Creating Abundance Through a Community of Value Creators
Curt Carlson, Ph.D.
Professor of Practice, Northeastern University and Distinguished Executive in Residence, WPI
Ignite employee engagement, foster a culture of empowerment, and enhance employee meaning by relentlessly learning and improving to maximize value for all stakeholders
I. The Unmet Need
Purpose:?Peter Drucker famously said, "The purpose of a company is to create and keep a customer," highlighting that value creation is the primary function of an enterprise and a responsibility of all professionals, whether their customers are external or internal.
Value creation is a profoundly human activity. It requires empathy, creativity, and a deep understanding of human needs and desires. It also demands hard work, dedication, and the resilience to overcome imposing challenges and setbacks. To achieve this purpose, organizations must provide critical value-creation skills, processes, and support that foster value creation at every level.
Many organizations struggle to fully engage employees and create a culture where everyone feels empowered to contribute their best work. This leads to untapped potential, missed opportunities, and a lack of fulfillment and meaning for both individuals and the organization.
Value creation and innovation are best achieved when people are fully engaged and empowered. Engagement is the starting point for learning and wanting to improve—the core activity of value creation. Empowerment provides individuals with the autonomy, resources, skills, and support they need to contribute their unique talents and perspectives to the process.
Therefore, engaging and empowering all employees to achieve maximum innovative success is critical. ?This post establishes the framework for achieving this objective: a Community of ?Value Creators (CVC).? The Innovation for Impact (i4i) value creation methodology sets the framework for achieving CVC [1].
Performance:? Creating sustainable enterprises is a formidable challenge. No company lasts forever. Indeed, the ten-year survival rate of a typical company is less than 50%, as captured in Figure 1. For technical companies, it is only 29%.
Gallup studies have shown that roughly a third of employees are highly engaged, a third are engaged, and a third are actively disengaged [2]. Actively disengaged employees often work against the firm. ?A remarkable example is after Elon Musk bought Twitter, he reduced the staff by 80% and performance improved.?
In the many hundreds of i4i value-creation workshops we have held with global companies, typically, less than 25% of their initiatives have any value. These companies reach this conclusion; we give them the missing framework so they can decide which of their initiatives have value. University R&D and innovation programs are almost always worse. These poor results suggest rethinking how we form and manage value creation in our enterprises.
Technology:? We are in the Age of AI. Moore's iconic exponential curve of computer speed at the same cost continues. Since 1900, there has been a 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 times improvement in computation per dollar. Remarkably, as predicted by Ray Kurzweil, we are seeing an accelerating exponential [3]. Jenson Huang, CEO of Nvidia, believes computer performance will be improved by 2-3 times every year – a hyper Moore's Law as shown in Figure 2. To survive, companies must adapt faster.
Unlimited Opportunities:? We have daunting problems, but we also have unprecedented opportunities.? We are in a time of potential unprecedented abundance fueled by the pace of innovation, including the rapid advance of AI. Technological advancements are exponentially democratizing access to information, education, and new opportunities.
The Internet and mobile devices connect billions globally, fostering collaboration and knowledge sharing. Biotechnological breakthroughs are leading to novel treatments and increasing lifespans. Gene therapy is real.? Renewable energy technologies are becoming increasingly affordable, promising a cleaner and more sustainable future.
From artificial intelligence to personalized medicine, innovations are revolutionizing industries and creating solutions to global challenges. Modular nuclear reactors offer safer and more efficient energy production. 3D printing is transforming manufacturing, enabling customized and on-demand production. Precision agriculture and gene editing are improving crop yields and food security.
SpaceX and other private companies are driving space exploration and commercialization. Furthermore, advancements in robotics and automation are streamlining processes across industries, increasing productivity and efficiency. Soon we will have autonomous driving cars that "refuse to collide." These and countless other innovations offer the potential for a more abundant and equitable future for all.
The Challenge of Getting Started: Creating something truly innovative within a typical enterprise is often like navigating a complex maze. It's a journey sparked by curiosity, leading you down a winding path of information gathering and conversations. You talk to everyone, seeking diverse perspectives and insights, often starting with a potential problem and a desire for a better solution.
Unfortunately, many people in large companies rarely venture outside their comfort zones to gather the required ideas and test them in the real world. Visionaries like the late Steve Jobs stand out because they actively engaged with the external world, constantly seeking new information and challenging conventional thinking. Today, Elon Musk is the most compelling example of this, pushing the boundaries of innovation across multiple industries.
The unmet need in most companies is mitigating the challenges that hinder this already challenging value-creation process. That is an objective of CVC.
Flow: In The Psychology of Optimal Experience,?Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi explored the concept of "flow," a state of deep engagement where time seems to dissolve and productivity soars. My colleagues Hunter Hasting and Mark Beliczky are writing a book on how flow can be a powerful mental model for improving how companies are designed and function [2].
