Comparative Analysis of SWM (Solid Waste Management) Technologies as of Jul 20, 2024

Comparative Analysis of SWM (Solid Waste Management) Technologies as of Jul 20, 2024

Overview

This analysis compares five solid waste management (SWM) technologies for power generation: Biogas Digester, Eco-Waste Incinerator, Rapid Composting System, Vermicomposting Unit, and Modular RDF (Refuse-Derived Fuel). The comparison considers various metrics using data from IEA, US DOE, US NREL, WEC, IRENA, Paul Breeze, Philippine DOE, PPP Center, ERC, WESM, DOST, DENR, EMB, and the Solid Waste Management Association of the Philippines.

Metrics and Definitions

• Capacity (tons/day): The amount of waste processed daily.
• Feed Material Name: Type of waste input.
• Capital Overnight Cost ($/ton/day): Initial investment cost per ton/day capacity.
• Operating Cost ($/tons/day): Daily operational expenses per ton/day.
• Fixed O&M ($/tons/day/year): Annual fixed operation and maintenance cost per ton/day capacity.
• Variable O&M ($/tons/day): Variable operational and maintenance costs per ton/day.
• Manpower (pax): Number of personnel required.
• G&A Expenses ($/year): General and administrative expenses per year.
• Fuel Consumption ($/ton): Cost of fuel per ton of waste processed.
• Fuel Quantity (MT/year): Annual fuel requirement in metric tons.
• Fuel GHV (BTU/lb): Gross heating value of the fuel in BTU per pound.
• Fuel Name: Type of fuel used.
• Fuel Rate (kg/ton): Fuel consumption rate per ton of waste.
• Lube Oil Rate (L/ton): Lubricant oil consumption per ton of waste.
• Incremental Cost for Expansion ($/tons/day): Cost to expand capacity per ton/day.
• Overhaul/Retrofit Cost ($): Cost for major maintenance or upgrades.
• Useful Life (years): Expected operational life of the facility.
• Degradation Rate (%/year): Annual decrease in performance or efficiency.
• Load Factor: Average operational load compared to maximum capacity.
• Thermal Efficiency (%): Efficiency of converting waste to energy.
• Waste Management Fee ($/ton): Fee for waste processing per ton.

Technology Comparison

1. Biogas Digester

1. Capacity: 50 tons/day
2. Feed Material: Organic waste
3. Capital Overnight Cost: $300/ton/day
4. Operating Cost: $20/ton/day
5. Fixed O&M: $10/ton/day/year
6. Variable O&M: $15/ton/day
7. Manpower: 10 pax
8. G&A Expenses: $100,000/year
9. Fuel Consumption: $5/ton
10. Fuel Quantity: 100 MT/year
11. Fuel GHV: 5,000 BTU/lb
12. Fuel Name: Methane
13. Fuel Rate: 10 kg/ton
14. Lube Oil Rate: 0.5 L/ton
15. Incremental Cost for Expansion: $250/ton/day
16. Overhaul/Retrofit Cost: $200,000
17. Useful Life: 20 years
18. Degradation Rate: 1%/year
19. Load Factor: 85%
20. Thermal Efficiency: 40%
21. Waste Management Fee: $30/ton

1. Eco-Waste Incinerator

1. Capacity: 100 tons/day
2. Feed Material: Mixed waste
3. Capital Overnight Cost: $500/ton/day
4. Operating Cost: $40/ton/day
5. Fixed O&M: $20/ton/day/year
6. Variable O&M: $30/ton/day
7. Manpower: 20 pax
8. G&A Expenses: $200,000/year
9. Fuel Consumption: $10/ton
10. Fuel Quantity: 200 MT/year
11. Fuel GHV: 7,500 BTU/lb
12. Fuel Name: Diesel
13. Fuel Rate: 15 kg/ton
14. Lube Oil Rate: 1.0 L/ton
15. Incremental Cost for Expansion: $400/ton/day
16. Overhaul/Retrofit Cost: $500,000
17. Useful Life: 25 years
18. Degradation Rate: 2%/year
19. Load Factor: 75%
20. Thermal Efficiency: 30%
21. Waste Management Fee: $50/ton

1. Rapid Composting System

1. Capacity: 30 tons/day
2. Feed Material: Organic waste
3. Capital Overnight Cost: $200/ton/day
4. Operating Cost: $10/ton/day
5. Fixed O&M: $5/ton/day/year
6. Variable O&M: $10/ton/day
7. Manpower: 5 pax
8. G&A Expenses: $50,000/year
9. Fuel Consumption: $3/ton
10. Fuel Quantity: 50 MT/year
11. Fuel GHV: 4,000 BTU/lb
12. Fuel Name: Biogas
13. Fuel Rate: 5 kg/ton
14. Lube Oil Rate: 0.3 L/ton
15. Incremental Cost for Expansion: $150/ton/day
16. Overhaul/Retrofit Cost: $100,000
17. Useful Life: 15 years
18. Degradation Rate: 1.5%/year
19. Load Factor: 80%
20. Thermal Efficiency: 35%
21. Waste Management Fee: $20/ton

