Counterintuitive Marketing: Why Breaking the Rules Can Boost Your Success

Marketing often seems like a game of tried-and-true formulas, but sometimes, success comes from flipping conventional wisdom on its head. In this episode of the Your Digital Marketing Coach podcast, I welcomed Nancy Harhut , behavioral science expert and author of Using Behavioral Science in Marketing, to discuss how counterintuitive strategies can not only grab attention but also drive customer engagement and loyalty.

The Science Behind Counterintuitive Marketing

At its core, counterintuitive marketing works because human behavior isn’t always rational. Nancy emphasizes that people often make decisions based on instinctive responses rather than careful thought. Behavioral science identifies these decision-making shortcuts, allowing marketers to ethically nudge customers toward desired actions. Let’s explore some standout techniques that may surprise you.

Why Saying "You Don’t Have to Buy" Can Double Sales

One of Nancy's key points is the “But You Are Free” (BYAF) technique. This approach involves asking customers to take an action while explicitly reminding them they’re under no obligation.

For example:

“We’d love for you to subscribe—but it’s totally up to you!”

Studies show this technique taps into our autonomy bias—our desire to feel in control—making people more likely to say yes. A University of Bordeaux study demonstrated that including a phrase like “but you are free to accept or refuse” increased compliance rates dramatically, even quadrupling results in some cases.

Embracing Imperfection with the Pratfall Effect

Another surprising tactic is the pratfall effect, which suggests that admitting a small flaw can make your brand more relatable and likable. Customers trust brands that show a touch of humanity.

Take Heinz ketchup as an example. Instead of ignoring the fact that their ketchup takes time to pour, they embraced it in ads with the song “Anticipation.” This transparency not only entertained customers but also reinforced their connection to the product.

The Power of Limits

Want to boost sales? Try imposing a limit. Behavioral science shows that scarcity drives action. For instance, when a supermarket placed a "Limit 12 cans" sign on discounted Campbell’s soup, customers bought more than twice as many cans compared to when no limit was mentioned.

This technique leverages FOMO (fear of missing out) and anchors customers to higher purchasing levels, even if they don’t need the maximum amount.

Using Strategic Surprise to Boost Engagement

Nancy shared an intriguing example of strategic surprise: deliberately misspelling a word or using an unexpected phrase. One campaign used the phrase “It’s been a lawn winter” (instead of “long winter”) in an email from a patio department, cleverly tying the “mistake” to their product offering.

Why does this work? Surprise increases emotional engagement and makes your message more memorable. Just ensure the “error” ties back to your product or message for a positive payoff.

Applying Counterintuitive Strategies in Your Campaigns

To make these tactics work for your brand, start by understanding your audience’s behavior. Whether it’s limiting product availability, embracing imperfections, or employing the BYAF technique, the goal is to align your message with how customers instinctively make decisions.

Final Thoughts

Counterintuitive marketing isn’t about throwing caution to the wind—it’s about leveraging behavioral insights to create authentic, effective campaigns. By understanding the psychology behind decision-making, you can break the rules in ways that captivate and convert.

For more actionable strategies, check out Nancy Harhut’s book, Using Behavioral Science in Marketing. And remember: Sometimes, the best way to stand out is to do what everyone else thinks you shouldn’t.

Here is a video of the entire interview if you want to check it out:

Thanks for reading all of the way to the bottom! I am beginning to create content specific for the LinkedIn community in my newsletter, but if you want to discover more of my comment, please check out my blog at https://nealschaffer.com/new-blog-posts/ where I am currently publishing 4 posts a week. You might also be interested in checking out other episodes of my Your Digital Marketing Coach podcast. Finally, I do help businesses and professionals in a variety of ways, so if you are interested, please click through on whatever interests you:

• Speak at Your Next Event
• Fractional CMO Marketing Consulting and Coaching
• Digital First Group Coaching Community
• Buy Maximizing LinkedIn for Business Growth
• Buy Digital Threads