Hasting and Beliczky envision a company where all employees and functions operate analogously to a person in flow. Each employee becomes fully motivated and engaged in end-user activities that provide the most significant new value. Consider, for example, ?a customer service representative proactively identifying and resolving a recurring issue that has been frustrating customers, even if it falls outside their typical responsibilities.
Fully engaged employees, unimpeded by barriers, demonstrate significantly enhanced performance. CVC embraces this aspirational goal.? Fostering a state of flow through CVC can unlock unprecedented levels of value creation for all stakeholders. This ambitious goal requires new methods and mental models, but the potential rewards are immense.
A Mental Model:?CVC?is a mindset and mental model that amplifies performance when understood and effectively practiced by all employees, In many ways, it can be viewed as including a more memorable and comprehensive mental model for Theory of Constraints (TOC), with other critical elements added, such as the requirement for a value proposition, as illustrated by the NABC Action Plan framework from i4i.
Not a Design:?CVC does not specify the design of an enterprise or its detailed management practices. Every enterprise addresses different opportunities and challenges in its market ecosystem.?Instead, it represents an enterprise committed to continuous value creation for its customers and stakeholders. CVC?provides a mental model to inspire managers and employees to embrace more productive human values, methods, processes, and behaviors. Regardless of how the many ingredients described here are assembled, the aspirational objective is to make the desired value creation results "inevitable."
Engagement, Empowerment, and Meaning:?Ultimately,?CVC?is about creating an adaptable and responsive organization that delivers the highest sustainable value to all stakeholders, first to end-users and then to employees, partners, and investors alike. It does this by engaging, empowering, and inspiring its employees to make a significant, positive impact. A contribution that provides meaning. Critically, CVC gives them the skills and supports the human values required for success.
By embracing the principles of?CVC and constantly seeking ways to create value, eliminate barriers, improve, and foster a culture that values the best human values, learning, and adaptation, companies and their employees can unlock their full potential and thrive in today's dynamic business landscape. A critical benefit is it provides employees with essential life skills in the Age of AI and with greater professional meaning.
II. Key Characteristics of CVC
Core values:
Meaning and Purpose
Human Values
Core practices:
Relentless Pursuit of Value:?This pursuit goes beyond mere intent. It's about embedding value creation into the very DNA of the organization, driving every decision, process, and action. It's a commitment to constantly seeking new and better ways to serve customers and stakeholders, relentlessly pushing the boundaries of what's possible. As noted, the mental model of CVC is to make the innovative results desired "inevitable."
Top Down: Bottom Up: A CVC enterprise develops the most efficient and effective combination of top-down and bottom-up approaches to achieve its purpose by maximizing customer value.
Minimal Friction:?This goes beyond simply removing obvious obstacles. It's about proactively identifying and eliminating any points of resistance in the value stream, whether physical, procedural, organizational, or cultural. This is also the main point of the Theory of Constraints (TOC).
Rapid Feedback Loops:?Fast feedback isn't just about speed; it's about quality and integration. It's about creating systems where feedback is gathered continuously, analyzed effectively, and used to drive immediate action.
Ecosystem Understanding: Staying informed about competitor activities and industry trends allows organizations to anticipate potential disruptions and adapt their strategies accordingly to maintain or increase value creation. Market tnowledge is a constantly changing entity that fuels successful companies by enabling informed decisions, driving innovation, and fostering operational efficiency. Innovation is achieved through a mix of creative ideas, diverse perspectives, and a culture that encourages experimentation and risk-taking, all built upon a foundation of market knowledge. It empowers businesses to understand their customers, optimize processes, and adapt to change, ultimately leading to sustainable growth.
Continuous Improvement:?This is the engine powering CVC. It's a mindset of constant learning and adaptation, where every process, product, and interaction is seen as an opportunity for creating additional value, whether external or internal.
Risk Mitigation: CVC enterprises are aggressive risk mitigators; not reckless risk takers. Removing risk fast and early at lost cost increases value and avoids costly mistakes.
Resource Allocation: This principle emphasizes empowerment and accountability by giving employees control over the resources they need to complete their tasks. This can reduce bureaucracy, improve engagement, and streamline decision-making, leading to improved value creation. This does not mean all actions are appropriate or allowed. There are serious expectations of performance and constraints.
III. Business Models
A Framework for Success:?A company's business model is the blueprint for how it creates, delivers, and captures end-user and stakeholder value. It fundamentally shapes the enterprie's potential for?value creation.
Companies aspire to deliver superior products through their design, quality, prestige, service, cost, and convenience. They simultaneously want to have superior business models, as illustrated in Figure 3 The “star” in the figure is the ideal goal.?
