Comprehensive Overview of QR Codes in Payment Systems, Security Measures, and Recent Trends

Introduction

QR codes (Quick Response codes) have quickly become a key part of modern payment systems, changing the way consumers and businesses interact both online and in physical spaces. Originally developed by Denso Wave in 1994 to improve automotive manufacturing efficiency, QR codes have since grown into a versatile tool used in many industries. Their ability to hold large amounts of data in a simple, compact format has made them particularly valuable in payment systems, especially for contactless and cashless transactions.

This article explores how QR codes are structured and used in payment systems, highlights recent trends, and addresses the growing need for better security—especially to protect against “qishing,” or QR code phishing attacks.

QR Codes in Payment Systems: Structure and Functionality

QR codes are essentially two-dimensional barcodes made up of black and white squares that encode information. This information can be as simple as a number or as complex as detailed transaction data. According to ISO/IEC 18004:2006, QR codes can store up to 7,089 numeric characters or 4,296 alphanumeric characters, depending on how they are set up. This flexibility is a major reason why QR codes are so useful for payments—they can securely store everything from merchant IDs to payment amounts.

Types of QR Codes: Static and Dynamic

There are two main types of QR codes used in payment systems:

- Static QR Codes: These codes contain fixed information that doesn’t change. They are useful for small, simple transactions, but because the data can’t be altered once created, they are more vulnerable to tampering or misuse.

- Dynamic QR Codes: These codes are generated in real-time and contain specific transaction data, such as the exact amount of the purchase. Dynamic codes are more secure because they are valid only for a single transaction, making them less likely to be intercepted or duplicated.

Data Encoding and Error Correction

QR codes are capable of encoding various types of data, such as numeric, alphanumeric, binary, and Kanji characters. The specific encoding method used depends on the type of data being stored. For instance:

• Numeric encoding can store up to 7,089 digits.
• Alphanumeric encoding can store up to 4,296 characters.
• Binary/byte encoding is used for more complex data, such as images, files, or more specialized characters like symbols

The encoding process converts data into a bit stream, which is then structured into the QR code symbol. The code also contains error correction and masking patterns that ensure data integrity and readability under various conditions.

Encoding methods like Huffman coding or Lempel-Ziv are often used to compress data to fit within a QR code.

QR codes also include an error correction system using Reed-Solomon error correction, which allows the code to remain readable even if part of it gets damaged. There are four levels of error correction:

- Level L: Recovers up to 7% of the data.

- Level M: Recovers up to 15%.

- Level Q: Recovers up to 25%.

- Level H: Recovers up to 30%.

BCH (Bose–Chaudhuri–Hocquenghem) Code: BCH error correction is also used in QR codes to ensure that format information and masking are correct. This method helps the QR code reader correctly interpret the data, even if parts of the QR code are missing or distorted.

The higher the level of error correction, the more damage the code can sustain while still being usable. However, higher error correction levels also mean that the code can store less information.

QR codes contain multiple elements, including finder patterns, alignment patterns, and timing patterns. The finder patterns help the scanner locate the code, while the alignment patterns ensure that the QR code is correctly oriented when scanned. The timing patterns assist in determining the size of the code.

The format information in a QR code contains information about the error correction level and the mask pattern applied to the code. This data is essential for decoding the information accurately, especially when the code has been partially damaged

• Dynamic QR Code Algorithms: A more recent development is the use of dynamic QR codes. These codes are generated in real-time for each transaction, making them resistant to cloning or tampering. Cryptographic algorithms such as RSA (Rivest–Shamir–Adleman) or Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA) are often used to ensure the authenticity of the transaction. These dynamic codes are used in payment systems to secure sensitive information.

QR Code Payment Systems

1. Scan-to-Pay: The Classic QR Code Payment Model

The scan-to-pay method is the most common way QR codes are used for payments. Merchants display a QR code, and customers use their mobile app to scan it. The app then decodes the information, and the payment is processed. This process is particularly useful for contactless transactions, as it eliminates the need for touching physical payment terminals.

