Crusades – a sub-optimal use case for countering recent violence in India and Bangladesh
Radhika Gopinatha dasa
Professor of Vedic Theology and Religious Studies: Present society needs a new paradigm of devotion to God.
A large section of population is worried about the recent religiously motivated violence in Bangladesh. The battle is as much ideological as it is physical. Hindu groups tout violence back against Muslims as the answer. However, the tales of Crusaders suggest otherwise.
“The Crusades were a series of military campaigns organised by Christian powers in order to retake Jerusalem and the Holy Land back from Muslim control. There would be eight officially sanctioned crusades between 1095 CE and 1270 CE and many more unofficial ones. Each campaign met with varying successes and failures but, ultimately, the wider objective of keeping Jerusalem and the Holy Land in Christian hands failed.” [1]
Goals of following key leaders and social groups:
“As the historian C. Tyerman points out in his God’s War, in many ways 1095 CE was the 1914 CE of the Middle Ages – a perfect storm of moral outrage, personal gain, institutionalised political and religious propaganda, peer pressure, societal expectations, and a thirst for adventure, which all combined to inspire people to leave their homes and embark on a perilous journey to a destination they knew nothing about and where they might meet glory and death or just death.” [1]
Responding to violence with Violence was the mistake the crusaders did and all it did was change the boundary lines of territories.?What did not happen was a change of heart in the Muslims to give up Jerusalem – a challenge that continues to this day with frequent violent clashes at the Temple of Jerusalem which is partially controlled by Waqf board.
Islamic Waqf runs the Temple Mount or Haram esh-Sharif since the Muslims under Saladin conquered it from the Latin (Christian) Kingdom of Jerusalem (Crusader State) in 1187. The Wakf objects to Israel having any authority on Temple Mount.
“It is estimated that waqf boards in India hold nearly 500,000 registered properties and tracts of land, making them among the top landowners in the country.” India will have the world’s largest Muslim population by 2050, according to a recent forecast by the Pew Research Center. [2]
The Muslim community which makes up around 13% of the population lags in employment and education since it primarily consists of converts from lower end of the society.?
Typically when the Muslim population reaches 50% the Shariah laws will be imposed with greater force and remaining population will be forced to follow the Shariah law.
Yet, the crusades remain a poor model to emulate as violence will engender more violence.?Better to cause a change of heart as give by Sri Caitanya Mahaprabu 540 years ago.
The timeline of the Great Crusades (1095-1291) follows [3]
Appendix:
The following is a list of events that occurred during the Great Crusades and covers the years 1095-1291.[1]
March 1095
Byzantium delegation asks for Urban's help against the Turks
November 27, 1095
Pope Urban II?preaches the First Crusade
1096
Fatimids retake Jerusalem from Seldjuks
spring,summer 1096
massacres of Jews
spring 1096
first wave (People's Crusade) leaves; 3 armies don't make it past Hungary
August 1, 1096
Peter the Hermit and Walter Sansavoir reach Constantinople
August 15, 1096
official start of First Crusade as set by?Pope Urban II
October 6, 1096
armies under Peter and Walter destroyed at Nicaea by Kilij Arslan
Fall 1096
leaders (and armies) of the second wave (official First Crusade) arrive at staggered times at Constantinople. Alexius I Comnenus asks for and receives oaths of fealty and promises to return lands formerly under Byzantine control
April 1097
crusaders cross the Bosporus
early June 1097
crusaders arrive at Nicaea, Kilij Arslan is absent, fighting Danishmend
June 19, 1097
Nicaea surrenders to Byzantium (not the crusaders)
June 26-28, 1097
crusaders head into Asia Minor
July 1, 1097
Turks under Kilij Arslan unsuccessfully attack the crusaders at Dorlyaeum
October 21, 1097
crusaders reach Antioch, which is ruled by Yaghi-Suyan
early February 1098
Muslim relief force under Kerbogha (Karbuqa) of Mosul heading to Antioch
February 6, 1098