Value-compounding business models are often exemplars of CVC. They offer superior products and, with their direct customer relationships, exponential network effects, and data-driven optimization, companies like Amazon, Google, and Apple exemplify high-value creation models. These companies create powerful systems for both creating, capturing, and building value, leading to compounding returns and market dominance. AI will make them even more valuable because it will amplying their ability to interact in real time with their customers.?
However, achieving true?CVC?requires more than just an effective business model. Internal operations must be aligned to support the seamless creation and delivery of value. Because the market ecosystem constantly changes, the end-user needs, specific tasks, and the networks formed with employees, partners, and end-users to address specific tasks, must also continuously change. SRI International's Value Creation Forums, where multiple teams presented their NABC Action Plans every few weeks, are a great example of how to facilitate this near real-time adaptability to ensure continuous alignment.
To effectively navigate change within such a dynamic environment, an effective balance must be made in your value propositions for end-users and stakeholders. Recognize that perfection is elusive, and instead leverage the 80/20 Pareto Principle to quickly identify the 20% of efforts that generate 80% of the desired results. Focus on these high-impact actions to achieve effective compromises and drive significant progress.
Low-Value Creation Models: These business models often struggle to generate sustainable profits, lack pricing power, and are vulnerable to disruption. They involve:
领英推荐
High-Value Creation Models: These models are designed to maximize sustainable value creation and delivery. They often involve:
Companies that have high-value business models include:
Examples: While a strong business model is essential, internal operations must be aligned to support?value creation.
Morning Star: Morning Star's distinguishing feature is establishing a strong understanding between all partners—including employees, suppliers, and customers—regarding the building blocks and behaviors for creating and delivering on trusted contracts. This eliminates a major barrier to efficiency caused by frequent changes in partner and supplier contracts.
SRI International: SRI's distinguishing feature implemented under CEO Curtis Carlson (1998-2014) is its highly efficient and effective value creation process, "i4i." Grounded in the scientific method, the i4i process emphasizes continuous learning and improvement based on the best learning science findings. This approach profoundly reduced the time and cost of value creation, enabling SRI to achieve breakthroughs with its partners with innovations such as HDTV, Intuitive Surgical, Nuance Communications, and Siri, now on the iPhone.
Nvidia and Tesla: Both Nvidia and Tesla are pushing the boundaries of technology with compelling offerings, but their long-term success hinges on building sustainable, exponentially more valuable ecosystems around their core products.
IV. Evaluating Value
Knowledge:?An important?value creation?metric is the quality of knowledge that moves throughout the company. It is knowledge that successfully supports ongoing functions and provides the feedstock for the development of new impactful innovations. Having employees understand and focus on actionable knowledge helps to identify more valuable missing knowledge while simultaneously eliminating noise and misinformation.
Knowledge is dynamic. It is subjective and always changing within its specific context. Some knowledge lasts indefinitely (e.g., Newton's laws), and other knowledge, at least in the original context, is transitory (e.g., pet rocks). Major innovations almost always create surprising, sustainable new knowledge.
CVC transcends mere efficiency. It's about creating a motivating, dynamic, responsive enterprise system where value creation moves seamlessly from concept to customer, like a river carrying resources effortlessly to the ocean while adapting to its surroundings.
A CVC enterprise focused on?value creation?operates with agility, constantly learning and adapting to deliver increasing value. These results involve streamlining processes, fostering rapid feedback loops, and cultivating a culture of continuous improvement. The goal is to optimize the creation of valuable knowledge within the enterprise, eliminating noise, misinformation, and barriers that impede progress.
Evaluating:? In a?CVC?enterprise, knowledge is a living asset that needs to be nurtured and leveraged. Because of the constantly changing market ecosystem, knowledge is a dynamic, subjective, constantly changing entity depending on the context. These factors require a system for evaluating and prioritizing knowledge based on its potential to create value.
Having a concise, memorable framework such as this is one of the most critical elements required for achieving?CVC. If you can’t measure the primary output for success, you literally can’t systematically know what you are doing.
The NABC Action Plan framework shown above, effectively illustrates a core feature of CVC enterprises. It strikes a balance between completeness and conciseness, providing the essential elements for informed decision-making without excessive complexity.
A shorter description would omit crucial factors, while a longer one could hinder agility due to an overabundance of interacting elements. This version emphasizes the importance of the NABC framework in the context of CVC and highlights the balance it achieves between providing sufficient detail and maintaining usability.
V. Tools and Methods
AI:? AI is a powerful tool for amplifying enterprise performance. It will be a fundamental element of the design and operation of?CVC?enterprises. It will reconfigure a CVC enterprise’s value creation networks in near real-time. It will be especially effective for today's dominant companies with exponential, networked business models. AI systems will become "trusted partners" with end-users, adjusting to their needs and suggesting new offerings.
