Current Pension Landscape: Examining the State of Pension Coverage in South Africa

Pension funds play a crucial role in providing social security for workers worldwide. However, many countries, particularly in the informal sector, struggle with low pension coverage. South Africa, like other developing nations, faces the challenge of providing pension coverage to informal sector workers. In this article, we will explore the current state of pension coverage in South Africa and the steps needed to address the issue.

Current State of Pension Coverage in South Africa

South Africa has a well-developed formal sector pension system. However, this coverage is limited to formal sector workers, leaving the majority of workers in the informal sector without any pension benefits. Not all workers are covered by formal pension plans, forcing them to rely on their own savings or the state's social grant system.

Informal sector workers face several challenges when it comes to saving for retirement. They often have irregular incomes, making it difficult to save consistently. Moreover, they lack access to financial services like banking and insurance, which hinders their ability to invest and protect their savings. Additionally, many informal workers lack financial literacy and fail to understand the importance of saving for retirement.

Adequacy of pension benefits is another crucial aspect that needs urgent attention. More work is required in this area to ensure that pension benefits are sufficient to meet the needs of retirees.

The South African Constitution: Section 27

Section 27 of the South African Constitution guarantees every person in the country the right to access healthcare services, sufficient food and water, and social security benefits. This section is particularly important for vulnerable groups such as the elderly, disabled, and children who may require additional support to meet their basic needs. To fulfil this duty, the government has established social protection programs, including grants for children, the elderly, and those with disabilities, to provide financial assistance to those in need.

The constitution also provides an opportunity for the private sector to aid and support the provision of retirement income as part of the social protection promise.

Where Are We?

South Africa boasts a thriving retirement savings industry and a robust regulatory system that ensures financial stability. However, certain challenges remain, such as insufficient benefits coverage, unclear costs, poor fund governance, and a large number of funds.

To address these challenges, a series of reforms were implemented between 2012 and 2019. These reforms aimed to encourage preservation, improve fund governance, promote annuitization at retirement, simplify the taxation of retirement contributions, encourage non-retirement saving through tax-free plans, review retirement product costs, and promote value-for-money retirement products.

It's important to acknowledge that reforming the retirement industry is an ongoing and complex process that requires strong leadership and collaboration among stakeholders. Political support and engagement from labor unions, industry, and retirement fund members are crucial for long-term success.

Notable Advances

Several notable advances have been made in improving the retirement system in South Africa:

• Default preservation regulation: Introduced in March 2019, this regulation encourages pre-retirement preservation.
• Employer liability: Employers failing to pay retirement contributions to a retirement fund can face criminal and personal liability.
• Trustee training: Trustees receive skills training through the FSCA’s trustee toolkit to enhance fund governance.
• Annuitization: The recent implementation of a provident fund annuitization requirement since March 2021 promotes annuitization at retirement.
• Simplified taxation: The taxation of retirement contributions has been simplified, with the same tax deduction applied across all funds since March 2016.
• Tax-Free Savings Accounts: Introduced in April 2015, these accounts promote non-retirement saving.
• Regulations for good value retirement products and services: Default investment portfolio and annuity strategy regulations were implemented in March 2019 to ensure value-for-money retirement offerings.

What's on SA National Treasury's Agenda?

The emergence of the Covid-19 pandemic has brought several important issues to the forefront of the South African National Treasury's agenda. These include sustainable finance, funding for infrastructure, early access to retirement savings for emergencies, and extending coverage to formal sector workers without retirement plans. Additionally, there is a need to establish some form of saving for workers in the informal sector and to consider whether traditional pension savings are suitable for low-income and informal workers. Defining who qualifies as informal workers is also an important consideration.

Consolidation: Addressing Regulatory Challenges

Supervising the large number of funds in the South African retirement industry poses a considerable regulatory challenge. Approximately 32% of funds have fewer than 100 members, while about 68% of active funds have fewer than 1,000 members. To address this issue, a policy proposal has been made to consolidate funds into a more manageable number. However, fund consolidation cannot be encouraged until governance issues are resolved. Questions remain regarding umbrella funds, such as member representation on Boards of Trustees, conflicts of interest, and barriers to switching between umbrella funds.

