Cloak of Power: Thailand's Affinity for Unarmed Warships

Cloak of Power: Thailand's Affinity for Unarmed Warships

History repeats! Thailand's newest flagship HTMS Chang was commissioned in 2023. This multifunctional carrier cost the Royal Thai Navy fifty per cent of its annual budget - without weapons, of course!

These are to be installed at some point as soon as there's money left over - in other words, never, if we take Thailand's previous command flagship as reference.

This one is called HTMS Chakri Naruebet and was commissioned in 1997. It's also a multifunctional vessel and spends an average of one day a month sailing around Bangkok Bay largely unarmed.

They were never liquid, which is why they were forced to forego the luxury of owning a warship with full armoury.

Really?

What stratagem does the Royal Thai Navy use?

Number 1, “Fool the emperor by crossing the sea”. The aim is to distract from the actual target (Leonhardt 2023).

The Royal Thai Navy has no money. This sentence can be carved in stone, as the organisation has an annual budget of USD 400 million to maintain 130 ships and 70,000 personnel (Axe 2021). This must be enough for everything from cleaning rags to gun powder, while at the same time they have big plans to buy more (expensive war) ships (Chacko 2023; Wassana 2024).

Therefore, Covid or the Asian financial crisis do not play a major role in the fleet's budget planning: although they lead to temporary budget reductions, these crises are mainly used to justify internationally why it's currently not possible to upgrade the ships with military equipment.

Instead, they do business as usual: new warships are bought or built that are equipped with everything except the weaponry required for combat missions. On the one hand, this saves a lot of money, and on the other hand, neither the Chinese nor other neighbouring states perceive them as a threat, while still treating them as a regional power (On Demand Journalism 2023; The Cove 2021; SCMP Reporter 1998).

The important thing for Thailand is not whether it can fight at any time, but that it possesses the necessary infrastructure and can upgrade it relatively quickly and easily. After all, all the connectors are there.

It was exactly the same with the Chakri Naruebet: they bought an aircraft carrier without anything but the basics (Pike 2021). Aircraft ready for scrap were supplied cheaply at the time. They were maintained until there were no spare parts available. The Matadors were then decommissioned and mothballed (Suttichart 2017). It wasn't a loss, they weren't required anyway.

The Chakri Naruebet and the Chang pursue the same mission objectives: to provide humanitarian aid in the event of climate disasters. Otherwise, they rescue shipwrecked refugees or tackle smugglers and pirates (Chacko 2023; On Demand Journalism 2023; Asian Military Review 2023).

There isn't much to do, as the ship is almost always anchored in Sattahip's harbour (Wassana 2015), where it serves as a tourist attraction and thus earns a few bucks, while at the same time being kept operational and in good condition (Newdick 2022). After all, you never know what tomorrow will bring.

Conclusion

To summarise, Thailand is pursuing a defensive, reactive strategy that allows it to adapt and expand its military capabilities without causing unnecessary provocation or stirring up regional tensions. This gives Thailand a certain flexibility in its defence policy, making it possible to react tactically to internal and external changes. The Royal Thai Navy thus positions itself as a potentially strong but cautious force that conceals its true strength and intentions until really needed.


Stratagems

Thailand's policy of using economic crises as an excuse to plausibly avoid equipping its warships is in line with Stratagem 5, “Exploit a conflagration for a heist”. In doing so, you use chaos to your advantage (Senger 1993: 67-74). Their procedure of neutrally observing the external political situation and keeping their own capacities concealed corresponds to number 9, “Observe the fire on the opposite shore”. This means passively observing what's happening in order to draw conclusions and, if possible, gain advantages (Senger 1992: 156-161).


