Cracking the Code: How to Improve Performance Without the Fear Factor

“As soon as the fear of punishment is removed, a person will perform poorly. Therefore, the fear of punishment must be present to ensure effective performance.”

Ah, what a delightfully Machiavellian sentiment. Isn’t it so?

It is like the workplace equivalent of “Do it or else!” I came across this quote while pondering the statement above, and it struck a chord. Though I could not pinpoint the author (perhaps they are secretly an evil genius in a darkened room somewhere), this idea has haunted my thoughts and led me to write this article.

Let us buckle up to discover the wild and wacky world of workplace punishment, from its organized forms to its chaotic cousins.

The Machinery of Punishment

When you join a new company or work under new leadership, it is like stepping into a new world with its own set of rules. Managers lay out the company’s priorities, department objectives, and, most importantly, your scope of work and deliverables. It is not a democratic process where every employee gets a gold star regardless of their performance.

Truly, performance management is a bit more… selective.

In any performance-driven culture, the best performers get glossy rewards, exceptional achievements are celebrated with gusto, and, well, the laggards are given less. It is a system of meritocracy with a sprinkling of what could be deemed “punishment.” But this is not some dystopian nightmare; it is just a harsh reality of the performance management principle.

Organized vs. Unorganized Punishment

Let us break it down. There’s organized punishment, which is neatly bundled into performance policies like the Performance Improvement Plan (PIP). And then there’s unorganized punishment, which is more like a rogue wave of frustration from managers who seem to have misplaced their compassion.

Organized Punishment

Organized punishment is akin to a well-structured curriculum. It is designed to improve performance and is generally part of a formal process.

For instance, a Performance Improvement Plan is supposed to be a roadmap to help employees bounce back from their struggles, be it due to health issues, family problems, personal trauma or could be due to some competency gap. The goal here is to offer a helping hand rather than wielding a sledgehammer.

Managers today, with the talent shortage looming over them, have learned to mellow down a bit. They are less likely to unleash their fury and are more inclined to give constructive feedback. It is all about understanding that not every dip in performance is a personal failure; sometimes life throws curveballs.

Unorganized Punishment

Now, let us talk about unorganized punishment. This is where things get a little filthy.

Unorganized punishment is not part of any formal policy—it is more like a wild card that managers play when they are feeling particularly grumpy or disheartened.

I have seen some truly creative (read: horrifying) methods of unorganized punishment I have seen earlier and even now. Let me entertain you with a few:

The Hall of Shame: Once, a manager at a popular insurance company decided to make a public spectacle out of underperformers. He created a “Board of Shame” listing the names of the bottom performers. Talk about killing someone’s self-esteem—this was like throwing them into the pit of despair with a bullseye painted on their backs.

The Sunday Work Torture: A senior manager at a nationalized bank had a unique approach to performance management. When his team fell short of their savings bank account targets, he insisted that they work through Sundays and holidays. Nothing says "motivational leadership" like robbing people of their weekends.

The Screaming Session: Another gem comes from the world of banking, where a senior banker used video calls to scream at branch managers for not meeting targets. Imagine being on the receiving end of a yelling spree while trying to pretend you are working from a beach paradise. Not exactly the motivational boost they were hoping for!

So, how do we direct the performance management without resorting to these extreme measures? Here are some actionable steps to consider:

1. Reframe the Performance Improvement Plan: Think of the PIP as a chance for redemption rather than a punishment. It is a golden opportunity for employees to rise from the ashes, so make sure they know that the organization is behind them, ready to provide support and resources to help them succeed. Each PEP should be customized to the individual. Every PIP should be as customized like a luxury vacation package. Some folks might need additional training, while others could benefit from flexible work schedules (because balancing life’s chaos is a skill, too). Break down expectations into bite-sized milestones that are realistic and achievable—no one likes staring at a mountain when they are barely out of bed. This approach keeps them from feeling overwhelmed and ensures steady progress without the tears.
2. Address the Root Causes of Poor Performance: Sometimes poor performance is simply due to a lack of proper training or unclear job expectations. Ensure that each employee has access to the learning resources and tools they need to succeed. And let us not forget the ever-feared burnout monster. Overworked employees will burn out faster than a cheap light bulb. Review their workloads regularly and, when needed, redistribute tasks. No one likes feeling like they are drowning in work. Give them a life raft! Yes, make sure they know how their work fits into the bigger picture. Role confusion is like driving without GPS—frustrating and likely to end up in a ditch.
3. Offer Coaching and Mentoring Support: Every employee needs a cheerleader. Coaching and mentoring can provide guidance, feedback, and encouragement, helping employees navigate their challenges and improve their performance. Sometimes, employees can learn better from peers in a non-judgmental environment, and hence introducing peer coaching could be beneficial where employees can share skills and best practices.
4. Provide Counselling Support: Life can be tough, and sometimes employees are dealing with personal issues that affect their work. Offering counselling support can be a game-changer. And a little compassion goes a long way in boosting morale. Encourage managers to regularly check in with their teams—not just to talk about work, but to genuinely ask, “How are you really doing?” These one-on-one conversations can help employees open about what is weighing them down, giving managers a chance to offer support (or just be a good listener). And remember, all counselling support should be handled discreetly to ensure employees feel comfortable using the resources without worrying they will become the office gossip.
5. Implement Regular, Constructive Feedback Loops: Do not wait for quarterly or annual reviews to address issues. Implement regular, informal check-ins to give feedback and gauge progress. In each feedback session, acknowledge the employee’s strengths and achievements before discussing areas for improvement. It is easier for people to hear constructive criticism when it is paired with recognition of what they are doing well. Make sure feedback is a conversation, not a monologue. It should be more “Let’s brainstorm together,” and less “I’ll tell you what you did wrong, and you take notes.”

A Balanced Approach to Performance Management

While the notion of using fear of punishment to drive performance might sound like a page from a Machiavellian playbook, it is not the most effective or humane approach. Organized punishment, when implemented with care and support, can be a constructive part of performance management. However, unorganized punishment is like trying to fix a delicate watch with a jackhammer—clumsy, destructive, and sure to ruin everything in the process

By focusing on supportive measures like Performance Enhancement Plans, coaching, and counselling, managers can foster a more positive and productive work environment. After all, employees are not robots programmed to always perform flawlessly. They are human beings, juggling their professional and personal lives, and a little understanding can turn the tide from performance slumps to triumphs.

?

?