Coaching Them "Out"? Don't Be A Coward

The Challenge of Leadership in Sales

Every sales leader knows the gut-punch feeling when a member of the team isn't hitting their numbers. It's like watching a train slowly veer off the tracks—the crash isn't instant, but the resulting mess is inevitable. There's this murky area in management where you're faced with a choice: to invest in coaching up a struggling salesperson or to start paving their path out of the door. Let's be clear, coaching someone out isn't leadership—it's a failure to lead.

ALERT: WE'RE MOVING!

I am moving my newsletter off of Linkedin to better serve you, cut down the noise, and create a better connection with the community. You can easily get it delivered to you when the move is finalized: CLICK HERE!

The Reality of Leadership Failure

Here's the harsh truth: if you're considering coaching someone out, you've already let them down. As a sales manager, your core responsibility is to develop your team, not just lead them to the next sale. Sales is a tough gig—targets can seem like moving goalposts, and rejection is part of the daily grind. It's no wonder that sometimes even the most promising talent might falter. It's at this junction that the metal of a true leader is tested—do you give up on your player, or do you coach them to be better?

The Transformative Power of Coaching Up

Now, let me paint a different scene—one where coaching up transforms potential into performance. This isn't some feel-good, inspirational poster talk; this is hard-nosed business sense backed by numbers. According to research by CSO Insights, organizations with dynamic, adaptable sales coaching outperform their peers, seeing win rates improve by up to 28%. And get this: a study from the International Coach Federation found that companies with strong coaching cultures reported higher revenue growth in relation to their competitors.

Bridging the Gap: The Sales Manager's Mindset

So, how do we bridge the gap between potential and performance? It begins with a sales manager’s mindset. Understand that coaching up isn't an afterthought—it's a fundamental part of your job. You signed up to be a leader, and leaders don't abandon ship at the first sign of a leak.

Understanding Context: The Key to Improvement

First, look in the mirror. Have you clearly communicated expectations? Do your team members have the resources they need to succeed? Are they battling personal challenges? Understanding context is key to unlocking improvement. It’s like trying to solve a puzzle; you need to see the bigger picture to know where the pieces go.

Individualized Coaching: The Future of Sales Coaching

Next, tailor your coaching to the individual. Cookie-cutter solutions won't cut it. The one-size-fits-all approach is a relic of the past—like fax machines and dial-up internet. Technology has evolved, and so has sales coaching. Use data and analytics to track progress, set realistic goals, and celebrate small wins. Gamification, contemporary training tools leveraging AI, VR—welcome to the future of sales coaching, where adaptation is the name of the game.

Building Relationships: The Strategy for Success

Now, let’s talk strategy. Regular one-on-ones are your bread and butter. This isn't just a numbers check-in; it's building a relationship, understanding motivations, and fine-tuning their approach. Be the coach who's more interested in progress than just quotas.

Peer-to-Peer Learning: An Overlooked Gem

Then we have peer-to-peer learning—a gem often overlooked. Your best performers can be catalysts for growth. Encourage mentorship and knowledge sharing. After all, who better to provide guidance than someone who's walked the same path? It's a win-win: your top salespeople solidify their knowledge by teaching, and your struggling reps get practical, from-the-trenches insights.

The Necessity of Transparency and Accountability

But what if, despite your best efforts, performance doesn't improve? Here's where transparency is your ally. Have open conversations about performance issues and what it will take to turn things around. Set a clear action plan with specific benchmarks—they need to know where the goalposts are. Continue to provide support but be clear that improvement is non-negotiable. Accountability isn't the enemy; it's the guardrail that keeps us on the road to success.

Coaching Up: More Than Just Saving a Struggling Salesperson

As we wrap this up, understand this: coaching up isn't just about saving a struggling salesperson; it's about creating a resilient, adaptable, and high-performing team. You're not just a manager—you're a talent sculptor, and each member of your team is a work in progress, a potential masterpiece. Your job is to bring that masterpiece to life, not toss the canvas when the first brushstroke goes awry.

The Legacy of a True Sales Leader

So, sales managers, let's ditch the escape hatch mentality. Our people are our most valuable asset, and when we invest in them, the returns aren't just in revenue—they're in loyalty, team cohesion, and a thriving culture. Coaching up isn't just the right thing to do; it's the smart thing to do. And remember, the only way to lead is from the front—rolling up your sleeves, getting down in the trenches, and showing your team what it takes to win. Because in the end, their success is your success. Let that be the legacy you leave.

I believe that cutting down on the noise and being part of a dedicated community allows for faster growth, more meaningful relationships and deeper thoughts.

Join Hundreds Of Your Most Successful Peers On Our Newsletter: CLICK HERE!