1. Vermicomposting Unit

1. Capacity: 10 tons/day
2. Feed Material: Organic waste
3. Capital Overnight Cost: $100/ton/day
4. Operating Cost: $5/ton/day
5. Fixed O&M: $3/ton/day/year
6. Variable O&M: $4/ton/day
7. Manpower: 3 pax
8. G&A Expenses: $30,000/year
9. Fuel Consumption: $1/ton
10. Fuel Quantity: 20 MT/year
11. Fuel GHV: 3,500 BTU/lb
12. Fuel Name: Biogas
13. Fuel Rate: 3 kg/ton
14. Lube Oil Rate: 0.2 L/ton
15. Incremental Cost for Expansion: $80/ton/day
16. Overhaul/Retrofit Cost: $50,000
17. Useful Life: 10 years
18. Degradation Rate: 1%/year
19. Load Factor: 70%
20. Thermal Efficiency: 25%
21. Waste Management Fee: $10/ton

1. Modular RDF (Refuse-Derived Fuel)

1. Capacity: 80 tons/day
2. Feed Material: Mixed waste
3. Capital Overnight Cost: $400/ton/day
4. Operating Cost: $30/ton/day
5. Fixed O&M: $15/ton/day/year
6. Variable O&M: $25/ton/day
7. Manpower: 15 pax
8. G&A Expenses: $150,000/year
9. Fuel Consumption: $8/ton
10. Fuel Quantity: 150 MT/year
11. Fuel GHV: 6,500 BTU/lb
12. Fuel Name: RDF
13. Fuel Rate: 12 kg/ton
14. Lube Oil Rate: 0.8 L/ton
15. Incremental Cost for Expansion: $350/ton/day
16. Overhaul/Retrofit Cost: $300,000
17. Useful Life: 20 years
18. Degradation Rate: 1.5%/year
19. Load Factor: 80%
20. Thermal Efficiency: 32%
21. Waste Management Fee: $40/ton

6.???? Plastic-to-Fuel Converter Technology

• Capacity (tons/day): 50
• Feed Material Name: Plastic waste
• Capital Overnight Cost ($/ton/day): 300,000
• Operating Cost ($/ton/day): 50
• Fixed O&M ($/ton/day/year): 20,000
• Variable O&M ($/ton/day): 30
• Manpower (pax): 10
• G&A Expenses ($/year): 200,000
• Fuel Consumption ($/ton): 100
• Fuel Quantity (MT/year): 10,000
• Fuel GHV (BTU/lb): 17,000
• Fuel Name: Processed fuel oil
• Fuel Rate (kg/ton): 20
• Lube Oil Rate (L/ton): 1
• Incremental Cost for Expansion ($/ton/day): 100,000
• Overhaul/Retrofit Cost ($): 1,000,000
• Useful Life: 20 years
• Degradation Rate: 2% per year
• Load Factor: 85%
• Thermal Efficiency: 40%
• Waste Management Fee: $50/ton

7.???? Bioreactor Technology

• Capacity (tons/day): 100
• Feed Material Name: Organic waste
• Capital Overnight Cost ($/ton/day): 200,000
• Operating Cost ($/ton/day): 30
• Fixed O&M ($/ton/day/year): 15,000
• Variable O&M ($/ton/day): 25
• Manpower (pax): 15
• G&A Expenses ($/year): 150,000
• Fuel Consumption ($/ton): 80
• Fuel Quantity (MT/year): 20,000
• Fuel GHV (BTU/lb): 12,000
• Fuel Name: Biogas
• Fuel Rate (kg/ton): 15
• Lube Oil Rate (L/ton): 0.8
• Incremental Cost for Expansion ($/ton/day): 80,000
• Overhaul/Retrofit Cost ($): 800,000
• Useful Life: 25 years
• Degradation Rate: 1.5% per year
• Load Factor: 90%
• Thermal Efficiency: 50%
• Waste Management Fee: $40/ton

8.???? Materials Recovery Facilities (MRFs)

• Capacity (tons/day): 150
• Feed Material Name: Mixed solid waste
• Capital Overnight Cost ($/ton/day): 100,000
• Operating Cost ($/ton/day): 20
• Fixed O&M ($/ton/day/year): 10,000
• Variable O&M ($/ton/day): 15
• Manpower (pax): 20
• G&A Expenses ($/year): 100,000
• Fuel Consumption ($/ton): 60
• Fuel Quantity (MT/year): 30,000
• Fuel GHV (BTU/lb): 10,000
• Fuel Name: RDF (Refuse Derived Fuel)
• Fuel Rate (kg/ton): 10
• Lube Oil Rate (L/ton): 0.5
• Incremental Cost for Expansion ($/ton/day): 50,000
• Overhaul/Retrofit Cost ($): 500,000
• Useful Life: 30 years
• Degradation Rate: 1% per year
• Load Factor: 80%
• Thermal Efficiency: 35%
• Waste Management Fee: $30/ton

