Compete or be Eaten - Strategies for Law Firms to Thrive Amid Vendor-Led Market Cannibalisation

Insights from Legal Halo 25/09/24.

Tom Slate, Director of Projects and Innovation at Shoosmiths, joined the Legal Halo cohort at Ochre last week (25.09.24) bringing over two decades of experience in process improvement and change management to the table, along with a passion for transforming law firms. Having worked in both Magic Circle and mid-market law firms, Slate's insights into the shifting dynamics of legal service delivery and the hurdles law firms face in driving meaningful change resonate across the industry. Last week he shared his thoughts on the competitive pressures, challenges, and strategies law firms must adopt to stay ahead in an evolving marketplace.

Competitive Pressures and Market Realities

"The legal industry is fiercely competitive," Slate began, highlighting the challenges firms face in securing work. Firms are not only competing on price but also striving to encroach on higher-value work traditionally dominated by their rivals. This competition has intensified as law firms across different tiers seek to expand their client base and grow their relationships with existing clients. ”Whilst the size of legal market place is growing, so i the number of market entrants, creating more competition and pressure that ten years ago” ?he explained.

The rise of legal COOs and procurement professionals further complicates the landscape, according to Slate. These professionals are driving efficiency within in-house legal teams and are working with their private practice firms to deliver services with greater value and transparency. “It’s no longer just about a partner calling their old friend to secure work. Procurement professionals are scrutinising how law firms deliver services to ensure they get value as well as good legal advice,” Slate remarked.

?

War for Talent and Technological Disruption

One of the most pressing challenges is the ongoing war for talent. US law firms, in particular, have entered the London market, offering highly competitive salaries to newly qualified lawyers, creating a ripple effect across the industry. "If you can't get the right talent, you can’t do the work, and if you can't satisfy your clients, you're out of the game," Slate noted. The pressure to attract and retain top talent has become a critical factor in a firm's ability to remain competitive.

Moreover, technological advancements are increasingly reshaping the legal landscape. "Some technology providers are no longer just vendors; they’re becoming competitors," Slate warned. The advent of AI-powered legal solutions, such as compliance products, allows clients to bypass traditional legal services altogether. This shift is cannibalising certain segments of the legal market, forcing firms to evolve. "If a law firm can't sit still, it must change and evolve, even just to maintain its market position," Slate emphasised.

Challenges to Effective Change Management

Despite the clear need for transformation, law firms face significant barriers to change. "There’s so much noise out there," Slate observed, pointing to the overwhelming number of technology vendors vying for law firms' attention. Deciding which technologies to adopt is a challenge in itself, exacerbated by the high switching costs involved in migrating from one system to another.

Law firm structures can also hinder innovation. "Are law firms geared towards innovation, change, or stagnation?" Slate asked, noting that many firms are structured in ways that stifle agility. The traditional partnership model, where consensus is often required to make decisions, can be a roadblock to swift action.

?

The Role of Cloud Technology

While the adoption of cloud technology offers opportunities for flexibility and scalability, it also introduces complexities. "Cloud makes it easier to trial and test new technologies, but it’s also created a proliferation of solutions, which can be frankly confusing," Slate remarked. Despite these challenges, he remains optimistic about the potential of cloud technology to streamline processes and improve efficiency.

?

Building Adaptability

In closing, Slate emphasised the need for law firms to develop a culture of adaptability. "With good change management, you have to acknowledge that you’re probably going to have to change quite often," he said. This means building general technology skills within the firm rather than focusing solely on specific tools. Slate advocates for developing a workforce that is flexible and capable of navigating continuous technological evolution. "It's not just about deep training on one system; it's about building the adaptability to switch between technologies," he concluded.

Slate's insights underscore the need for law firms to not only embrace technology but also foster a culture that supports continuous learning and adaptability. As the legal industry continues to evolve, those firms that can effectively navigate these challenges will be the ones best positioned for success.

As the legal market faces increasing competition and disruption, staying ahead requires more than just adapting—it demands proactive strategy.

At Alt-V Law , we partner with firms to navigate these challenges and implement change that drives lasting success.

Alt-V Law | Law through a different lens.