Coaching Stances and Their Role in School Improvement to Enhance Collaboration and Creativity

In an era where global competition and rapid technological advancements have made education more critical than ever, the drive for school improvement remains at the forefront of educational discourse. To truly propel a school or district towards excellence, however, a systemic and strategic approach is required – one that revolves around the potent skill of coaching. Just as athletes rely on their coaches to extract their best performance, educational institutions stand to gain significantly from the application of effective coaching practices. This article delves into the various types of coaching stances and underscores the importance of approaching school improvement with leaders as a coach.

Coaching stances, at their core, represent the different positions or perspectives a coach assumes based on the specific context, need, or situation. In education, these stances determine how a coach interacts with their coachee, be it a teacher, a school leader, or even a student. Let’s examine some of these stances:

Directive Stance: This stance is more instructional and is deployed when an immediate action is required or when the coachee lacks the knowledge or skill necessary for a particular task. The coach provides clear guidance and possibly even models the desired behavior.

Consultative Stance: In this approach, the coach serves as a consultant, offering expert advice or specialized knowledge in a particular area. While it might sound similar to the directive stance, the consultative stance is less about immediate action and more about offering insights.

Collaborative Stance: As the name suggests, this stance involves a mutual exploration of ideas, strategies, or challenges. It’s a partnership where both coach and coachee bring their insights to the table, allowing for a more democratic process of problem-solving.

Facilitative Stance: Here, the coach primarily asks open-ended questions, prompting the coachee to reflect deeply, explore their own thinking, and arrive at their own conclusions. This approach boosts the coachee's autonomy and builds capacity over time.

Now that we have a clearer understanding of the various stances, we must address the burning question: Why is coaching vital in educational leadership, especially when it comes to school improvement?

Nurturing a Growth Mindset

A coaching approach promotes a growth mindset both among the school leaders and the broader school community. Leaders, when coached, begin to view challenges not as setbacks but as opportunities for growth. This perspective trickles down to teachers, students, and other stakeholders, creating a positive learning culture.

For example,? a seasoned science teacher was struggling with low participation in his class. Frustration clouded his initial view, seeing it as a lack of interest in the subject matter. However, after a series of coaching sessions with Principal Martinez, he began to perceive this challenge differently.

The principal prompted the science teacher, "Instead of seeing their silence as indifference, could it be a fear of making mistakes?"

This perspective shift led the science teacher to design a 'Failure Friday' initiative. Each week, students were encouraged to share their scientific hypotheses on various topics, no matter how off-the-mark or unconventional they seemed. Mistakes were celebrated as pathways to deeper understanding, with the class collectively exploring the reasons behind each misstep.

As weeks went by, a palpable change occurred. Students became more vocal, eager to share hypotheses, knowing errors were steps toward growth. Moreover, they began supporting and coaching each other, emphasizing the journey of learning over just the right answers.

The science teacher’s transformation, catalyzed by a coaching approach, turned challenges into opportunities, fostering a classroom where a growth mindset thrived.

Enhancing Professional Development

Traditional professional development sessions can sometimes be generic and detached from a teacher's real classroom experiences. A coaching approach, on the other hand, offers personalized, timely, and actionable feedback. This boosts not only the competency but also the confidence of the educators.

For years, a teacher attended the same annual professional development workshops. They were broad, covering general teaching strategies applicable to all. Yet, her specific challenge was managing diverse learning styles in her mixed-ability class.

One day, the school introduced a new initiative: personalized coaching sessions for educators. The teacher was paired with an expert instructional coach that focused on improving differentiated instruction.

Their first session began with a deep dive into the teacher's classroom dynamics. They reviewed student profiles, understanding each learner's strengths and areas of growth. Instead of offering generic strategies, instructional coach observed a few of the teacher’s classes, pinpointing exact moments where differentiated instruction could be more effective.

Together, they crafted tailored strategies, from grouping methods to technology integrations, targeting the unique needs of the teacher’s students. Each subsequent coaching session revolved around feedback from actual classroom implementations, ensuring a cycle of action, reflection, and refinement.

With this hands-on, tailored approach, the teacher felt more equipped and confident. She wasn't just applying broad strategies; she was implementing methods aligned precisely with her classroom's needs.

Over time, her students' engagement and performance soared, and the teacher became a beacon of inspiration for her peers. Her experience underscored the transformative power of personalized professional development, showing that when educators receive timely and relevant coaching, their potential to make impactful changes in the classroom is limitless.

Facilitating Effective Change Management

School improvement often implies changes – changes in curriculum, teaching methodologies, assessment practices, and so forth. Leaders equipped with coaching skills can navigate these transitions more smoothly, ensuring that changes are not just imposed but are understood, embraced, and effectively implemented.

