The Color of Christmas: Exploring Racial Tensions Around Black Santa

Firstly, I want to thank my extraordinary patrons for holding this newsletter down! Your support is crucial, and it's paving the way for me to be able to write and organize full-time. I need as many supporters as possible to elevate this work; please become a Patron. Even small contributions make a huge impact. www.patreon.com/khafrejay Also, please follow my work at?Hip Hop For The Future SPC, connecting Hip Hop culture to businesses that want to impact marginalized communities.

Now, let's get into it...

In the collective consciousness, the image of Santa Claus is often a jolly, white-bearded man clad in red, embodying the spirit of Christmas generosity. This widely accepted portrayal, however, does not just exist in a cultural vacuum; it carries profound implications about representation and inclusivity.

The origins of Santa Claus can be traced back to Saint Nicholas, a fourth-century figure known for his generosity. Intriguingly, Saint Nicholas hailed from what is now modern-day Turkey, suggesting a reality far removed from the fair-skinned Santa that dominates our contemporary white-washed collective consciousness. The transformation of Santa's image into the iconic white figure we know today was significantly influenced by a 1930s Coca-Cola commercial. This commercial not only entrenched the image of a white Santa but also showcased the intertwining of American capitalism and cultural iconography, effectively shaping a uniform representation that overshadowed diverse iterations of Santa Claus.

This monolithic portrayal of Santa Claus has broader implications, especially in communities where this image does not resonate with the cultural or racial identity of the people. For the Black community, the omnipresent white Santa is more than just a symbol of Christmas; it is a reminder of systemic erasure and marginalization in broader cultural narratives. The lack of representation in such a universally recognized figure can have subtle yet profound effects on the self-perception and cultural identity of Black children and families. It's a narrative that quietly whispers about who is seen, who is celebrated, and, by omission, who is not.

The story of Santa Claus becomes a lens through which to examine broader issues of racial representation and the power of imagery in cultural norms. It raises critical questions about whose stories are told and how and the importance of inclusive and diverse representation in all facets of society, including in our cherished cultural symbols and traditions.

Historical Context

The history of Black Santas in the United States is a compelling narrative that intertwines with the nation's broader racial and civil rights struggles. Post-World War II marked a significant era in this context, with increased Black urbanization and growing consumer power in African American communities. This period witnessed a gradual but notable shift in the representation of Santa Claus, reflecting the socio-political dynamics of the time.

In the years following the war, as African Americans moved into urban centers in more significant numbers and their economic power grew, some white-owned department stores and retailers began to employ Black Santas. This was not just a business strategy to appeal to Black consumers but also a way to foster "good interracial feelings in the community." This shift marked a subtle but significant acknowledgment of the increasing prominence and influence of the Black community in American society. This new representation was met with backlash immediately, but Black people persisted.

Beyond mere commercial representation, Black Santas also played a vital role in the civil rights movement. Activists ingeniously used the figure of Santa Claus as a tool to draw attention to racial injustices and biases. For instance, the NAACP in Bloomington, Indiana, featured a Black Santa float in the city’s Christmas parade explicitly to highlight discrimination within the city's Chamber of Commerce. In Milwaukee, a Black Santa led a march advocating for open housing legislation. In New York, protests against "Santa Claus segregation" compelled significant department stores like Macy's to hire Black Santas, directly confronting and challenging the prevailing racial biases.

This use of Black Santas in civil rights activism was not just a fight for representation; it was a more profound struggle against the pervasive forms of racial bias that permeated American society. In some instances, militant Black activists even rallied against the image of the White Santa Claus, viewing it as a symbol of white cultural hegemony and psychological harm inflicted upon Black people, especially children. This resistance took various forms, from rejecting the Santa Claus figure altogether to dramatically remaking it to embody the radical currents of the time.

One notable example was the series of Black Christmas parades in Chicago, organized by Operation Breadbasket, the economic arm of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference. The inaugural 1968 parade featured a Black Santa in a black velvet dashiki, symbolically wearing a black glove to support African American athletes Tommie Smith and John Carlos, who protested at the 1968 Summer Olympics. The following year, the parade featured a Black Santa who greeted onlookers with a Black Power salute, with floats showcasing images of prominent Black figures like Fred Hampton, chairman of the Illinois chapter of the Black Panther Party.