Sources

  1. Asian Military Review (2023): New Frigate (HTMS Chang) by Royal Thai Navy presents an opportunity for Defence Industry. Press Release. In: Asian Military Review Magazine, 18.05.2024. Online under https://www.asianmilitaryreview.com/2023/05/new-figate-htms-chang-by-royal-thai-navy-presents-an-opportunity-for-defence-industry/, last checked on 07.01.2025.
  2. Axe, David (2021): The World’s Weirdest Aircraft Carrier Just Reappeared Near Singapore. In: Forbes, 31.03.2021. Online under https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2021/03/31/the-worlds-weirdest-aircraft-carrier-just-reappeared-near-singapore/?sh=1b8763f2f9f5, last checked on 29.04.2024.
  3. Chacko, Joseph P. (2023): Thailand receives HTMS Chang, a modified Type 071 dock landing ship from China. Military. In: frontier India, 27.04.2023. Online under https://frontierindia.com/thailand-receives-first-htms-chang-a-modified-type-071-dock-landing-ship-from-china/, last checked on 08.01.2025.
  4. Leonhardt, Walter (2023): The 36 Stratagems westernized analyzed. Stratagem 1: Deception. 12.12.2023. Updated 28.12.2023. Ulan Bator: The Tenth Man in Reality (Think Tank).
  5. Newdick, Thomas (2022): The Harriers are gone but Thailand’s unlikely aircraft carrier sails on. In: The War Zone, 12.08.2022. Online under https://www.twz.com/the-harriers-are-gone-but-thailands-unlikely-aircraft-carrier-sails-on, last checked on 29.04.2024.
  6. On Demand Journalism (2023): Why doesn’t Thailand sell its aircraft carrier to a country that could probably make better use out of it like Turkey, Pakistan, or Brazil? In: Quora, 2023. Online under https://www.quora.com/Why-doesn-t-Thailand-sell-its-aircraft-carrier-to-a-country-that-could-probably-make-better-use-out-of-it-like-Turkey-Pakistan-or-Brazil, last checked on 02.05.2024.
  7. Our Bureau (2024): Royal Thai Navy Anoints HTMS Chang LPD. Aerospace & Defence. In: Global Business Press, 20.05.2024. Online under https://gbp.com.sg/stories/royal-thai-navy-anoints-htms-chang-lpd/, last checked on 20.05.2024.
  8. Pike, John (2015): Chakri Naruebet (OPHC) Aircraft Carrier. Last updated 30.09.2015. Online under https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/thailand/chakri-naruebet.htm, last checked on 29.04.2024.
  9. SCMP Reporter (1998): Aircraft carrier a ?white elephant?. In: South China Morning Post, 16.02.1998. Online under https://amp.scmp.com/article/230006/aircraft-carrier-white-elephant, last checked on 02.05.2024.
  10. Senger, Harro von (1993): The Book of Stratagems. Tactics for Triumph and Survival. Under participation of Myron B. Gubitz. New York, NY: Penguin Books.
  11. Suttichart, Denpreuktham (2017): Why does Thailand have an aircraft carrier? In: Quora, 2017. Online under https://www.quora.com/Why-does-Thailand-have-an-aircraft-carrier, last checked on 30.04.2024.
  12. The Cove (2021): KYR: Thailand – Military. In: The Cove, 12.06.2024. Online under https://cove.army.gov.au/article/kyr-thailand-military, last checked on 02.05.2024.
  13. Wassana, Nanuam (2015): ?Chakri Naruebet? gets new lease of life. Special Report. In: Bangkok Post, 24.12.2015. Online under https://www.bangkokpost.com/thailand/special-reports/804852/chakri-naruebet-gets-new-lease-of-life, last checked on 29.04.2024.
  14. Wassana, Nanuam (2024): Budget rejection ?won’t halt? navy’s frigate purchase plan. In: Bangkok Post, 08.05.2024. Online under https://www.bangkokpost.com/thailand/general/2755411/budget-rejection-wont-halt-navys-frigate-purchase-plan, last checked on 07.06.2024.

#36stratagems


要查看或添加评论,请登录

Walter LEONHARDT的更多文章

  • Currywurstgate

    Currywurstgate

    Anns an Lùnastal 2021, thug bòrd Volkswagen air falbh a’ Currywurst bhon chafaidh aig prìomh-oifisean a’ chompanaidh…

  • Penny Lane: Breaking Bad News

    Penny Lane: Breaking Bad News

    I mí an Mheithimh 2020, bhí scéal faoi Penny Lane i Learpholl i mbéal an phobail ar fud an domhain. Deirtear gur…

  • Ryu Asada – An Ceardaí a D’imir idir Domhain

    Ryu Asada – An Ceardaí a D’imir idir Domhain

    Bhí clú agus cáil ar Ryu Asada mar dhearthóir diecast agus mar dhuine ar leith ar fud an domhain. Ach i ndáiríre, ní…

  • Mohd, an t-iascaire daoine

    Mohd, an t-iascaire daoine

    Is earcaitheoir pearsanta Indiach é Mohd Shahrukh, a dhíríonn ar fhostaithe a mhealladh ó chuideachtaí eile. Tá a mhodh…

  • Jack Out of the Box: Cratur’s Foolproof Escape

    Jack Out of the Box: Cratur’s Foolproof Escape

    Cratur was a prisoner who was interned with Gerry Adams in Northern Ireland's Long Kesh. He played the lunatic to…

    1 条评论
  • Pretty Preddie & Travel + Leisure’s Cocktail Mix

    Pretty Preddie & Travel + Leisure’s Cocktail Mix

    Nowadays, thinking about media content is called “critical journalism”. If you add external sources, you're instantly…

  • Power Without People – The Price Is Solitude

    Power Without People – The Price Is Solitude

    Last week we had a huge dispute in the family: my three-year-old son didn't want to share the marbles with his twin…

  • Fergie's Foresight for Customer Loyalty

    Fergie's Foresight for Customer Loyalty

    When Sir Alex Ferguson was still a publican in Govan, a customer came into 'Fergie's' one day offering a new pair of…

  • No Farewell, my Lovelies

    No Farewell, my Lovelies

    Naim Attalah was the loyalty magnet of British publishing world and a pioneer of personnel management. With Jennie…

  • The Digital Abstinence Trap: Why Avoiding Media Does More Harm Than Good

    The Digital Abstinence Trap: Why Avoiding Media Does More Harm Than Good

    My friends' children are eight and ten years old and grew up without media at home. Instead, they were kept busy with…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了