The COVID Crisis: Now We Need Great Marketing
We are entering a dangerous time in the COVID crisis, and we need a marketing mindset to navigate the coming months without massive conflict.
Over a month ago I predicted that the world would shut down in a bid to slow the spread of the Corona virus. In the absence of a convincing marketing message, government leaders would have to use force to close everything. It was not a particularly bold prediction, but it was accurate.
So here is my next prediction: there is conflict ahead if we aren't careful. We need a plan and some great marketing to navigate the next, more treacherous, phase. In some ways, shutting down was the easy part. The virus was clearly a problem, it was essential to bend the curve, and the only way to do that was a shut down.
The next decision will not be so easy. To understand why, let's look at our options.
Option 1: Wait for the Vaccine
One thought is that we need to remain locked down until we have a good vaccine, so no restaurants, no in-person school, no sports, no events, no elective medical procedures.
This might take a year, but more likely it will take two years.
Is this a feasible option? No.
It is technically possible, but not realistic. The longer people are locked down, the more problems we will face: economic disarray, poverty, food-chain disruptions and mental health issues.
Option 2: Declare Victory and Resume Life
Another thought is that we should declare victory and get back at it, so we should immediately open the schools, go back to work, reopen the restaurants, reschedule concerts.
Is this a feasible option? No.
The problem is that reopening activity will certainly lead to a significant spread of the virus and this will put us right back where we were a month ago. The healthcare system would again be in crisis. It isn’t a remotely feasible option.
Option 3: The Middle Ground
So the obvious answer is that we need a middle ground. We need some way to resume life even as the virus is part of our daily activity. The problem is that it is not at all clear what this life looks like, or what trade-offs come with it.
People talk about testing, but that isn’t the answer, since many people with the virus are asymptomatic. We aren’t anywhere near being able to test everyone every day. That would be great but it won't happen soon.
Consider universities, for example. It is possible to reopen universities in the fall, but then what steps are required when a case develops? I teach at Northwestern University in Evanston. If a student, staff member or professor comes down with the virus, what should happen? Does Northwestern shut down? Is so, well, the school cannot open at all for in-person learning. The cost and disruption that would come with that likely scenario is not acceptable. Or is there a way to manage with a certain number of cases?
The Risk: Conflict
The risk is profound conflict. We are already seeing protests. These will only grow as people grow frustrated with the restrictions. People will soon start flaunting the rules. Will local governments start hauling individuals who walk in a park off to jail? That is a scary prospect indeed.
One thing is very clear: everyone cares a lot about this, and the intensity will ramp up over time as people get more desperate. History tells us that bad things happen when people are under severe economic pressure.
The Need: A Plan, a Benefit, Great Marketing
We desperately need business, government, religious and, yes, marketing leaders together to develop a middle ground, a plan that will let life proceed with a reasonable amount of cost. People need to see the path forward. There needs to be hope and a benefit after all the sacrifice.
We need to lay out life 2.0 - perhaps a life with more space, less touching, more masks, more cleaning, and a certain amount of illness from the virus. We can't evacuate the world every time a case pops up.
If people understand the benefit and the trade-offs, they will embrace a different life. That is where marketing has to come in. We need a protocol, a name and a benefit.
Sustained and severe restrictions will only lead to a growing crisis. Without seeing a benefit, people will lose hope and lash out. It is time to find a path forward, and use great marketing to guide and encourage people.
A version of this article was first published on my blog, www.timcalkins.com
Program Director at Northwestern Medicine
4 年I appreciate your clear and rational summary of the current situation and opinion on how to move forward. There is so much confusion and conflicting information across the country that encourages an "us versus them" mentality. We are all in this together, and need clear marketing and strong leadership to help everyone understand that.
LJA Consulting: Brand & Service Positioning | Product Innovation | Private Brand Leadership, Strategy & Execution | Retail Category Strategy & Planning | Joint Business Planning | Organizational Design
4 年Tim, Well said!! As always you bring a disciplined and clear approach on how best to move forward. I completely agree it will take great marketing to support the life 2.0 plan......the challenge will be having a solid strategy and plan that the marketing can support. Personally I've never been a hugger, so I'm up for Calkins "life 2.0". Stay well, AR
Thanks Tim. So agree with “Let life proceed with a reasonable amount of cost.” Truth! Isn’t this what life was, is and forever will be?
Sr. Factory Engineering Manager - Nestlé
4 年Great article , Professor. Nice way to summarize the scenarios with a clear head . Hopefully people’s emotions will be under enough control to allow society to get back to some sense of normalcy. I hope all is well H
Organizational Strategic Communications Consulting and Crisis Planning at Tap Your Potential & PIVOT Crisis PR.
4 年I completely agree with your blog, Professor Calkins. Sadly, I believe the reason we do not/cannot have a national rallying point around which we can gather and move forward is that we have no strong national leadership. Dr. Anthony Fauci is the closest we have to a nationally respected figure and it's unlikely he would be allowed to head such an effort. Very sad.