Curiosity and Critical Thinking: Essential Tools for Empowering English Learners and Historically Marginalized Students

When envisioning an ideal education system for the future, we often imagine one that prepares students for an increasingly complex and globalized world. In the quest to achieve this, education stakeholders sometimes resort to emphasizing rote learning and traditional interventions, particularly in the areas of mathematics and science. However, for English Learners (ELs) and other historically marginalized students, there's a growing consensus that the real game-changers are curiosity and critical thinking. These two qualities, when nurtured and integrated into teaching and learning, can bridge educational gaps and elevate learning experiences to unprecedented heights.

Understanding English Learners and Historically Marginalized Students

Before delving into the importance of curiosity and critical thinking, it's crucial to understand the challenges faced by ELs and historically marginalized students. ELs grapple with the dual challenge of mastering a new language while keeping up with content in other subject areas. Meanwhile, historically marginalized students often navigate structural barriers, racial or socio-economic biases, and limited resources.

In the face of these challenges, merely focusing on rote learning in subjects like mathematics and science doesn't suffice. Such an approach can even be detrimental, as it might sideline the broader skill sets these students need to succeed in the world. Additionally, rote learning can inadvertently promote a culture of memorization without understanding, which can hamper the cognitive and linguistic development of these students.

The Power of Curiosity

Albert Einstein once remarked, "I have no special talent. I am only passionately curious." Curiosity, an innate human trait, is the driving force behind exploration, discovery, and learning. For ELs and historically marginalized students, fostering curiosity can open doors to authentic and engaged learning.

One of the most challenging tasks for educators is motivating students, especially those who feel disconnected due to language or cultural barriers. Curiosity can bridge this gap. A learning environment that stimulates students' natural inquisitiveness can motivate them to explore topics, ask questions, and seek answers. Such an environment taps into their innate desire to understand the world around them.

For ELs, curiosity can accelerate language learning. When students are genuinely interested in a subject, they are more likely to engage with the material and internalize new vocabulary and structures. In this sense, curiosity becomes a tool for holistic language development, merging content learning with language acquisition.

The Role of Critical Thinking

While curiosity sets the stage for exploration, critical thinking equips students with the skills to navigate, analyze, and interpret the vast amounts of information that they encounter. For historically marginalized students and ELs, developing these skills is paramount.

Historically marginalized students often encounter narratives that sideline their histories, experiences, or cultures. Critical thinking enables them to challenge these dominant stories, fostering a deeper understanding of their identities and the complexities of the world, as they challenge dominant narratives.

The ability to think critically goes beyond the classroom. It empowers students to evaluate situations, consider multiple perspectives, and make informed decisions. For ELs, critical thinking combined with language skills can be particularly transformative, allowing them to navigate and thrive in new cultural and linguistic landscapes.

Beyond Rote Learning in Math and Science

While mathematics and science are vital disciplines, a narrow focus on rote learning in these areas can stifle the broader development of students. Real-world problems are multifaceted and cannot be solved through formulaic approaches alone. Instead, they demand a combination of curiosity to explore new avenues and critical thinking to evaluate and implement solutions. By over-emphasizing rote learning, we risk producing learners who can recite facts but may falter when faced with complex, real-world challenges.

Shaping the Future of Education

If we genuinely aim to level the playing field for English Learners and historically marginalized students, we need to prioritize curiosity and critical thinking in our educational strategies. This approach requires:

Inclusive Curriculum Design:

Curricula should reflect diverse histories, cultures, and perspectives, sparking the curiosity of all students and enabling them to see themselves as integral to the narrative of knowledge.

For example in an English class, instead of solely focusing on the Western canon, an English class can be designed to include literature from around the world. For instance, students can study novels like "Things Fall Apart" by Chinua Achebe (African literature), "One Hundred Years of Solitude" by Gabriel Garcia Marquez (Latin American literature), and "The God of Small Things" by Arundhati Roy (Indian literature) alongside Shakespeare and Jane Austen.

By exploring diverse voices, students not only gain a broader understanding of literary traditions but also see the richness and complexity of different cultures. Such a curriculum allows students from diverse backgrounds to find representation in the texts they study and fosters a greater appreciation of global perspectives among all students.

Pedagogical Shifts:

Teachers should be trained and encouraged to prioritize inquiry-based learning, fostering classroom environments where questions are celebrated, and critical discussions are the norm.

For example in Science class, instead of a traditional lecture-based approach to teaching science, a teacher can use inquiry-based projects. For instance, when studying ecosystems, students can be tasked with investigating a local pond or forest area. They would form their questions, such as "What types of organisms can be found in this habitat?" or "How does pollution impact the pond's ecosystem?"

Students can then conduct research, make observations, collect samples, and present their findings. This method encourages them to ask questions, seek answers actively, and engage in critical discussions with their peers, shifting the learning process from passive reception to active discovery.

Reimagining Assessment:

Traditional testing methods, which often favor rote memorization, should be re-evaluated. Alternative assessment forms, such as project-based learning and reflective writing, can provide a fuller picture of a student's ability to think critically and apply knowledge.

Traditionally, art classes might grade students based on a few major projects or exams. However, a more holistic approach would be a portfolio assessment. Throughout the course, students maintain a portfolio of their work, reflecting a range of skills, techniques, and personal growth.

At the end of the term, instead of a traditional exam, students present their portfolios, explaining their artistic choices, techniques they've mastered, and areas they wish to improve. This assessment method values continuous growth and self-reflection over the ability to perform on a single test. It provides a comprehensive view of the student's skills, creativity, and critical thinking applied over time.

In conclusion, while mathematics and science are undeniably important, an undue focus on rote learning can do a disservice to our students, particularly English Learners and those from historically marginalized communities. By valuing and nurturing curiosity and critical thinking, we not only create more engaged and empowered learners but also contribute to a more inclusive and equitable education system, ready to face the challenges of the 21st century.

Learn More about the Tools that School Teams Can Utilize to Strengthen Collaborative Learning and the Collective Efficacy of Teams to Tackle Recuring Challenges and Solve Problems Together with CREATE Solutions.