CSR is a Scam: Why Purpose-Driven Businesses Are the Only Future

Introduction:

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) has been touted as the moral backbone of the modern corporation, a way for companies to give back to society while generating profits. But let’s be clear: CSR is a scam. It’s a token gesture that allows corporations to continue harmful practices while painting a veneer of responsibility. If a company’s commitment to “doing good” is limited to a tiny, isolated CSR project, we must ask ourselves—what are they doing the other 99% of the time?

I’ve been grappling with this question for years, and I believe it’s time for businesses to evolve. The world doesn’t need more CSR checkboxes. What it desperately needs are purpose-driven enterprises that infuse every aspect of their operation with a commitment to create value for society, not just for shareholders. The truth is, future-proofing your business requires more than a well-crafted CSR report. It requires a purpose that drives every decision, every product, every interaction.

(Naveed Khawaja on stage at Smart Manufacturing Summit in an expert panel in Prague)

Full expert panel video available at NAKAdvisory - PurposeCast

CSR: A Convenient Cover-Up

Many corporations proudly flaunt their CSR programs as evidence of their commitment to social good. They roll out small projects—perhaps donating to charity, organizing a cleanup event, or sponsoring a community initiative. While these actions look good on paper, they are often mere cover-ups. If 1% of a company’s efforts are dedicated to CSR, what’s happening during the other 99% of the time?

That’s the dilemma we face: 99% of corporate actions don’t actually make the world a better place. In fact, many corporate operations actively harm it. CSR has become the feel-good band-aid that covers up deep-seated issues within companies—issues that, if not addressed, will harm not only society but the business itself in the long run.

The reality is that CSR is often a strategy for damage control, not meaningful change. Companies use it to distract stakeholders from the negative impact they have on the environment, workers, and communities. And while they continue to chase profits at any cost, their CSR projects attempt to smooth over the ethical cracks in their foundation. The question we must ask is: why should any company operate if it’s not actively contributing to a better world?

The Shift from CSR to Corporate Social Value (CSV)

Thankfully, the conversation is shifting from CSR to Corporate Social Value (CSV). This emerging concept suggests that companies should be driven by purpose—not as an afterthought but as part of their very DNA. It’s no longer enough to do good in small, isolated ways while continuing harmful practices elsewhere. The real challenge for businesses today is to make value creation integral to their core operations.

Naveed Khawaja put it bluntly during the Smart Manufacturing Summit in Prague: making money isn’t the problem; making money at any cost is. When corporations prioritize profits over purpose, they ultimately undermine their long-term viability. The companies that thrive in the future will be those that create products, services, and operations that add value to society without compromising the planet or the people on it.

This shift toward purpose requires leadership to look beyond short-term gains. It requires them to adopt a long-term vision that aligns with the interests of society. Leaders must ask themselves: what value is our company creating, and how are we making the world a better place?

Why Purpose-Driven Companies Will Outlast CSR-Driven Companies

1. Purpose is Proactive; CSR is Reactive

CSR tends to be reactive, a response to criticism or a method to prevent reputational damage. Purpose, on the other hand, is proactive. It requires embedding ethical principles and value creation into the very fabric of the company from day one. Purpose-driven companies anticipate societal challenges and build their businesses to address them—not as an afterthought but as a core mission.

2. Purpose is Deeply Rooted; CSR is Superficial

CSR initiatives often address symptoms of systemic problems rather than tackling the root causes. They are often created in isolation, detached from the broader strategy of the company. In contrast, purpose is holistic and deeply rooted in a company’s culture and operations. When businesses are purpose-driven, every decision—from product development to hiring practices—reflects a commitment to societal good. They don’t need to “market” their values because those values are inherent in everything they do.

3. Purpose is Holistic; CSR is Fragmented

Many businesses treat CSR as a side project—a compartmentalized initiative that doesn’t impact the day-to-day workings of the company. Purpose, however, is all-encompassing. It defines the very mission of the company, ensuring that every department, every employee, and every decision aligns with the company’s commitment to creating value for society. Purpose-driven businesses are transparent, consistent, and accountable in all their dealings, not just when it’s convenient.

The Business Case for Purpose

Shifting to a purpose-driven model is not just a moral imperative—it’s also a strategic one. Purpose-driven companies are future-proof because they are building resilient, sustainable businesses that meet the needs of today’s customers and tomorrow’s challenges. Here are three key reasons why purpose will drive the businesses of the future:

1. Customer Trust and Loyalty

In today’s world, customers are increasingly demanding transparency and authenticity. They want to engage with companies that share their values and make a real impact. Purpose-driven businesses foster deeper trust and loyalty, creating long-term relationships with their customers. In contrast, companies that rely on CSR initiatives often face backlash when their actual practices contradict their “responsible” image.

2. Engaged Employees

The most talented and passionate employees are no longer satisfied with simply working for a paycheck. They want to work for companies that align with their personal values. Purpose-driven organizations attract and retain top talent by creating a sense of shared mission and meaning. Employees who feel that their work has a larger impact are more engaged, more innovative, and more committed to the company’s success.

3. Resilience in the Face of Crisis

Purpose-driven companies are more resilient in times of crisis because they are built on strong ethical foundations. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we saw how companies with a clear purpose were able to pivot and adapt more quickly, addressing societal needs while protecting their business. Companies that are focused on short-term profits struggle to survive in such uncertain environments because they lack the flexibility and trust required to weather the storm.

Conclusion: CSR is Dead, Long Live Purpose

The age of CSR is over. It’s no longer acceptable for businesses to hide behind token gestures of social responsibility while continuing to harm the world around them. In today’s economy, businesses must go beyond surface-level initiatives and commit to being purpose-driven. Purpose is not a side project or a marketing tactic—it’s the very reason for a company’s existence.

To the leaders and decision-makers of the world: it’s time to rethink the role of business in society. Your legacy will not be defined by your CSR programs but by the genuine impact your company makes on the world.

Are you ready to lead with purpose?

Let us connect for follow-up conversations:

https://www.youtube.com/@nakadvisory

https://www.instagram.com/nakadvisory

https://www.tiktok.com/@nakadvisory

https://www.facebook.com/nakadvisory

https://www.x.com/nakadvisory