For example, one middle school was gearing up for a significant shift: the introduction of a project-based learning (PBL) curriculum. While the benefits of PBL were evident, many teachers, accustomed to traditional teaching methods, were apprehensive about the change.

The principal, known for her adept coaching skills. Recognizing the enormity of the transition, she devised a systematic change management plan.

Firstly, she organized a series of town-hall style meetings where teachers could voice their concerns. Instead of merely presenting the benefits of PBL, she asked questions like, "What excites you about this shift?" and "What are your main concerns?" These questions allowed her to gauge the faculty's pulse and understand their reservations.

Drawing insights from these sessions, she organized focused workshops. But, instead of generic training, these workshops were led by internal 'PBL Champions' – early adopters of the method who had seen success. Their real-world classroom stories resonated more with the faculty than any external expert's lecture might have.

Additionally, the principal set up peer-coaching groups, ensuring every teacher had a support system during the transition. These groups met regularly, discussing their PBL successes and challenges, and collaboratively finding solutions.

As months passed, the atmosphere at the middle school began to change. What initially was a school filled with apprehension became an institution brimming with enthusiasm. Teachers weren't just implementing PBL; they were innovating and adapting it to best suit their students.

Through her coaching-centric approach to change management, the principal ensured the shift to PBL wasn't just accepted but embraced wholeheartedly. Elmwood's successful transition became a testament to the power of effective change management in education.

Leaders as Coaches: A Paradigm Shift

For many, the archetype of a school leader might be someone authoritative, distant, and focused on administrative tasks. However, as the educational landscape evolves, so too does the role of school leaders. They are no longer just managers but visionaries, mentors, and yes, coaches.

The new principal at a local high school began talking with teachers and the community and realized that the school was known for its strict hierarchy and top-down approach to decision-making. Teachers felt disconnected from leadership, often viewing administrative decisions with skepticism due to a lack of understanding or involvement. But the principal decided to come from a different perspective, shaped by his belief in leadership through coaching.

In his first month, he initiated 'Open Door Fridays'— a time when any staff member could discuss ideas, concerns, or seek guidance. These weren’t just cursory conversations; the principal actively listened, asked probing questions, and sometimes, played the role of a devil's advocate to stimulate deeper thinking.

Moreover, he introduced collaborative committees consisting of teachers, administrative staff, students, and even parents. These committees were tasked with discussing and brainstorming on topics ranging from curriculum changes to school events. The principal’s role in these committees was not of a decision-maker but a facilitator, guiding the conversation and ensuring all voices were heard.

He also launched a mentorship program, pairing veteran teachers with newer educators. This not only fostered professional growth but also strengthened inter-faculty relationships, building a sense of unity and purpose. As time went on, the culture at the high school began to shift. Decisions were no longer met with resistance, as stakeholders felt involved in the process. Teachers felt empowered, the community and students felt heard, and the school thrived in this inclusive, collaborative environment.

The principal’s approach embodied the paradigm shift in educational leadership. He wasn't just an administrator; he was a coach, a mentor, and a visionary. Through his coaching-centric leadership, the high school transformed from a hierarchically run institution into a collaborative educational community.

Cultivating Relationships

Coaching is fundamentally a relational task. When leaders adopt a coaching mindset, they prioritize relationship-building. Trust, respect, and open communication become the hallmarks of their leadership style.

For example, a newly appointed vice-principal at an elementary school, had often heard that the school environment was somewhat "cold." Teachers mostly kept to themselves, with limited collaboration across grades or subjects.

Recognizing that meaningful change couldn't happen without strong interpersonal relationships, The assistant principal decided to invest time in cultivating these connections. His goal wasn't just to oversee the teaching staff but to truly understand their aspirations, challenges, and unique perspectives.

He began by hosting bi-weekly "Tea with the VP" sessions. These weren't formal meetings but relaxed get-togethers where teachers could chat about anything, whether school-related or personal. He actively listened, offering empathy, sharing his own experiences, and occasionally sprinkling in humor to build camaraderie.

Furthermore, he initiated "Classroom Swap Days." On these days, teachers would step into each other's classes, not to evaluate, but to learn and appreciate the diverse teaching styles and strategies employed throughout the school. After each swap, the assistant principal facilitated reflection sessions where teachers shared insights and praised their colleagues. Over time, a noticeable shift occurred at the elementary school. The once-siloed teachers began collaborating, sharing resources, and seeking each other's advice. They felt connected not only to their peers but also to the school's leadership.

And at the heart of this transformation was the assistant principal's prioritization of relationships. By actively cultivating connections, he not only fostered a positive work environment but also laid the foundation for lasting educational improvements. His leadership highlighted that before one can effectively lead or coach, one must genuinely connect. Ensuring that trust, respect, and open communication helped to transform the elementary school, leading to a positive impact on the school culture with relationship-driven leadership.