Resisting Supremacy: The Backlash Against Black Santa and Its Implications

The depiction of Black Santa Claus has historically been met with racism and controversy, highlighting deep-rooted issues in society regarding race and representation. In recent years, the increasing presence of Black Santas in public spaces and media has been a positive step towards diversity and representation. However, these depictions have often faced backlash, rooted in white supremacy and fears around the loss of white identity.

A notable example occurred in 2016 when retired U.S. Army Captain Larry Jefferson became the first Black man to play Santa at the Mall of America. While many parents appreciated the move, seeing it as valuable for their children to see a Santa Claus who resembled them, the decision also attracted racist and derogatory comments. This incident underscores the discomfort and resistance that some parts of white America exhibit towards non-white representations of cultural figures like Santa Claus. The backlash Jefferson faced was not an isolated incident but part of a broader pattern of resistance to the diversification of traditionally white symbols.

Similarly, in 2018, a family in Arkansas received a racist note demanding the removal of their Black Santa decoration. This incident, which went viral, brought to light the hostility that can accompany attempts to diversify cultural imagery. The family's experience points to a larger societal issue where anything that challenges the norm of white supremacy, even in as seemingly benign a form as a holiday decoration, can provoke aggressive responses.

These incidents reveal the deeper societal fears and biases white people have around race and representation. The debate over Santa's racial identity, while seemingly trivial to those who have been comfortable in their privilege, actually reflects long-standing issues around white racial panic. It's not just about a mythical figure but rather about the more profound implications of shifting societal norms and the fear of losing the privilege and power associated with whiteness. Those fears lead to us dying all too often.

Personal Narratives and Cultural Impact

The significance of Black Santa representations in the lives of individuals who grew up with them is profound and deeply personal. These narratives highlight the impact of seeing a Santa that resembles one's community and underscore the broader implications on the self-perception and joy of Black children and families.

One touching example comes from a writer, Daizha Rioland, who recalls a single Black Santa Claus figurine in her grandmother's living room. This figurine, unique in her childhood experience, symbolized the idea that Santa didn't have to conform to the traditional image of being "pale as snow." It was a rare but cherished reminder that Santa Claus could mirror her own image and identity. This early exposure to a Black Santa played a crucial role in affirming her self-worth and presence in the festive narrative of Christmas.

Similarly, another individual recounts in Psychology Today how growing up with Black Santa ornaments, a tradition cherished by their father, shaped their flexible view of Santa as either white or Black. This early exposure to diverse representations of Santa fostered an inclusive mindset, highlighting the importance of visible forms of representation in meeting the psychological need for belonging and acceptance. The author notes the sense of pride felt upon seeing Black Santas and nutcrackers in mainstream settings, signaling a shift toward greater inclusivity.

The impact of these experiences is not limited to personal anecdotes; it extends to shaping the cultural identity of Black communities. Seeing a Santa that resembles them can profoundly affect Black children, fostering a sense of inclusion and representation in a season often dominated by images that do not reflect their reality. For many Black families, incorporating Black Santa into their holiday traditions is an act of liberation, an affirmation of their identity, and a powerful statement against the dominant cultural narratives that have historically excluded or marginalized them.

Black Santas and Anti-Racist Education

For many Black families, the presence of Black Santa Claus figures in their homes and communities is more than just a seasonal decoration; it's a profound statement of identity and empowerment. These representations provide Black children with a reflection of themselves in a universally recognized figure, affirming their place in the festive narrative and broader society. The impact of this can be seen in the joy and pride that Black children exhibit when they see a Santa Claus who shares their skin color and features. This act of representation is a form of liberation, as it breaks away from the dominant narrative that often marginalizes or excludes Black identity.

A Tool for Anti-Racist Education

Parents in the Black community are intentionally incorporating Black Santa into their holiday traditions as a means of anti-racist education. By showcasing Black Santas in various shades and representations, parents are teaching their children about the beauty and value of their skin color and cultural heritage. This practice goes beyond mere representation; it is an active step in creating a space where Black children feel seen, heard, and valued. It challenges the stereotypes and biases that often pervade society and encourages children to embrace their identity confidently.

Impact on Children’s Self-Perception

When children grow up seeing positive images that reflect their identity, like Black Santa, it significantly impacts their self-perception and esteem. A child's realization that "Santa looks like me; he has brown skin too" can be a decisive moment of self-affirmation. This recognition helps build a foundation of self-love and respect for others' uniqueness. By affirming their identity through these representations, children learn the importance of diversity and the value of seeing and making others feel seen.

