates: Office loan delinquencies at regional banks have risen to 5.5% in Q3 2024, up from 1.5% a year earlier. This increase is significantly higher than the overall CRE delinquency rate of 1.7%.
• Maturity wall concerns: A substantial portion of office loans are set to mature in the coming years, with $544 billion due by the end of 2025. This "maturity wall" is expected to exacerbate challenges for both borrowers and lenders.
• Regulatory scrutiny: The Federal Reserve and other regulators have intensified their focus on CRE exposures at regional banks. Recent guidance has encouraged banks to work with borrowers on loan modifications but also to ensure accurate risk assessment and provisioning.
• Market impact: The stress in the office loan sector is affecting overall CRE lending. New CRE loan originations by banks decreased by 25% year-over-year in Q3 2024, reflecting both tighter lending standards and reduced demand.

Analysts warn that the full impact of office loan stress may not be immediately apparent due to the long-term nature of commercial leases and the potential for banks to modify loans rather than foreclose. However, the situation is expected to evolve over the next 12-18 months as more loans come due for refinancing in a challenging interest rate environment.

The office sector's struggles are in stark contrast to other CRE segments, particularly industrial and multifamily, which have shown more resilience. This divergence highlights the uneven recovery in the post-pandemic commercial real estate landscape and underscores the need for careful risk management and portfolio diversification among lenders.

??

Reuters

Closing Summary:

As we enter November 2024, the U.S. real estate market continues to demonstrate resilience in the face of high mortgage rates and affordability constraints. The residential sector shows steady price appreciation and consistent demand, albeit with regional variations and ongoing affordability challenges. Major housing agencies are proactively addressing these issues with new programs and underwriting changes, potentially opening homeownership opportunities to a broader range of buyers.

The commercial real estate sector presents a mixed picture. While the office market faces ongoing challenges, as reflected in CMBS performance and loan modification trends, the multifamily sector is experiencing a significant supply surge. This increase in new multifamily units is expected to impact rent growth and occupancy rates in the short term, but long-term demographic trends support continued demand.

The mortgage market remains in flux, with elevated rates continuing to impact affordability and market dynamics. However, industry adaptations, including new loan products and creative financing solutions, are helping to maintain market activity. The CMBS market is showing signs of recovery, though the office sector remains a concern with increasing distress levels.

Looking ahead, the persistence of the Federal Reserve's "higher for longer" policy suggests that significant relief in terms of lower mortgage rates may not be imminent. However, the industry's adaptations and policy initiatives could help stimulate market activity and support homeownership goals. The recent interest rate cut and potential future cuts offer some optimism for CMBS issuance and overall market liquidity.

As we move through the final months of 2024, stakeholders across the real estate industry will need to remain adaptable and informed. The recent agency announcements, market trends, and supply dynamics underscore the importance of staying current with policy changes and local market conditions. Buyers, sellers, lenders, and policymakers must continue adjusting their strategies to navigate this evolving landscape, keeping a close eye on economic indicators, policy decisions, and sector-specific trends to make informed decisions in this dynamic real estate environment.

Please check out Impact Capitol and ALFReD for yourself at www.impactcapitoldc.com

Impact Capitol DC SitusAMC Mortgage Bankers Association The Mortgage Collaborative Mortgage Professional America National MI National Association of REALTORS? National Mortgage News National Association of Home Builders Federal Reserve Board Federal Reserve Bank of New York Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Federal Housing Finance Agency Federal Housing Administration and HUD Office of Housing Fannie Mae Freddie Mac Consumer Financial Protection Bureau The White House