Cursed By Language
Anuradha Ganesan
Teacher Training | Whole School Transformation | Curriculum Design
The other day, I was listening to a podcast where Shabana Azmi and Javed Akhtar were talking about the literary works of their respective fathers. In response to a question on what learnings from his father have influenced his work, Javed Akhtar quoted something his father the Late Jaan Nisar Akhtar said, that I am going to paraphrase - "Mushkil zubaan mein likhna aasaan hai, lekin asaan zubaan mein likhna, mushkil."
This line reminded me of a particularly prickly pet peeve (the alliteration is unintended) of mine - inaccessible language of academic research papers for research-unintelligent folks like me.
The opportunity in learning from academic papers is either lost to a paywall or to incomprehensible language. I am talking about the latter, though, I also don't understand why quality academic research is not available for free to people who should actually be putting it to use. Do you see the elitism in this endeavour? I strongly feel that research on pedagogy or #FLN, for example, needs to be easily accessible to teachers/facilitators of learning so they are able to critically analyse their own work and possibly even see the scope to innovate from learnings through reading research papers. If all readers of a piece of academic writing are not given the opportunity to understand it, it shouldn't be surprising that there is such disparity in ambition and achievement among educators.
领英推荐
Personally, I've had to often times read segments over and over again, read the referenced pieces of writing and other articles to even say I somewhat understand what the paper is trying to convey. While the abstract is supposed to convey an idea of what the paper is talking about, I've found the abstract, at times, assumes the reader to have a certain level of content-specific language proficiency.
While I am here ranting, I also understand this is unlikely to change anytime soon. I would like to know if there are others like me here who access academic papers only to be put off or be dejected in its incomprehensibility. How have you worked around it?
#accessandequity #makeresearchaccessible
Senior Corporate Counsel, India & South Asia - Juniper Networks
1 年I believe this is a very common yet less pointed-out reader's hurdle! I've particularly felt this while reading some of the legal research papers/articles, editorials, political pieces, etc.
Director, Sri Ethiraja Technologies
1 年Very true
A "Nobody" on a mission to increase "educated" youths in as many under-served communities and families as possible
1 年Profound thoughts!
Visiting Faculty (English) at SVKM's Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies (NMIMS), Bangalore(Bannerghata Campus) Teaching English Literature,Language for UG students
1 年So true! Abstract of a research paper itself is sometimes couched in heavy language. Wading through for laypersons is tough.
EdTech Products | Learning experience design
1 年Totally agree. Have experienced this frustration many a times in the past. The purpose and reach of the research gets lost in the complexity of the language. These days though we can use chatgpt to simplify it.