Promoting Curiosity and Understanding

Including Black Santa in family traditions and community celebrations also promotes curiosity and understanding among children. It encourages them to ask questions, recognize differences, and appreciate the diversity around them. This educational aspect helps break down stereotypes and foster a more inclusive and empathetic viewpoint towards others.

Creating Brave Spaces

Having Black Santa figures in homes and community spaces creates what some describe as a "brave space." Children can freely explore and express their identities in these environments without fear of judgment or prejudice. Such spaces are essential for children, especially those in marginalized communities, as they offer a sense of security and affirmation.

The Power of Black Santa for White Families

The significance of representation, mainly through cultural icons like Santa Claus, extends beyond the communities directly reflected in these images. For white families and other non-Black individuals, the inclusion of diverse representations such as Black Santas plays a crucial role in fostering anti-racist attitudes and keeping your kids from becoming the bigots we deal with every day.

Psychological Need for Belonging and Representation

The psychological need for belonging and representation is universal. When children and adults are exposed to diverse representations, it broadens their understanding and appreciation of different cultures and identities. In modern culture and commerce, the increasing presence of Black Santas in stores, media, and public spaces serves as a powerful example. These images not only affirm the identity of Black communities but also introduce white families to a broader spectrum of cultural narratives. This exposure is essential in a society striving for inclusivity and equality.

Inclusive Cultural Imagery in White Families

If you're white, think about your home. Do you have any representation other than white people for your kids to stare at every day? If not, what does that teach your children, and what does it not teach them? For white families, inclusive cultural imagery like Black Santa serves as an educational tool, providing opportunities to engage in conversations about race, diversity, and inclusivity. It encourages white children and adults to acknowledge and respect differences, fostering empathy and understanding. When white families incorporate diverse imagery into their lives, it demonstrates a commitment to a world that values and celebrates all its members, regardless of race.

Celebrating and Affirming Blackness

The presence of Black Santas in mainstream culture helps to normalize and celebrate Blackness. This is important not just for Black individuals but for society as a whole. When white families actively engage with and support these representations, it helps to dismantle stereotypes and counteract the biases that are often perpetuated in society. It's a step towards acknowledging the rich tapestry of human diversity and the unique contributions of each group. White families should be actively seeking out Black Santas for their children, and when they first walk up to see their very first Santa, how they respond will tell you if you have failed or succeeded in instilling humanity in their hearts.

Conclusion

The Black Santa movement transcends mere holiday symbolism; it's a profound act of cultural reclamation and resistance against a pervasive cultural hegemony that has long marginalized Black identities. This movement's significance lies in the affirmation of Black identity and its challenge to the dominant narratives that have historically excluded or misrepresented Black people.

The presence of Black Santas in homes, public spaces, and media is a powerful statement. It's an assertion that Black people, and particularly Black children, deserve to see themselves as universal symbols of joy, generosity, and wonder. This representation is crucial in a world where the erasure and distortion of Black stories and images have real and damaging consequences. It's about counteracting a systemic narrative that often devalues Black lives and experiences. The Black Santa movement is not merely about diversity in holiday celebrations; it's a stand against a history that has too often rendered Black people invisible or stereotyped.

The implications of this movement are far-reaching and profound. While some may see the inclusion of Black Santas as a small step, it is, in reality, part of a more giant fight against a system that can have life-or-death consequences. When Black children grow up in a world that consistently undervalues their lives and narratives, it contributes to a society where racial bias and systemic racism can flourish. By challenging these narratives and insisting on representation in even the seemingly small things like holiday icons, we are taking steps towards a society where Black lives are genuinely valued and respected.

In essence, the Black Santa movement is a call to action. It challenges each of us, regardless of race, to critically examine the symbols and narratives we support and to actively seek out and promote inclusivity. It's a reminder that the journey towards racial justice and equality is ongoing and that every action, no matter how small it may seem, is a step towards a more just and equitable world.

Lastly, If you want to elevate this work, please become a Patron. Your support is crucial, and it's paving the way for me to be able to write and organize full-time. If you still need to, become a Patron and join the community, empowering me to speak louder and organize stronger. Every contribution is a strike against those trying to silence us. Join me at www.patreon.com/khafrejay, and please follow my work at Hip Hop For The Future, connecting Hip Hop culture to businesses that want to impact marginalized communities.