A comparison of 3 different methods to deliver value creation initiatives

Before we delve into the 3 delivery methods of post-merger integration, transformation and continuous improvement projects to enable the delivery of value creation initiatives, let's first look at what value creation is...

As explained in a recent podcast that I listened to; you will get different, subjective responses to the question ‘what is value creation?’. The responses you get would be linked to the proverbial story of the blind men who had to touch and identify different parts of an elephant - they all describe the elephant based on the part they encountered - and although each one of those men may have been right based on their encounter, they also needed the big picture to understand that it was in fact an elephant. Much to the same when we consider value creation.

What value creation is, is an approach to shape the direction of an organisation.

However, due to the subjectivity (as the analogue above refers to), the understanding of what value creation is depends on the organisation and the individuals involved in creating the value creation plan (VCP), meaning value creation for one organisation or individual will be completely different from another.

The answer to ‘what is value creation for us?’ should be answered, agreed, set and cascaded with clarity to the leaders of the organisation by the board.

Value creation itself refers to the process of producing products, services, or outcomes that are perceived as valuable by the recipient, whether that be a customer, employee, shareholder, investor, the community, or society at large. It involves identifying and meeting the needs, desires, and expectations of all these stakeholders in ways that enhance their lives or solves their problems, often leading to increased satisfaction, loyalty, and long-term success for an organisation.

But, as the analogue above also cleverly refers to, value creation is actually multiple areas operating as part of a wider system - with each part functioning in synergy with other parts to create the right outcome. If we focus on one part of the system, the other part may not work as expected, which will negatively impact the system and outcome. For example, if we only focus on creating value for the customer, we may will miss all other areas that must be in place to produce value for the organisation.

In a business context, value creation can take many forms, such as initiatives in product and service innovation, efficiency gains, CSR, brand building and reputation management, leveraging tech and data, strategic partnerships and alliances, mergers and acquisitions (M&A), employee engagement and development, customer relationship management, sustainability and ethical practices, market expansion, financial management and corporate governance. Whereby in these areas value can be created through product/service design, sales, marketing, human resources, culture, operations, employee and customer experience, profit, productivity, performance and so on and on.

Let's focus on 3 different value creation initiatives (once the VCP process has been completed and initiated)

Methods to deliver value creation initiatives

Value creation initiatives can widely vary depending on the goals, industry and market conditions. This article will focus on 3 delivery methods for value creation initiatives: post-merger integration (PMI), transformation and continuous improvement (CI) projects.

First things first, PMI, Transformation and CI initiatives focus on different aspects of business enhancement, different mechanisms, different processes, and varying timelines; but all share the common goal of increasing the overall value of the organisation.

Here's a rundown and comparison of how value is created through each type of initiative.

Post-merger integration (PMI) projects

PMI projects focus on integrating two or more entities into a single, unified entity after a merger or acquisition. The primary goal is to combine the operations, cultures, and systems of the merging entities to realise the synergies that justified the investment of the merger or acquisition in the first place.

PMI value creation mechanisms

• Operational synergies -?PMI projects often aim to reduce costs by eliminating redundancies, such as overlapping departments, IT systems, and operational processes. Streamlining operations can lead to significant cost savings and improved efficiency.
• Revenue synergies -?By combining products and/ services, expanding market reach, and leveraging cross-selling opportunities, PMI projects can create new revenue streams. The integration allows the merged entity to offer more comprehensive solutions to customers, increasing sales.
• Market expansion - Mergers and acquisitions often provide access to new markets, customers, and geographies. Effective PMI enables the organisation to quickly capitalise on these opportunities, driving growth and market share.
• Talent retention and optimisation - PMI projects that successfully manage cultural integration and employee engagement can retain key talent and align them with the new organisational goals, maximising human capital value.
• Strategic alignment - PMI can help align the strategic objectives of the combined entities, enabling the organisation to pursue new opportunities with greater focus and resources.

?A few examples of value creation via PMI projects

• A reduction in operating costs by consolidating office/locations or supply chains.
• Enhanced customer offerings by integrating complementary products or services.
• Increased market share by entering new regions or customer segments.