2. Tap-to-Pay: NFC and QR Code Integration

A newer development in QR payments is the integration with Near Field Communication (NFC) technology, creating a hybrid system called tap-to-pay. In this method, users with NFC-enabled phones can simply tap their devices near a terminal, and the terminal reads a dynamic QR code. This approach offers several benefits:

- Speed: Transactions happen almost instantly without needing to scan a code.

- Security: NFC payments require close proximity, reducing the chances of interception.

- Convenience: Users can store multiple payment methods in their phone’s wallet and choose between them with a simple tap.

For example, in a grocery store, a customer can tap their NFC-enabled phone near the payment terminal, which processes the payment using a dynamic QR code generated by the system.

3. Cross-Border Payments and Standardization

As digital payments grow globally, there’s an increasing effort to standardize QR code payment systems, especially in regions like Southeast Asia. A standardized system would allow customers to use the same QR code-based payment method in different countries, making international transactions easier and promoting financial inclusion.

Technical Algorithm and Example of a Domestic Transaction

Let’s take a look at a technical process flow of a domestic QR code payment transaction:

Customer and Merchant Setup:

• The merchant generates a dynamic QR code, embedding information like merchant ID, transaction amount, timestamp, and encryption metadata.
• The customer scans this code using their payment app linked to a bank account or digital wallet.

Encryption and Data Transfer:

• Once scanned, the app decodes the QR code and prepares a transaction request containing encrypted details like the customer’s account and payment specifics.
• This encrypted data is sent securely to the payment processor’s server for validation.

Transaction Processing:

• The payment processor decrypts and verifies the transaction details using RSA or AES encryption.
• The system checks for potential fraud using machine learning algorithms that detect suspicious transaction patterns.

Approval and Settlement:

• After validation, the payment is authorized and a confirmation is sent to both customer and merchant.
• The payment processor settles the amount using either Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) or Deferred Net Settlement (DNS), depending on the system’s requirements.

Notification:

• Both customer and merchant receive real-time transaction confirmations through push notifications.

Security Concerns: Qishing and Mitigation Strategies

Although QR codes have made payments more convenient, they also introduce new security risks. One major threat is qishing—QR code phishing—where attackers replace legitimate QR codes with malicious ones. When scanned, these fraudulent codes might direct users to dangerous websites or download malware.

Qishing Attack Scenarios

Physical Tampering: In public places, fraudsters can physically replace a legitimate QR code with a fake one. For example, a scammer might replace a restaurant’s payment QR code with one that redirects the payment to their own account.

Digital QR Code Phishing: Online, attackers can send malicious QR codes through phishing emails or fake websites. When scanned, these codes might lead users to a fraudulent site that asks for sensitive information like banking passwords.

Security Measures to Combat Qishing

To mitigate the risks posed by qishing and ensure secure QR code transactions, several security measures and best practices have been developed:

Digital Signatures and Cryptographic Methods

One of the most effective ways to secure QR codes is by signing them using digital cryptography, such as RSA or Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA).

• RSA Signatures: In this approach, the entity generating the QR code (e.g., a bank or merchant) signs the data embedded in the QR code with their private key. The payment app used by the customer can then verify the signature using the issuer's public key before processing the payment. This ensures that the QR code is authentic and has not been tampered with
• ECDSA: This method offers the same benefits as RSA but with smaller key sizes, making it more efficient for QR codes, where data capacity is limited.

Dynamic QR Codes

Unlike static QR codes, which are permanent and unchanging, dynamic QR codes are generated in real-time for each transaction. Dynamic QR codes contain unique information for each payment, such as a one-time transaction ID. This makes it difficult for attackers to reuse or alter QR codes

Dynamic codes also enable real-time tracking and verification of transactions, adding another layer of security.

NFC Integration for Secure Payments

To create a seamless and secure payment experience, QR codes are increasingly being integrated with Near Field Communication (NFC) technology. NFC allows users to initiate payments by simply tapping their smartphones near a terminal. Combining QR codes with NFC ensures that the transaction process is both fast and secure, eliminating the need for manual input or card swiping. Additionally, NFC supports encrypted transactions, reducing the risk of data interception.

