Consumer Banking Under Siege: the Digital Transformation Secrets of Trailblazer Banks

Consumer Banking Under Siege: the Digital Transformation Secrets of Trailblazer Banks

The banking scenery is rapidly changing. Consumer banks, the gurus of risk management and pillars of the global economy, are now urgently called to reinvent themselves. The pandemic has disrupted their retail branch operations, and shifted the preferences of their customers towards remote service models and digital products. The rise of blockchain and AI, coupled with cybersecurity concerns challenge banks' understanding of what digital-readiness entails. Retailers like Walmart, Big Tech providers like Amazon, and a wide array of innovative FinTechs are gaining momentum in the market. This puts enormous amounts of pressure on banks' profitability, who are feeling the heat to digitally transform themselves.

Cover of the Consumer Banking under Siege Study. Shows a woman holding a mobile phone and a credit card, looking at the credit card, almost ready to do a purchase or payment.

However, not all banks find themselves in a dire state. We just completed a?major industry study?in consumer banking as part of our Global Workforce Intelligence Project, (the entire research collection is exclusively available to the Josh Bersin Company?Corporate Members) and we uncovered a breed of highly transformed banks who are thriving in the market.

We call them Trailblazers and, at a time when the majority of the industry is being pressured, they seem to be accelerating their lead. What sets them apart? Well, it's not what one might initially think...

The commonly held belief is that the future of banking relies a lot on technology and analytics. This is, of course, true. But only to an extent. We looked at the top 200 global banks and identified what sets apart Trailblazers, and it's not better analytics or access to superior technology. It's the uniqueness of their talent strategies, organizational models, and culture.

Trailblazer banks are able to offer the high-touch digital experiences their customers are seeking (and secure their profitability!) because they approach technology, product development, operations, culture and skills differently. Traditional banks aren't challenged to access great technology; they are challenged by the fact that their talent cannot keep up.

We actually ran the numbers on this, examining the skills, talent and organizational structures of more than 200 banks globally. We tapped into the rich database of the Josh Bersin Company around people practices and strategies, combined with million data points from Eightfold's Talent Intelligence Platform around job roles and skills. We also conducted deep-dive interviews with more than twenty of the largest players in the global consumer banking industry to capture their stories. One thing became evident: the digital transformation of banks is a talent challenge.

Most consumer banks are 3-5 years away from providing the digital products and services customers need, because their are short on critical forward-looking tech skills. Meanwhile, their existing skills are either stable or losing prevalence (declining) in time.

A table of skill categories and use cases that shows that banks are not ready to provide the digital products and services customers want and need, because their talent cannot keep up. Their skills maturity is low.
Source: Consumer Banking Under Siege: Addressing the Digital Capability Gap, Josh Bersin and Stella Ioannidou / The Josh Bersin Company, 2022

Meanwhile, Trailblazer banks have vastly different roles, job titles, skills, and distribution of labor compared to their traditional peers. With 1.3x more people in the IT and digital-related areas of the bank, and 1.6x less people in middle and back-office areas, they place more people where they need them to create better digital services and products for their clients.

A chart comparing the talent mix of FinTechs, Traditional and Trailblazer banks that shows that Trailblazer banks have more people in IT operations and less people in middle and back-office areas of the organization compared to Traditional banks.
Source: Consumer Banking Under Siege: Addressing the Digital Capability Gap, Josh Bersin and Stella Ioannidou / The Josh Bersin Company, 2022

Trailblazer Banks also place a lot of emphasis on the type of roles people occupy; not just where they sit in the organization. They have 3.7x less people in middle/back-office and front-line service roles, and 2.3x more people in transformation roles than traditional banks. They don't just focus on building great products. They also run leaner teams and are deeply concerned about how to transform the operating model and change the organization looking ahead.

Skills are top of mind for all CHROs in banking right now. Trailblazer Banks actively prioritize forward-looking digital and technology skills. It's the skills that help them build more modern user interfaces, capture and understand their client base better, and swiftly pivot operations to address those needs.

A chart comparing the talent mix of FinTechs, Traditional and Trailblazer banks that shows that Trailblazer banks have more forward-looking tech skills compared to traditional banks.
Source: Consumer Banking Under Siege: Addressing the Digital Capability Gap, Josh Bersin and Stella Ioannidou / The Josh Bersin Company, 2022

However critical, the talent mix, tech roles and skills are not the only thing that sets apart Trailblazer Banks from their traditional counterparts.?Trailblazer banks build enduring employee-focused organizations because they adopt key people practices that forge irresistible cultures. They approach the organization as a system, and apply a multitude of strategies that, in unison, help them effectively address any digital capability shortage.