Transformation projects

Transformation projects involve large-scale, fundamental changes to an organisation’s strategy, structure, operations, culture, or business model. The goal is to achieve significant, often disruptive improvements that reposition the company for future success.

Transformation value creation mechanisms

• Strategic realignment -?Transformation projects often involve redefining the company’s strategic direction to better align with market opportunities, technological advancements, or changing customer needs. This can lead to new business models, product or service lines, or market entries that drive long-term growth.
• Organisational restructuring -?Transformations often involve reshaping the organisational structure to improve decision-making, enhance agility, and align resources with strategic priorities. This can lead to faster responses to market changes and more effective execution of strategy.
• Cultural change -?A transformation project may involve shifting the organisational culture to one that is more innovative, customer-focused, or agile. Such cultural shifts can enhance the company’s ability to adapt to change, attract top talent, and improve overall performance.
• Technological innovation -?Transformation often involves the adoption of new technologies, such as digital platforms, automation, or data analytics. These technologies can unlock new capabilities, improve customer experiences, and create competitive advantages.
• Financial performance -?Successful transformations can lead to significant improvements in financial performance, including revenue growth, margin expansion, and enhanced shareholder value. This is often achieved by entering new markets, launching innovative products, or significantly improving operational efficiency.

Examples of value creation via Transformation projects

• A company adopts a digital transformation strategy, leading to new revenue streams through online sales and services.
• An organisation restructures its operations to focus on high-growth areas, resulting in increased market share and profitability.
• A cultural transformation leads to a more innovative organisation, with a significant increase in the pace and success of product development initiatives.

Continuous improvement (CI) projects

CI projects aim to make incremental enhancements to processes, products, or services. The focus is on optimising current operations and sustaining improvements over time.

CI value creation mechanisms

• Efficiency gains -?CI projects focus on identifying and eliminating waste in processes, leading to faster cycle times, reduced costs, and improved productivity. This results in more efficient use of resources and higher output with the same or fewer inputs.
• Quality improvements -?CI projects often involve refining processes to reduce defects, enhance product quality, and improve service delivery. Higher quality can lead to increased customer satisfaction, lower return rates, and reduced rework costs.
• Cost reduction -?By optimising processes, CI projects can reduce direct costs (e.g materials, labour) and indirect costs (e.g overheads, waste management). This contributes directly to bottom-line savings.
• Employee engagement -?CI fosters a culture of continuous learning and involvement, where employees are encouraged to suggest improvements and take ownership of their work. This engagement can lead to higher morale, lower turnover, and more innovative ideas.
• Sustainability -?CI projects often incorporate sustainable practices that reduce the environmental impact of operations, leading to long-term cost savings and enhanced brand reputation.

?Examples of value creation via CI projects

• A process is refined to reduce waste, lowering production costs.
• A customer service process is improved to resolve issues more quickly, leading to higher customer satisfaction.
• A distribution process is streamlined to reduce delivery times, enhancing competitiveness

What are the differences across these 3 delivery methods to create value?

To articulate the differences across these 3 delivery methods of value creation initiatives, the table below outlines the differences in purpose, scope, timeframes, approach, value creation focus, risk levels and value creation drivers.

What are the key similarities across these 3 delivery methods to create value?

1. Change management -?All three require effective change management to address resistance, communicate changes, and ensure that stakeholders are aligned and engaged.
2. The goal of improving performance -?Whether through integration, incremental improvements, or radical transformation, the ultimate goal is to enhance organisational performance, competitiveness, and value creation.
3. Leadership involvement -?Strong leadership and a clear vision are essential to drive success in each type of initiative.

While PMI, Transformation and CI projects all contribute to creating value within an organisation, they do so through different methods and on different scales. PMI projects focus on realising synergies and integrating businesses efficiently to unlock new value; transformation projects aim for broad, strategic changes that reposition the company for future success; and CI projects drive ongoing, incremental improvements that enhance efficiency and quality. Understanding these differences helps organisations select and prioritise the right approach based on their value creation plans, ROI, specific goals, resources, and market conditions.

?