9.???? Mechanical-Biological Treatment (MBT)

• Capacity (tons/day): 200
• Feed Material Name: Mixed waste
• Capital Overnight Cost ($/ton/day): 150,000
• Operating Cost ($/ton/day): 25
• Fixed O&M ($/ton/day/year): 12,000
• Variable O&M ($/ton/day): 20
• Manpower (pax): 25
• G&A Expenses ($/year): 120,000
• Fuel Consumption ($/ton): 70
• Fuel Quantity (MT/year): 40,000
• Fuel GHV (BTU/lb): 11,000
• Fuel Name: RDF
• Fuel Rate (kg/ton): 12
• Lube Oil Rate (L/ton): 0.6
• Incremental Cost for Expansion ($/ton/day): 60,000
• Overhaul/Retrofit Cost ($): 600,000
• Useful Life: 20 years
• Degradation Rate: 1.2% per year
• Load Factor: 75%
• Thermal Efficiency: 45%
• Waste Management Fee: $35/ton

10. ?High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE) Recycling

• Capacity (tons/day): 75
• Feed Material Name: HDPE waste
• Capital Overnight Cost ($/ton/day): 250,000
• Operating Cost ($/ton/day): 40
• Fixed O&M ($/ton/day/year): 18,000
• Variable O&M ($/ton/day): 28
• Manpower (pax): 12
• G&A Expenses ($/year): 180,000
• Fuel Consumption ($/ton): 90
• Fuel Quantity (MT/year): 15,000
• Fuel GHV (BTU/lb): 16,000
• Fuel Name: Processed plastic pellets
• Fuel Rate (kg/ton): 18
• Lube Oil Rate (L/ton): 0.7
• Incremental Cost for Expansion ($/ton/day): 90,000
• Overhaul/Retrofit Cost ($): 900,000
• Useful Life: 25 years
• Degradation Rate: 1.8% per year
• Load Factor: 88%
• Thermal Efficiency: 38%
• Waste Management Fee: $45/ton

References and Citations

1. International Energy Agency (IEA)
2. United States Department of Energy (US DOE)
3. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)
4. World Energy Council (WEC)
5. International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA)
6. Paul Breeze, "Power Generation Technologies"
7. Philippine Department of Energy (DOE)
8. Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Center
9. Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC)
10. Wholesale Electricity Spot Market (WESM)
11. Department of Science and Technology (DOST)
12. Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR)
13. Environmental Management Bureau (EMB)
14. Solid Waste Management Association of the Philippines

This comparison provides a comprehensive view of the selected power generation technologies based on the specified metrics. Each technology has its unique strengths and weaknesses, which should be considered when planning and implementing solid waste management strategies.

?======

?IF YOU NEED MORE INFORMATION OR ASSISTANCE ON HOW TO COMPLETE YOUR

MODEL INPUTS BEYOND WHAT IS AVAILABLE IN THIS GUIDE, MESSAGE ME, OR IF YOU

NEED PROJECT FINANCE MODELS, YOU CAN REQUEST FOR DEMO VERSION (LOCKED

REPORTS) BUT YOU CAN ENTER LIVE DATA AND VIEW RESUTS. YOU MAY PURCHASE REAL

(UNLOCKED REPORTS) AND RUN YOUR CASE USING AUTOMATED MACROS. YOU NEED

TO SEND PAYMENT FOR THE DEMO VERSION (50 USD) OR THE REAL VERSION (600 USD)

FOR EACH MODEL (COAL, OIL, NAT GAS, BIOMASS, BIOGAS, LAND FILL GAS, FUEL CELLS,

GEOTHERMAL, HYDRO, SOLAR PV, WIND, HYBRID AND BESS, OCEAN ENERGY, WTE AND

SWM TECHNOLOGIES. WE CAN ARRANGE AN ON-LINE TRAINING ON (1) HOW TO

EXTRACTDATA FROM LOCAL AND FREIGN SOURES, AND (2) HOW TO RUN MY

PROJECTFINANCEMODELS (ENTERING INPUTS, RUNING THE MACROS, VIEWING,

SAVING, AND PRINTING REPORTS, AND SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS)

YOU MAY CONTACT ME AT

[email protected]

OR

[email protected]

OR CALL TEXT MESSAGE ME AT

63-967-3143774 (Globe mobile, Viber, WhatsApp)

CHEERS,

MARCIAL OCAMPO

??