'Cut her mic' moment left me flabbergasted

'Cut her mic' moment left me flabbergasted


"Cut her mic."

No-one's ever said my microphone should be cut before, so when Dr Ben Carson suggested I should be shut up after I asked him if he thought the women accusing Donald Trump of sexual abuse were lying, I was a bit flabbergasted. It sounded almost Soviet. 

Let's be clear about what happened. I asked Dr Carson, a surrogate for Mr Trump, a simple yes/no question. He refused to answer. When I pushed him he asked not once but twice that the programme shut off my mic. All I wanted was an answer - what I got was a ridiculous demand for censorship. 

Replaying the tape I see it also looks rather bullying. In a conversation about sexual harassment a man asks a woman to be silenced for asking a question he doesn't want to answer. He may not have meant to, but Dr Carson gave a perfect, real-time example of exactly the kind of overbearing, condescending attitude a lot of women experience all too often and that the whole Donald Trump scandal has raised as a conversation here. 

'Common in the workplace'

But I'd be remiss if I didn't point out that this pattern is very familiar to women everywhere. In less crass and explicit ways, this happens in the workplace all the time, men who talk over women at meetings, who take credit for a woman's idea or dismiss their female colleagues as somehow too emotional. 

Amid the stunned reaction to Dr Carson's "cut her mic" demand another important thing he said has been slightly overlooked. Later in the our interview he said it didn't matter whether the women accusing Mr Trump were lying or not. I don't really know what he meant by that but it's clearly nonsense. If the women are all lying they deserve criticism, if they're not, they don't. How could it not matter? 

One upside of this miserable campaign season is that we are now talking about these important issues and I think men are getting a new insight into the inequality, big and small, that women suffer every day. 

My Twitter feed has been flooded with outraged messages from men and women. Joe Scarborough, the host of Morning Joe, called Dr Carson out in no uncertain terms and raised the issue of his call to silence my mic after the ad break. I'd like to thank them all. Wouldn't it be a strange thing if Mr Trump's candidacy ended up precipitating greater sexual equality not less.


How could Dr. Carson answer your slanted question? He was not a witness to any of the episodes Mr. Trump is being accused of. The only answer to your questions would have been conjecture. And that word (conjecture) very accurately describes the nature of MSNBC and other networks of your left wing ilk. We really do so terribly miss our news being reported based on facts and real news. Not subjects being asked for answers that can't be described as anything but personal opinion. I guess your kind of reporting can be done while the investigator/interrogator is sitting on one's ass while 'true news reporting' has to be pursued or sought out. True reporting is seeking out and delivering facts while your reporting garners nothing more than guesses and assumptions. tsk, tsk, tsk Oh, what I would give for the good-ole days....

Michael B.

Systems Administrator WINTEL (Business Applications) IRS

8 年

It's hard to hide that you're an Idiot when the camera is running. Only goes to prove that having multiple degrees, prestigious titles and prominent positions doesn't equate to real life intelligence ! Sad but like the old saying goes "it's best to remain silent" and be thought a fool, than open your mouth and remove All Doubt : ) Even sadder is that this man was a very well respected professional (Pioneering Medical Doctor/Surgeon) in the health care system. He should have stayed in his lane; by dabbling into politics he's made a complete fool of himself.

Steve W.

Assistant Professor Process Technology at College of the Mainland

8 年

This was another fine example of "ambush reporting" by Ms Kelly. The now quite common way of the long lost and dead art of actual reporting, as practiced by Anderson Cooper, all FOX reporters, and yourself. There is no decorum, no off limits, oh let me interrupt YOU and get my topic i want to make YOU look bad at and OMG then throw righteous indignation when you are treated as the adversary.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Katty Kay的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了