URL Verification in QR Code Scanners

Many QR code scanning apps now include URL verification features. Before redirecting the user to a website, the app checks the URL for known phishing patterns or malicious domains. If the URL is flagged as suspicious, the app alerts the user or blocks access entirely.

Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)

Incorporating multi-factor authentication (MFA) into payment processes is another way to secure QR code transactions. After scanning a QR code, the customer might be required to authenticate through a second method, such as a one-time password (OTP) sent to their phone or biometric verification (e.g., fingerprint or face recognition). This adds a layer of security even if a malicious QR code is scanned.

User Education and Awareness

Educating users about the risks of qishing is crucial. Users should be encouraged to:

• Verify the source of a QR code before scanning it.
• Avoid scanning codes from untrusted or unknown sources, such as random posters or emails.
• Always check the URL they are redirected to and ensure it is the legitimate domain of the service they are using.

Thee Evolution of QR Code Payments

As QR code payments become more popular, several trends are likely to shape the future of this technology:

- Biometric Authentication: Payment systems might start using biometric data like facial recognition or fingerprints to further secure QR code transactions, ensuring that only authorized users can complete a payment.

- Advanced Cryptography: As computing power increases and quantum computing develops, traditional security algorithms might become vulnerable. In the future, QR payment systems could adopt quantum-resistant or optical cryptography to stay secure.

- Global Standardization: Efforts to create a globally standardized QR code payment system will likely continue, making it easier for users to make payments when traveling abroad and simplifying international commerce.

Novel Idea: Shoppable TV and the Future of Connected Retail

Imagine a future where Shoppable TV is not just an interactive novelty, but a seamless, integral part of our everyday retail experience. Shoppable TV refers to the concept of purchasing products directly from TV ads or shows, blurring the lines between entertainment and commerce. Today, QR codes have helped move this concept forward by allowing consumers to scan a code on their screens, instantly accessing product pages or completing transactions. However, while the technology exists, it has not yet reached its full potential due to key barriers—particularly consumer hesitation and friction in the process.

To make Shoppable TV a mainstream success, it must become as intuitive and frictionless as any other form of e-commerce. Currently, users often need to reach for their phones, scan the QR code, wait for the webpage to load, and then navigate through various steps to finalize a purchase. This multi-step process disrupts the immersive TV-watching experience, causing consumers to disengage. The process needs to evolve into something more immediate—potentially integrating technologies such as voice-activated commands, NFC-enabled remotes, or smart home assistants to reduce the number of steps between seeing a product and purchasing it.

A key to unlocking the potential of Shoppable TV lies in the convergence of retail media and connected TV. As smart TVs become more sophisticated and connected, they can offer personalized content and targeted advertising. Imagine watching a TV show where the items characters wear or use are available for immediate purchase with a simple voice command or a single tap on your smart remote. This convergence would create an integrated shopping experience, where TV content dynamically adapts to individual viewers, recommending products based on their preferences and browsing history. Moreover, with the rise of augmented reality (AR) features in connected devices, users could potentially "try on" products virtually while watching TV, before completing the purchase in real-time.

To fully realize the potential of Shoppable TV, retailers, media companies, and technology providers must collaborate to streamline the process and create a fully immersive, intuitive shopping experience. By reducing friction and making the buying process seamless, shoppable TV could transform how we engage with media and commerce in the near future, blending entertainment, advertising, and retail into one cohesive platform. This vision could redefine the shopping experience, turning passive TV consumption into an active, personalized retail journey.

Conclusion

QR codes have revolutionized payment systems, offering a fast, secure, and cost-effective way to handle contactless transactions. Whether using the traditional scan-to-pay method or the newer NFC-integrated tap-to-pay, QR codes provide both consumers and businesses with significant benefits. However, as these systems grow in popularity, it’s crucial to stay ahead of security risks like qishing by implementing strong security measures, including dynamic codes, digital signatures, and NFC technology. Looking ahead, QR codes are expected to remain a key part of the digital payment landscape, driving continued innovation in the global financial system.

#DigitalPayments #Fintech #QRCode #ContactlessPayments #Security #TV