Driving Inclusive Decision Making

A coaching leader values the insights and opinions of their team. They recognize that sustainable school improvement is a collective endeavor and ensure that everyone's voice is heard and valued.

There was a high school that had a long-standing tradition: decisions, from curriculum changes to event planning, were exclusively made by the school's senior leadership team. While efficient, this approach often left a large portion of the school community feeling overlooked.

When the new principal stepped in, she recognized the immense untapped potential in the collective wisdom of her staff, students, and parents. Determined to drive inclusive decision-making, she introduced the "High School Roundtable."

Each month, a diverse group—comprising teachers from various grades and subjects, students from different age groups, support staff, and parents—was invited to a roundtable discussion. Here, upcoming decisions were presented as open-ended challenges, e.g., "How can we better integrate technology into our curriculum?" or "What can make our annual school carnival more engaging for the community?"

These discussions were facilitated, not dominated, by the principal. She encouraged participants to share their unique perspectives, ask questions, challenge prevailing notions, and co-create solutions. Ideas were noted, debated, and often, blended to form comprehensive strategies that genuinely reflected the school's diverse needs and aspirations.

Over time, the High School Roundtable became a cherished institution. Not only did it yield more holistic and effective decisions, but it also fostered a culture of inclusivity and mutual respect. Staff felt empowered, students felt valued, and parents felt connected. By prioritizing inclusivity and collective wisdom, the principal ensured that decisions at the high school were not just top-down directives but collaborative endeavors, ensuring the school's success was genuinely a shared achievement.

Encouraging Reflective Practices

One of the core tenets of coaching is reflection. Leaders as coaches encourage continuous reflection, both at an individual and organizational level. This ensures that the school remains agile, adaptive, and always in pursuit of excellence.

For example, the new assistant principal noticed that while teachers were deeply dedicated, there was limited space for introspection and recalibration. Recognizing the value of reflective practices, she introduced the "Reflective Journal" initiative.

Each teacher was provided a simple journal. The intent wasn’t for it to be another grading tool, but a private space for self-reflection. At the end of each week, teachers were encouraged to jot down their successes, challenges, and any 'aha!' moments they experienced.

To bolster this practice, the assistant principal initiated monthly "Reflection Circles." In these gatherings, teachers could, if they chose to, share insights from their journals. The emphasis was not on critique but on collective learning and growth. Questions such as "What surprised you this month?" or "Which strategy will you revisit?" spurred deep, constructive conversations.

The impact of this initiative was profound. Teachers began to approach their challenges not as isolated incidents but as opportunities for growth. The reflection circles became a treasure trove of shared experiences, where strategies were discussed, refined, and sometimes, reinvented. Inspired by the success with the faculty, the assistant principal introduced reflective journals for students, fostering a school-wide culture of introspection.

By championing reflective practices, the assistant principal ensured that the school remained dynamic, always learning from its journey, always striving for better. Through continuous reflection, the middle school became a bastion of adaptive learning, resilience, and pursuit of educational excellence.

Coaching, in its various stances, offers a versatile toolkit for educational leaders. By embracing these stances, school leaders can drive meaningful and lasting school improvement. However, this requires a shift from traditional top-down leadership models to more collaborative, inclusive, and reflective practices. When leaders step into the shoes of a coach, they pave the way for a vibrant, resilient, and high-performing educational community. As the saying goes, "Give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime." Similarly, by coaching our educational leaders, we are not just improving schools for today but ensuring their excellence for generations to come.

References & Future Readings

Aguilar, E. (2013). The art of coaching: Effective strategies for school transformation. Jossey-Bass.

Bloom, G., Castagna, C., Moir, E., & Warren, B. (2005). Blended coaching: Skills and strategies to support principal development. Corwin Press.

Goff, P., Guthrie, J. E., Goldring, E., & Bickman, L. (2014). Changing principals' leadership through feedback and coaching. Journal of Educational Administration, 52(5), 682-704.

Knight, J. (2007). Instructional coaching: A partnership approach to improving instruction. Corwin Press.

Lochmiller, C. R. (2016). Exploring principal development through reflective coaching with a principal supervisor. Journal of Research on Leadership Education, 11(1), 26-49.

Neumerski, C. M. (2013). Rethinking instructional leadership, a review: What do we know about principal, teacher, and coach instructional leadership, and where should we go from here? Educational Administration Quarterly, 49(2), 310-347.

Read about How a District Level Leader Used a Coaching Stance and Established Collaborative Instructional Structures with her Leadership Team to Transform Her District in Leading Change for Diverse Learners: Transforming the Matrix of Your School System .