Baldwin reaches Edessa (al-Ruha to Arabs) whose prince is Thoros
March 9, 1098
Thoros killed in riot
March 10, 1098
Baldwin takes control of Edessa. Start of the first Latin settlement in the East
June 2-3, 1098
Firuz, a garrison captain of Edessa, lets crusaders into city; Yaghi-Suyan flees; crusaders take city
June 5, 1098
Muslim army under Kerbogha arrives and besieges the crusaders in Antioch
June 14, 1098
crusaders believe they have found the Holy Lance
June 28, 1098
crusaders attack besiegers and win; they then decide to wait out the summer before continuing
August 1, 1098
Adhémar of Le Puy dies, exacerbating crusaders' leadership problems
mid-November 1098
armies of Raymond of St. Gilles and Robert of Flanders arrive at Ma'arat en Nu'man (rank-and-file force the march)
December 11-2, 1098
Ma'arat en Nu'man falls to the crusaders
1098 (sometime)
crusaders practice cannibalism at Ma'arra
January 13, 1099
rank-and-file force Raymond to continue to?Jerusalem
February/March 1099
rank-and-file at Antioch force continuance to Jerusalem
February 14, 1099
crusaders start to besiege 'Arqah
May 13, 1099
crusaders give up on siege of 'Arqah and continue to Jerusalem
June 6, 1099
Tancred seizes Bethelham
June 7, 1099
most of the crusaders arrive at Jerusalem
July 8, 1099
penitential procession of crusaders around Jerusalem
July 15, 1099
crusaders seize and sack Jerusalem
July 22, 1099
Godfrey elected ruler of settlement at Jerusalem
July 19, 1099
Pope Urban II dies, never hearing news of capture of Jerusalem
August 11-12, 1099
crusaders defeat Egyptian army at Ashdod
1099
al-Harawi of Damascus leads group of refugees to Baghdad to protest lack of action by leaders
1100
Baldwin becomes the first king of Jerusalem
summer 1100
Danishmend captures Bohemund
November 15, 1100
Pope Paschal II preaches crusade; threatens deserters and those with unfulfilled crusade vows with excommunication
1101
next wave of crusaders defeated in Asia Minor
1104
Baldwin takes Acre
1104
Muslims defeat Franks at Harran, stopping (momentarily at least) their eastward drive
1108
two coalitions, both of Franks and Muslims, fight near Tel Bashir
1109
Tripoli falls to the crusaders after 2000 days of siege
1110
Beirut and Saida seized by crusaders
1111
riot in Baghdad organized by Ibn al-Khashab (Aleppo's qadi) to try to get help against the Franks
1112
Muslims prevent Franks from seizing Tyre
1113
Order of St. John (the Hospitallers) starts
spring 1115
Muslims and Franks in Syria together fight Muhammad Ibn Malikshah, Seldjuk sultan
1119
Franks defeated at Sarmada by Ilghazi of Aleppo
1120
Order of the Knights Templar begins
July 1124
Franks seize Tyre and so occupy the coast to Ascalon
1125
in Beirut, peasants revolt
1125
Ibn al-Khashab killed by member(s) of the Assassins
1127
Zangi becomes ruler of Mosul
1128
Frankish attempt to seize Damascus fails
1128
Zangi gets control of Aleppo
1131
nobles revolt in the Latin kingdom of Jerusalem (the first such revolt)
1135
Zangi unsuccessful in attempt to take Damascus
1137
King Fulk of Jerusalem captured by Zangi and released
1139
Zangi besieges Damascus
1140
Damascus and Jerusalem ally against Zangi
1144
Zangi seizes Edessa, ending the first (of four) crusader states in the mideast
领英推荐
1146
Zangi murdered (reportedly by a slave), his son Nur al-Din inherits Aleppo
1147-1149
the Second Crusade, includes crusades in Spain, the eastern border of Germany as well as the middle east
1147
crusaders in Spain take Lisbon
1148
crusaders under Conrad of Germany and Louis VII of France besiege Damascus, giving up after Nur al-Din arrives at the request of Damascus
1154
Nur al-Din gets Damascus, unifying the parts of Syria that are Muslim
1163-1169
Nur al-Din's general Shirkuh fights for control of Egypt for Nur al-Din
1169
Shirkuh gets control of Egypt, becomes vizier, then dies within two months; he is succeeded by Saladin, his nephew
1170
Nur al-Din gets control of Mosul upon brother's death
1171
Saladin declares Fatimid control of Egypt is over and becomes sole ruler; start of Ayyubid dynasty; increasing tension between Nur al-Din and Saladin
1174
Nur al-Din dies, power struggle ensues for control of his son
1174
Saladin seizes Damascus
1183
Saladin seizes Aleppo, reuniting Egypt and Syria
1185
Saladin officially controls Egypt and Damascus, Aleppo and Mosul