Coverage: Extending Retirement Plans

In South Africa, it is not mandatory for individuals to contribute to a retirement fund. The 2022 Q3 Labor Force Survey revealed that around 5.8 million employed individuals are not contributing to a retirement fund, highlighting the coverage gap. Extending coverage to the informal sector remains a challenge for retirement systems worldwide, as these systems are typically built around salaried or wage-based employees who can make regular contributions.

To address this, South Africa is considering the establishment of a mandatory national retirement fund that focuses on the needs of workers in the formal economy. Auto-enrollment, which has proven successful for salaried employees with a formal employer, is proposed for formally employed workers who are not contributing. The next step would be to extend coverage to the informal or vulnerable sector through a more voluntary system supported by incentives, FinTech solutions, and a default fund.

What About Adequacy?

The living wage in South Africa varies based on factors such as location, family size, and the cost of living. According to the Living Wage South Africa Campaign, the living wage for a single adult as of 2021 is approximately R6,784 per month, which translates to R81,408 per year. This estimate is based on the cost of essential goods and services needed for a decent standard of living, including food, housing, transport, healthcare, and education. It also includes a small amount for discretionary spending.

It's important to note that the living wage can vary due to local market conditions and personal circumstances. The living wage is often higher than the minimum wage. Many organizations and employers have voluntarily adopted the living wage to ensure their employees can afford a decent standard of living.

The Relationship Between Living Wage and Social Wage

Living wage and social wage are interconnected but distinct concepts that can impact each other. The living wage represents the income needed to afford basic necessities without relying on government assistance, primarily concerned with wages earned from employment. On the other hand, social wage refers to government-provided benefits and services that ensure access to basic necessities, regardless of income.

Living wage and social wage can be complementary in some cases. If a worker earns a living wage, they are less likely to require government assistance, reducing the demand for social wage programs. Conversely, if social wage programs are available to all, regardless of income, the living wage threshold can be lowered.

However, living wage and social wage can be in tension. If the living wage is set too high, employers may cut back on benefits or reduce their workforce, increasing the demand for social wage programs.

The Role of Private Pensions in Living and Social Wages

Private pensions play a vital role in retirement income security and can complement social wage programs. They provide additional retirement income beyond what is offered by government benefits, helping to reduce the risk of retirees falling into poverty or relying solely on government assistance.

However, not all workers have access to private pensions, and some may not save enough to fully fund their retirement. The availability and generosity of social wage programs can also vary, impacting the overall retirement income security of workers.

In summary, private pensions contribute to living and social wages by providing additional retirement income. However, they are just one part of a broader set of policies and programs needed to ensure a decent standard of living and a secure retirement for workers.

The Mercer CFA Retirement Index: Assessing Retirement Income Systems

The Mercer CFA Retirement Index is a global study that ranks retirement income systems based on their adequacy, sustainability, and integrity. While it does not specifically address living and social wages, it offers insights into the overall retirement income security of workers worldwide.

The adequacy component of the index measures the level of retirement income workers can expect from all sources, including pensions and personal savings. Sustainability assesses the long-term viability of retirement income systems, considering factors like demographics and government debt. Integrity examines the regulatory and governance framework of retirement income systems.

While the index does not directly address living and social wages, countries with higher scores generally provide greater retirement income security, which can contribute to overall economic stability for workers and retirees.

In conclusion, the current state of pension coverage for workers in South Africa is inadequate, particularly for those in the informal sector. Efforts are needed to extend coverage, address regulatory challenges, and improve retirement income adequacy. Furthermore, considering the relationship between living and social wages and the role of private pensions is essential for ensuring a decent standard of living and retirement income security for all workers.

#socialwage #livingwage #pensions #retirementreformsa

?