Methods:? Here's how specific tools and methodologies can enhance?value creation:
Of the methods mentioned, only i4i has a robust and practical framework for the value proposition. That, in addition to its 3-Laws for value creation, sets a foundation for systematic success. If any of the 3-Laws is missing, systematic success rapidly declines and can go to zero. They are:
The 3-Laws, as part of the i4i methodology, are not the only way to incorporate these essential elements for innovation. However, if these elements are not present in some form, innovative success will likely be episodic or non-existent.
VI. Quantifying Value Creation
Measuring?value creation?requires identifying metrics that reflect the efficiency and effectiveness of the value stream. Examples include:
VI. Barriers to Value Creation
Obstacles to?value creation?can arise from various sources. Examples include:
VII. Company Culture
Culture:?An enterprise's "culture" is the sum of its mindsets, mental models, purpose, human values, societal norms, and practices. A company culture that encourages collaboration, empowerment, learning, trust, and integrity is essential for fostering a?CVC?enterprise.
A CVC enterprise provides purpose and meaning to employee's professional life in part through the commitment to real achievement, a fundamental human need. The attributes and values required don't happen by chance or a CEO telling everyone to collaborate better without providing the skills and support needed to assure it happens.
A CVC?enterprise delivers on its promises and commitments. It does this by embracing fundamental learnings from team science, systems thinking, behavioral science, active learning, Theory of Constraints (TOC), and Innovation for Impact (i4i) to achieve these objectives. They are all based on core human values.
A CVC company culture includes.
Innovation:?The methods used and understood must include:
The i4i and Amazon methods provide successful examples.
Teams to Enterprise:?A CVC enterprise?can start with and be achieved in individual teams. Indeed, when first being introduced, it is often best to start with early adopters who demonstrate superior performance so as to then attract more followers.
However, the most profound performance improvements occur when?CVC?is achieved across the enterprise. The alignment of a few core but critical concepts can be a huge amplifier of performance. For example, when Carlson was CEO at SRI, everyone understood and used NABC Action Plan value propositions for all activities. Everyone, from the security guards to the CEOs of SRI's new companies, knew that all presentations for others started with the end-user's unmet needs. SRI was likely the only company where that was true. That one concept was transformative and allowed SRI, with its other i4i practices, to systematically create multiple billion-dollar companies.
VIII. CVC: Peak Performance Through Optimized Value Creation
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, characterized by profound technological advancements and the rise of AI, companies face immense pressure to innovate and adapt. Traditional approaches to innovation often fall short, with many initiatives failing to deliver lasting end-user and market value.
CVC?in a business context involves creating a dynamic and responsive system where value moves seamlessly from concept to customer, driven by engaged employees and fueled by actionable knowledge. This requires minimizing friction, fostering rapid feedback loops, and cultivating a culture of continuous improvement.
Strong business models, like those of Amazon, Google, and Apple, serve as engines of?value creation?by facilitating direct customer relationships, leveraging network effects, and utilizing data-driven optimization. However, achieving true?CVC?necessitates aligning internal operations with the business model. This involves fostering a collaborative and empowering culture that embraces systems thinking, behavioral science, and active learning.
Tools like Agile, Theory of Constraints (TOC), and SRI's Innovation for Impact (i4i) model can further enhance?CVC?by streamlining processes, identifying bottlenecks, and promoting a shared understanding of CVC and how to evaluate it. These tools must be adapted to the specific purpose of the enterprise.
Ultimately,?CVC?is about creating an adaptable and responsive organization that delivers the highest sustainable value to all stakeholders. By fostering a culture that values learning, innovation, and customer-centricity, companies can unlock their full potential and thrive in the dynamic marketplace.
This requires a commitment to continuous improvement, the elimination of barriers to?CVC, and the cultivation of a shared understanding of CVC throughout the organization. By embracing the principles of?CVC, companies can navigate the complexities of the modern business environment and achieve sustainable success.
References
Appreciation
Thanks to these folks for all the great ideas and suggestions:
Mark Béliczky, Hunter Hastings, Stephen Denning, Darrell Rigby, Annika Steiber, Michael Lurie, Andrew Holm, Doug Kirkpatrick, Joey Spooner, Heidi Musser, Hugo Lourenco, Hendrik Esser, Carlota Perez, Stephen Forte, Rita McGrath.
Not perfect but always awesome
2 个月A culture of innovation and value creation is a key to employee rentention. Thank you for pushing this topic!
Strategic Business Development | Advanced Technologies | Start-up Mentor | AI Tech | Board Member | Angel Investor | I enjoy making lasting business partnerships & relationships
2 个月Another great article Curt. Thank you for continuing to carry the value creation torch!