A Conversation with a Jewish Patriot

In my travels, I encountered a highly patriotic Jewish individual. We had an interesting conversation that was worth sharing. He asked me what I thought about the concept of a Militia. While my answer was spot on and more to the point than below, I am articulating the sentiment I expressed for those reading this post.

Purpose of a Militia

The constitutional purpose of a militia, as outlined in the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, was to provide for the security of a free state. The framers believed that a well-regulated militia was essential for defending against external threats and potential tyranny from a standing army.

Militias were seen as a means for citizens to participate in their defense and maintain a balance of power between the government and the people. The idea was rooted in the colonial experience, where local militias were crucial in resisting British rule. Thus, the militia was intended to serve both a practical military function and safeguard individual liberties.

Does the Media tell the whole truth on anything?

In ethical journalism, the media is expected to strive for accuracy and transparency, but the "whole truth" can be complex. Journalists should aim to present facts fairly and comprehensively, considering multiple perspectives. However, practical constraints like space, time, and the need for clarity can limit how much information is shared.

Ethical journalism also involves accountability and correction of errors. While complete disclosure might not always be possible, a commitment to truthfulness and integrity is fundamental. The goal is to provide the public with the information necessary to make informed decisions.

Republicans have been bamboozled using their own beliefs against them.

If you, as a citizen, had to take up arms against a tyrannical government that murdered your people, bombed their homes, etc, all in the name of national security, would that be a reason to fight back as a militia?

Using any patriotic definition, would Hamas not be the ideal militia for the injustices we are seeing in Israel?

If you were in a nation that pretended to care about all faiths equally that is comprised of Christians, Muslims, and Jews, should you automatically accept the word of the media on the conflict?

Israel has killed at least 640 Palestinians in north Gaza since it laid siege to the area 17 days ago, 33 of them since dawn on Monday, medical sources have told Al Jazeera.

“Genocide is unfolding in northern Gaza in its clearest form, in full view of the world. The occupation army is forcing residents of northern Gaza to either flee under bombardment or face killing in what resembles a circle of certain death,” it said, adding that the failure of the international community to stop this “war of extermination has emboldened Israel to continue its deadly campaign.

Meanwhile, Palestinian women forced to flee north Gaza said the Israeli army is separating and arresting dozens of men at checkpoints.

People filling water containers were targeted and killed. In Beit Lahiya, a school shelter was also attacked, with several killed and dozens wounded.

Do you dare ask why other countries in the United Nations are not supporting Israel and Genocide?

Do you dare ask yourself what biases or racist or religious beliefs you hold and are indoctrinated into that color your perception of world events?

According to the treaties in the 50's, Israel was to turn over Gaza to the Palestinian people but never kept up the agreement. What should we all think?