Cybersecurity Awareness Training Showdown: Living Security vs. KnowBe4 vs. Proofpoint
Let’s be real—cybersecurity training has a bit of a reputation. You mention “security awareness,†and half the office suddenly finds an urgent need to refill their coffee. But with social engineering attacks on the rise and human error responsible for over 80% of breaches, security training isn’t just a checkbox—it’s so much more important than that.?
So, if you’re looking for a cybersecurity awareness training platform that won’t bore your employees into loathing their cybersecurity departments, you’ve got options. Three of the top contenders? Living Security, KnowBe4, and Proofpoint Security Awareness Training. Each has its strengths, and each is a partner here at SecureNation . So, let’s break them down and find the best fit for your team.?
?
Living Security : The Fun & Gamified Innovator?
?? Best for: Gamified, immersive, and behavioral-focused training?
If the words “security training†make your employees groan, Living Security might just be your lifesaver. Instead of traditional slide decks and quizzes, Living Security makes learning fun with escape rooms, interactive storytelling, and team-based challenges.?
?? What’s great about it??
? Most engaging platform—escape rooms, storytelling, and games.?
? Focuses on behavior change, not just training completion.?
? Advanced human risk scoring that integrates with SIEM & IAM tools.?
? Best for organizations that want to boost security culture.?
?? Potential drawbacks??
? Phishing simulations are weaker than KnowBe4’s.?
? Higher cost for immersive experiences.?
Verdict: If you want employees to actually enjoy security training, Living Security is your best bet. It’s less about checking boxes and more about driving real behavioral change.?
?
KnowBe4 : The Phishing Simulation Powerhouse?
?? Best for: Phishing simulations & compliance-driven training?
If you want to put your employees to the test with realistic phishing attacks, KnowBe4 is the go-to platform. Their AI-driven phishing simulations are top-notch, letting you send out tricky, real-world-style phishing emails to see who takes the bait (and then train them accordingly).?
?? What’s great about it??
? Industry-leading phishing tests with customizable templates.?
? Huge library of security awareness content (videos, quizzes, games).?
? Strong compliance focus (HIPAA, GDPR, PCI, etc.).?
? Simple and effective user risk scoring based on training performance.?
?? Potential drawbacks??
? Less engaging than newer, interactive training methods.?
? Doesn’t provide deep behavioral analytics.?
Verdict: If your top priority is phishing simulation and compliance training, KnowBe4 is the best in the business. But if you want next-level engagement, you might want to look elsewhere.?
领英推è
?
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training : The Data-Driven Defender?
?? Best for: Threat-driven training & behavioral analytics?
Proofpoint takes a data-first approach to security awareness, leveraging its industry-leading threat intelligence to provide personalized, adaptive training based on actual attack trends. If you’re already using Proofpoint for email security, the integration makes this an even stronger choice.?
?? What’s great about it??
? Uses real-world threat intelligence to shape training programs.?
? Adaptive learning adjusts training based on employee behavior.?
? Deep integration with email security & SIEM tools.?
? More behavior-based insights than KnowBe4.?
?? Potential drawbacks??
? Pricier than some competitors.?
? Smaller training content library compared to KnowBe4.?
Verdict: If you want security awareness training tied to real-world threats, Proofpoint is a strong choice. It’s smarter than KnowBe4, but it lacks some of the breadth of training content.?
?
Final Recommendation: Which One Should You Pick??
Use Case? Best Choice?
Most Engaging & Gamified Training? ? Living Security?
Best Phishing Simulations & Compliance Training? ? KnowBe4?
Threat-Driven Training & Behavior Analytics? ? Proofpoint?
The right choice depends on what matters most to your organization. Want the most realistic phishing simulations? Go with KnowBe4. Need training based on real-time threat intelligence? Proofpoint is your answer. Looking for fun, immersive training that doesn’t suck? Living Security is a game-changer.?
What’s your experience with security awareness training? Drop a comment below! ???
References?
?
Security expert specializing in healthcare risk elimination
1 个月Great advice! Where did Infosec land? Ive had a great response to it with our end users.
High Beam IT Leader | Strategist & Architect | Information Security | People Focused | Smart, Simple, Effective Results
1 个月Very good read.
Cybersecurity Leader | Cloud & Risk Expert | Award-Winning Career Coach & Speaker | EdTech Founder | Advisory Board Member | Canada’s Top 100 Black Women to Watch
1 个月Security awareness training doesn’t have to be boring! The key is engagement when employees connect with the training, they retain more and apply it better. Gamification, phishing simulations, and real-world scenarios all serve different needs, but the best approach? A mix of all three!
Recruiter and PMP | Business & Strategy | Engineers | Telecom | Logistics | Custom Software | Gov Contracting | Full-time | Project | Contract-to-hire
1 个月My password is super sneaky because it's pa55word. See what i did?
Information Security (IAM/IGA) Analyst who lives in SailPoint and Microsoft Excel.
1 个月Love the breakdown - especially the focus on matching the product to use case. What are your thoughts on how one of the newer disruptors, Wizer, and how they fit into the mix? They seem priced to try to strategically get people to adapt their solution.