A Critical Perspective on the ‘Dark Triad’ Traits in Leadership: Balancing Influence with Humanity

As we watch events that unfold across the world and the suffering that follows, I find myself wondering how we choose our leaders. My PhD on leadership in uncertainty clarified that difficult times mean many of us are attracted to the confidence displayed by leaders who live with psychological disorders described as the ‘Dark Triad’. This article aims to create awareness of those disorders and their effects.

Research highlights how individuals with Dark Triad traits—Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and Psychopathy—employ a variety of influence tactics in social interactions. These findings, as illustrated in the study “A protean approach to social influence: Dark Triad personalities and social influence tactics” (Jonason, P.K. and Webster G.D., 2012), provide insightful strategies for adaptability in leadership. But they also raise ethical concerns.

As someone deeply invested in leadership during uncertain times and committed to the principles of wisdom and humanity, I find it crucial to address these concerns in our discussion of leadership dynamics.

The Tactics of Dark Triad Personalities in Leadership

The thrust of the research paper referenced above is reflected in the term ‘protean’ itself and in its meaning of ‘tending or being able to change frequently or easily’. The paper introduces us to how individuals endowed with Dark Triad traits—Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and Psychopathy—navigate social interactions by employing a wide range of manipulative tactics. The study identifies the inherent adaptability of these individuals in altering their methods of influence to avoid recognition of the behaviours for what they are, and to maximise their success in various interpersonal scenarios. Click here for the full paper.

Key findings from the study include the following insights into these behaviours.

• Diversity of Tactics: Individuals with high levels of Dark Triad traits utilise an extensive array of influence tactics. This range of tactics allows them to adapt to different social contexts and interactions, making their manipulative efforts less predictable and more effective.
• Contextual Adaptability: The research highlights that these personalities do not rely on a single strategy but modify their approach based on the target and situation. This protean strategy helps them manoeuvre social dynamics adeptly, often sidestepping social repercussions.
• Tactical Efficacy: The research highlights that these personalities do not rely on a single strategy but modify their approach based on the target and situation. This protean strategy helps them manoeuvre social dynamics adeptly, often sidestepping social repercussions.

Robustness Across Scenarios: Despite varying their tactics, the core approach of these individuals remains consistent – using whatever means necessary to achieve their desired outcomes. This indicates a sophisticated understanding of social dynamics and a calculated approach to social influence.

The Relationship between Performance and the Dark Triad

In recent studies on the Dark Triad traits several nuanced findings have been reported which might be of interest when considering the dynamics within high-performance relationships.

Subdimensions of Dark Triad Traits: Scholarship suggests that these personality traits are more complex than previously thought, with each trait containing multiple dimensions that can influence behaviour differently. For instance, narcissism includes elements like authority and acclaim-seeking, which might impact leadership styles, while Machiavellianism includes traits like cynicism and manipulation, influencing how interpersonal strategies are deployed in competitive environments

Impact on Motivation and Performance: It’s noted that Dark Triad traits can impact motivation and work behaviour. For instance, traits like Machiavellianism and narcissism can drive individuals towards achievement and power, potentially beneficial in roles requiring assertiveness and strategic manoeuvring. However, these traits are also linked to competitive and manipulative behaviours, which might undermine teamwork and organisational cohesion.

Role in Leadership and Firm Performance: While often viewed negatively, certain aspects of Dark Triad traits are described as advantageous in specific contexts, such as corporate leadership or entrepreneurial environments. Narcissism, for example, has been linked to higher levels of perceived leadership effectiveness and can drive performance when aligned with a firm’s goals. My view is that it is important to also recognise that these traits can lead to negative workplace dynamics and may only be beneficial under certain conditions, such as intense competitive rivalry or specific organisational cultures.

Thus, while Dark Triad traits can offer some advantages in high-performance settings by driving ambition and strategic behaviour, they also come with risks that can impact team dynamics and overall organisational health.

Understanding these nuances can help structure better leadership development programs and team management strategies to mitigate the weaknesses and adverse outcomes associated with these traits.

Ethical Implications of Dark Triad Traits?

1. Lack of Empathy and Its Impact on Team Cohesion.

While Dark Triad traits can offer a strategic advantage in adaptability and manipulation, they are inconsistent with empathy. This deficit can lead to a toxic work environment, undermining trust and cooperation among team members. Leaders should foster an atmosphere where empathy is valued as a means to enhance understanding and support within the team, promoting a healthier, more sustainable work environment.

2. Short-Term Gains vs. Long-Term Sustainability.

The manipulative tactics associated with the Dark Triad traits might yield immediate results, but they can jeopardise long-term organisational goals. Sustainable leadership requires building relationships based on trust and mutual respect, not transient manipulation. Leaders must consider the long-term impact of their influence tactics on their organisation’s reputation and employee well-being.

3. Risks of a High-Pressure Environment.

The high-stress environments that often appeal to those with Dark Triad traits can lead to significant employee burnout and turnover. It is essential for leaders to recognize these risks and strive to balance high performance with a supportive work culture that prioritises the well-being of all employees.

Countering the Influence of Dark Triad Influences - Incorporating Wisdom and Humanity in Leadership.

Promote Ethical Leadership

Leaders need to be vigilant in their self-awareness and ethical responsibilities. Training programs focused on ethical leadership can help in recognizing and curbing manipulative behaviours, guiding leaders to use their influence positively.

Build a Culture of Integrity

Organisational cultures that emphasise integrity and transparency can counteract the influence of the Dark Triad. Encouraging open communication and ethical behaviour from the top down serves to reinforce these values across the organisation.

Encourage Diversity in Leadership Styles

Diverse leadership styles can mitigate the impact of Dark Triad traits by incorporating a broader range of perspectives and approaches, including those emphasising collaboration, empathy and emotional intelligence

Final Thoughts

While the adaptability and tactical acumen of Dark Triad personalities can be seen as advantageous in certain leadership scenarios, it is crucial to critically assess these traits from a moral and long-term perspective.

True leadership excellence comes from the ability to inspire and sustain a thriving organisational culture, rooted in ethical practices and human-centric values.

As we navigate the complexities of leadership in uncertain times, my hope is that we can all learn to see more clearly when influence is wielded wisely and compassionately, ensuring our leadership practices leave a positive, lasting impact on our organisations and the individuals within them.

Read paper: Leadership in Uncertainty

References

Jonason, P. K., & Webster, G. D. (2012). A protean approach to social influence: Dark Triad personalities and social influence tactics. Personality and Individual Differences, 52(4), 521-526.

Truhan, T. E., Wilson, P., M?ttus, R., & Papageorgiou, K. A. (2021). The many faces of dark personalities: An examination of the Dark Triad structure using psychometric network analysis. Personality and Individual Differences, 171, 110502.

LeBreton, J. M., Shiverdecker, L. K., & Grimaldi, E. M. (2018). The dark triad and workplace behavior. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 5, 387-414.

Haar, J., & de Jong, K. (2023). Is the dark triad always detrimental to firm performance? Testing different performance outcomes and the moderating effects of competitive rivalry. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1061698.

Subscribe to the Newsletter | Book a Call | Download Buddha in Pinstripe