#100: Customer decision: Emotion or logic?
John Smibert
Best selling author - Helping you to transform the way you sell to grow revenue at higher margins, and drive better customer outcomes.
How do our customers make decisions? We have all seen those tick lists that some enterprise buyers use to evaluate suppliers. They assess proposals based on logic. But do they decide based on logic?
In this discussion, which is the 100th in the Talking Sales series, Cian McLoughlin shares a very significant finding from the thousands of ‘post decision’ reviews he has conducted with enterprise buyers.
His conclusion is that – even in large enterprise decisions – the emotional evaluation gets you the decision – not the logical.
He said his research confirms that even enterprise buyer “use the right brain, feeling part of their psyche to make a decision, and then they justify it with their left brain, with the rational, information, common sense approach”.
The key message that I got from listening to Cian is that no matter how good you, your company, and your product are; if you can’t relate on a human level, people are going to have trouble buying from you.
View or read the interview below to learn more. Cian discusses particular business case studies that reinforces this conclusion.
Cian McLoughlin is a guru in win/loss analysis, he’s a speaker, an author, and a leading advisor to the sales fraternity.
See more of the ‘TALKING SALES’ series here
Interview
John: Hello! I’ve got Cian McLoughlin with me again – welcome back, Cian!
Cian: Thanks, John – nice to be here!
John: Hey Cian, you do a lot of work in win/loss analysis, and you talk to customers all the time about how and why they made decisions, and you’ve learnt a lot from that and you’ve shared some of that in the past.
Cian: Yes.
John: We’ve just had an offline discussion, a little bit about right brain, left brain, etc. Can you share some of your findings in that area?
Cian: Yes, absolutely. When I sit down and talk to senior decision makers… Initially
when I started to do that, I had a sense they’d talk about a particular vendor, and
their product set and the price point, etc., and occasionally that gets mentioned, but it’s very rare that that actually is the deciding factor in many of these strategic decisions. Often what they talk about is the connection they felt with the salesperson or the sales team, and their ability to create credibility and authority. And when you drill down on that, it’s really, really interesting.
John: In what way?
Cian: What we tend to do is default to our standard pitch, and “Here’s our features and here’s our functions, and this is hopefully what you’ll find interesting, and this is how it relates to your problem,” but actually that doesn’t really have the ability to engage an audience. What we need to do is we need to start realising how people make decisions, and what we usually do is we use the right brain, feeling part of our psyche to make a decision, and then we justify it with the left brain, with the rational, information, common sense approach.
John: And that’s being human, isn’t it? We ‘re all like that. Some more than less, obviously.
Cian: Absolutely, yes. The interesting thing is that what we tend to do in the sales industry, for whatever reason, is we tend to try and appeal to the left brain, rational “Here’s the information, now you can make a decision,” but all that really does is tick a box, because invariably there might be four or five or six solutions that, broadly speaking, can do it, so then you’ve got an apples for apples comparison. Now the question becomes “What else have you got? Why would we engage with you?”
John: Have you got any case studies in mind where the customer has actually talked about how, probably not in those terms, but how these people appeal to my right brain versus left brain, etc.?
Cian: Yes, there’s been many, many instances where they say, “We liked them, we felt there was a strong connection. We got them, or they got us in fact; they spoke our language. etc.” What they’re really saying is, “This salesperson or these individuals came in and they spoke to us about what they were passionate about, what they believed in, what their vision was for our business or for the industry more broadly,” and it gave them something to connect with, and as a result of that it differentiated them from the other organisations they were competing with.
A really good example, I was sitting down with the key decision makers from a customer, and they talked about the fact that even though… they worked in the office, they were mostly a blue-collar workforce. One of the vendors had come in and said, “Okay, you’ve got a lot of people who are out there and they’re getting hot and wet and dusty, they’re out on the job,” so they went and found ruggedised iPad covers and they brought them in. They brought some and they said, “Could you see yourselves using this out on the job?” and gave it to the guys. It was just one little thing, but what it did was it spoke volumes about their understanding and the cultural fit, and the fact that they actually cared.
John: Right.
Cian: It was a huge… Even though it was such a small thing to do, it had a huge impact on the perception of them, and as a result they went and won a massive, massive piece of business.
John: When I look at all the really successful salespeople, they have a strong human element to them, and they really think about the other person, work out ways in which they can make them feel comfortable and feel enthused about what they’re doing and so on. I think it’s a very valid point.
Cian: Absolutely. I think with things like empathy and your EQ and active listening and the way you use stories to communicate your point, all of these things, which are maybe soft skills rather than hard sales skills, are incredibly important in terms of actually creating that level of connection.
John: I’d probably go so far as saying if you haven’t got that, you’re not going to sell very effectively, no matter how good you are, and your product and the value your product brings to the industry you’re selling to and so on; if you can’t relate on a human level, people are going to have trouble buying from you.
Cian: I couldn’t agree more.
John: Thank you very much, Cian – really appreciate your time!
Cian: Pleasure, John!
****************
More interviews with Cian McLoughlin:
- "What is win-loss analysis"
- "The value of win-loss reviews"
- "How to get customer buy-in to a win-loss review"
- "Customers say the great salespeople do this"
- "Strategies to retain and grow customer business"
- "Maintaining the human element in sales"
- "How Cian got 80 commitments from 300 emails"
***************
Your Invitation: I invite you to join the Strategic Selling group on LinkedIn where you can experience informative discussions with your peers and sales thought leaders on subjects like the one we have discussed here. I also invite you to subscribe to the Strategic Selling Resource Centre here.
Please Share: If you valued this article, please share via your Twitter, LinkedIn, Google+ and Facebook social media platforms. I encourage you to join the conversation or ask questions. So feel free to add a comment on this post – I promise to respond. Please follow my LinkedIn post page.
Senior Business Development Manager
8 年Nice message guys. The genie is out of the bottle. Storytelling is a skill that works and must be trained to make sure your sellers are more successful
Compassionate, detail-oriented home health consultant dedicated to providing patient-centered care, fostering compliance, and delivering innovative solutions for improved health outcomes.
8 年Great interview John Smibert with Cian Mcloughlin. Neil Rackham said 'People Do Not Buy From Salespeople Because They Understand Their Products, But Because They Felt The Salesperson Understood Their Problems.' If you as a seller can tap into their emotions and make them feel comfortable and enthused like Cian pointed out your engagement with that target becomes more personal. Today is about good storytelling, and taking them on a journey, the 'Buyers Journey' that is.
Sales and Business at Shiva Industries
8 年Useful post John Smibert. I agree with the thought. Relevancy of expectation is necessary to create while doing the story telling with any customer to sell the product.
Growth Focussed General Manager | Commercial and Marketing Strategy | Experienced Strategic and Commercial Leader | MBA | MAICD
8 年I like this post - because generally, decisions that are openly based on emotion are criticised. This ignores the fact that, for all our logic, decisions are taken by human beings, with their own perceptions, values, beliefs, and motivations.
Strategy Consultant
8 年Years ago I had a manager who would always say that people do business with people who think like they do and it's true, especially with new technology where you are introducing something with no history. You have to show benefit without loss of autonomy for the user. That means having the perspective of the user in mind. AI can parse faster but it can't (at least yet) asses user skills and emotional advantage. Stepping out of the box is a distinctly human characteristic. AI can benefit though with the qualification process.