A 4-quadrant chart that shows the Josh Bersin Company's Systemic People Solutions Framework (the 4Rs), outlining people strategies in Recruitment, Reskilling, Redesign and Retention.
Source: Consumer Banking Under Siege: Addressing the Digital Capability Gap, Josh Bersin and Stella Ioannidou / The Josh Bersin Company, 2022

Trailblazer banks invest in building talent organically and sharpen their reskilling muscle. They adopt agile ways of working. They offer flexibility and expand benefits beyond pay and bonuses. And all these strengthen their employer brand and capability to attract and retain the talent and skills required. Trailblazer banks play the long game.

In our rich collection of resources created for this study, you will find:

  • A comprehensive analysis designed for CHROs and CEOs outlining the strategies and the practices that work in Consumer Banking right now and help Trailblazer banks effectively address the industry's most pressing business and talent-related challenges.
  • In-depth talent mix, role and skills benchmarking guides which lay out the next step in the digital transformation journey of consumer banks, and
  • A series of case studies from identified Trailblazer Banks, which will help you see how these strategies and practices are implemented.

And here is a brief video outlining top findings, key results and best practices included in the study.

If you’d like more information about this study, please contact us or download our?GWI Banking Infographic. By joining the Josh Bersin Company?corporate membership program?we will walk you through the findings and you can?benchmark your organization against the Trailblazers. And if you are wondering about Josh Bersin 's key takeaway points from our study, please feel free to check out his latest article below.

For more information on the Global Workforce Intelligence Program,?download our whitepaper?on the changing world of industries, jobs, and organizations.

Allison Mairena (Sproul)

Global VP of People @ NewGlobe | SHRM-SCP

2 年

Way to go, Stella!

Maria B.

Legal scholar experienced in the environmental & corporate law | Legal Consultant | Legal literacy & soft skills trainer & Facilitator | Certified Coach | Mentor

2 年

Congratulations Stella Ioannidou! Well done! ?? ??

Vivian Fatourou

Legal Executive at Cerved Property Services | The Legal 500 GC Powerlister | Mediator | DE&I Practitioner | Co-leader at Lean in Network Greece (Athens)

2 年

Excellence is in the details ! Bravo Stella Ioannidou great work ????????

John Gusiff

Chief Experience Officer | CX Strategy | Brand Loyalty | Customer JTBD | Experience Design | makeit toolit | Behavioral Science | GenAI |

2 年

Fascinating study Stella Ioannidou, cc'ing a few people in my network Richard Coughlin Cassandra Henry Allison Paine Landers Andy Netzel, CCXP Florin Arghirescu Jared Gebers Phil Leininger Scott Mulloy who will want to read the report.

Josh Bersin

Global Industry Analyst, I study all aspects of HR, business leadership, corporate L&D, recruiting, and HR technology. ?

2 年

This research is the pinnacle of our work over the last 25 years. We studied jobs, skills, roles, career data across 200+ banking and financial service organizations to identify the talent and skills embedded in the "Trailblazer" companies. I believe this research will be a global benchmark for HR and talent strategies in banking for years to come. Please contact us if you'd like to see the details and possibly benchmark your company against this data set. Stella Ioannidou thank you for such groundbreaking work.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Stella Ioannidou的更多文章

  • 2020: A Year Of Purpose

    2020: A Year Of Purpose

    Only a couple of weeks before this year bids us farewell, and in synchronicity with tomorrow’s Solstice Day, I find it…

    10 条评论
  • Opportunity to Grow

    Opportunity to Grow

    How do people perform under pressure? What matters most during a crisis? How can organizations provide with support…

    1 条评论
  • Navigating Change | The Manager's Cut

    Navigating Change | The Manager's Cut

    We live in unprecedented times, to say the least. Almost Orwellian.

  • How I incorporate Learning into my Daily Life

    How I incorporate Learning into my Daily Life

    My day kick-starts around 7am. I hear there's people out there who can do as early as 6am or 5am, but I’m not one of…

    18 条评论
  • How *Do* They Do It? | New Monthly Column by Project Mamager

    How *Do* They Do It? | New Monthly Column by Project Mamager

    We’ve all been through this at some point. We painstakingly stroll our baby to the nearest park to vent some of the…

    1 条评论
  • Project-Mamager.com | A new blog where Motherhood greets the Business

    Project-Mamager.com | A new blog where Motherhood greets the Business

    They say motherhood is a transformative experience. That when it happens, things change.

  • May the Workforce be with You

    May the Workforce be with You

    I've had this idea for a digital magazine that draws from all those amazingly inspiring stuff that pass before my…

  • A new look & feel for WanderFoods

    A new look & feel for WanderFoods

    I'm excited to announce that WanderFoods, my yummy side-project on nutrition, has acquired a brand new look & feel! And…

    1 条评论
  • WanderFoods: My new yummy side-Project!

    WanderFoods: My new yummy side-Project!

    This..

    4 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了