July 4, 1187
Saladin defeats armies of the Frankish states at the Battle of Hattin
October 2, 1187
Saladin retakes Jerusalem and (about the same time) most of the land the Franks had controlled, leaving the Franks only Tyre, Tripoli, and Antioch
1189-1192
Third Crusade, major Franks were Richard I of England, Philip II of France, and Frederick I (the Holy Roman Emperor)
June 1190
Frederick I dies crossing the river Goksu
summer 1191
Richard and Philip arrive in the mideast, besiege Acre
July 1191
Acre falls to Richard and Philip, who then decide who will rule Jerusalem (between Guy and Conrad), Philip then leaves and Richard seizes Arsuf and Jaffa, refortifies Ascalon
September 2, 1192
Richard and Saladin sign a treaty, ending their fighting
October 9, 1192
Richard leaves the mideast
1193
Saladin dies, several years of civil war follow, until his brother al-Adil, takes control
spring 1197
Frederick I's son, Henry VI goes on crusade
September 28, 1197
Henry VI dies
July 1, 1198
Henry VI's nobles reach a treaty with Muslims and leave
1198
Order of Teutonic Knights begins (Acre is their main base)
1202-1204
Fourth Crusade
1202
some of the crusaders seize Zara from the king of Hungary, a fellow crusader, for the Venetians to earn fare
July 17, 1203
crusaders take Constantinople, put Alexius IV on the throne
late January 1204
Murzuphlus seizes throne and tries to expel crusaders
April 12, 1204
crusaders seize and sack Constantinople, found Latin Empire out of Byzantine lands; a government-in-exile formed
1209-1229
Albigensian crusade in southern France against Cathar heretics
1212
Children's Crusade
1213
Pope Innocent III begins planning the Fifth Crusade
1215
imposition of a crusade tax (on Church estates)
July 16, 1216
Innocent III dies, planning continued by successor, Pope Honorius III
1217-1229
Fifth Crusade, consists of various attacks on Egypt
1217-1218
Andrew II of Hungary tries for Acre
1219-1221
crusade in Egypt led by Cardinal Pelagius; he seized Damietta and tried to take Cairo but was defeated by al-Kamil, Egypt's sultan
1227
Genghis Khan dies; ensuing wars for succession lessen Mongol threat for a time
1228-1229
Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II, while under papal interdict, crusades in Egypt; al-Kamil gives him Jerusalem under a treaty; Jerusalem then under interdict
1219
Francis of Assisi fails to convert al-Kamil, sultan of Egypt
1230
Teutonic Knights start attacking Prussia
1235
Byzantines have retaken Asia Minor
1236
Ferdinand III of Castile begins attack on Cordova
1238
army of Aragon takes Valencia
1239-1241
Theobald of Champage and Richard of Cornwall lead a small crusade
1244
Franks lose Jerusalem for the final time
1245
Pope Innocent IV sends missionaries to Mongols; other negotiations follow
1247
Louis IX plans crusade; Frederick keeps al-Kamil's son, Ayyub, informed of plans
1248-1254
Sixth Crusade
1248-1250
Louis IX of France invades Egypt; he seizes Damietta, but is defeated and captured at the Mansurah; released for ransom (and Damietta)
1248-1250
end of Ayyubid dynasty, Mamluks now control Egypt
by 1251
M?ngke, grandson of Genghis Khan, controls Mongols
February 1258
Mongols under Hülegü (Genghis Khan's grandson) take Baghdad, kill the last 'Abbasid caliph; the population is massacred
December 1259
Qutuz becomes leader of Egypt in coup
January 1260
Mongols under Hülegü take Aleppo
March 1, 1260
Mongols under Hülegü take Damascus
1260
M?ngke dies; Hülegü returns to fight for succession
September 3, 1260
battle of 'Ayn Jalut: Mamluks under Qutuz defeat Mongols
September 8, 1260
Mamluks take Damascus
October 23, 1260
Baybars kills Qutuz and becomes sultan; he controls Cairo without a fight but there is some conflict
July 25, 1261
Byzantines recapture Constantinople, end of Latin Empire
1265
Hülegü dies
May 18, 1268
Baybars seizes Antioch (formerly allied to Mongols)
1268
Baybars seizes Jaffa
1270
Seventh Crusade: Louis IX attacks Tunis
August 25, 1270
Louis IX dies near Tunis
1277
Baybars is poisoned and dies; Qalawun becomes sultan
April 26 or 27, 1289
Qalawun, the Mamluk sultan, retakes Tripoli from Franks
November 1290
Qalawun dies; his son Khalil assumes power
June 17, 1291
Khalil retakes Acre, ending what we are defining as the Great Crusades; crusaders fall back to Cyprus
References: