Choosing the Right Accounting Qualification: CA vs ACCA Vs CMA (ICMAB) vs CMA (CIMA)

You've taken the thrilling step of pursuing an advanced accounting degree, and now you're confronted with the choice between various accounting degrees. The most popular ones in Bangladesh are:

• Chartered Accountant (CA) from The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB) .
• Chartered Certified Accountant ( ACCA ) from Association of Chartered Certified Accountants,
• Cost & Management Accountant (CMA) from The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Bangladesh (ICMAB) ;
• Chartered Management Accountant (CMA) from Chartered Institute of Management Accountants ( CIMA ).

In this blog, I will attempt to delve into the distinctions among CA, ACCA, and CMA (ICMAB), CMA (CIMA) aiding you in identifying which one aligns more closely with your career goals. It's essential to keep in mind that these insights are purely my personal observations working in Bangladesh, and may vary significantly depending on whom you consult.

Chartered Accountant (CA) from The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB).

Pros:

Wider local recognition: The CA qualification holds an unquestioned reputation as the pinnacle of achievement in the field of accounting in Bangladesh. It is also acknowledged in major economies worldwide, giving you the opportunity to apply your skills and expertise internationally. However, it's essential to verify whether ICAB has established a memorandum of understanding with the accounting body of your chosen destination before planning to work or practice there.

Master of Multiple Disciplines: CAs are like the Swiss Army knives of the accounting world – they're experts in auditing, taxation, accounting, and financial management.

Regulator's Best Friend: If you fancy keeping a close eye on compliance and making sure everyone's playing by the financial rules, the CA's the way to go.

Fancy Status and Fat Paychecks: With a CA, you can expect a prestigious title and a bank account to match.

Public Practice: CAs have the option to engage in public practice, which allows them to serve a wide range of clients and industries.

Cons:

Long and Winding Road: Getting your CA is like a long winding walk up a steep mountain – it's tough, time-consuming, and not for the faint of heart. The curriculum is demanding, with extensive examinations, requiring years of dedication.

Full-time Training Requirement: Just like legal associates in apprenticeships, aspiring CAs must complete a rigorous three-year full-time training period called “articleship”, during which they work under the guidance of a principal at an audit firm. This means that individuals undergoing this training cannot pursue full-time employment simultaneously.

Chartered Certified Accountant (ACCA) from Association of Chartered Certified Accountants

Pros:

Global Reach: ACCA is recognized in over 180 countries, making it a versatile qualification for international career opportunities. So, if you're dreaming of an international career, this is your ticket.

Options: ACCA gives you the power to choose your specialization – think of it as a menu where you can pick your favorites, be it audit, taxation, or financial management.

Business Acumen: ACCA focuses on business and management skills, making it ideal for roles beyond traditional accounting.

Faster completion: You can complete the ACCA qualification faster than CA (you need to be committed, of course), potentially expediting your entry into the job market.

Vibrant network: ACCA has stepped up their game in member engagement and network visibility. Upon achieving qualification, you will become a valued member of this dynamic and active network.

Cons:

Practical exposure: Through there are Practical Experience (PER) requirements, ACCA candidates do not get the depth of practical exposure as a CA student during their training.

Competition: Global recognition means global competition. You'll need to bring your A-game in the job market.

Cost & Management Accountant (CMA) from Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Bangladesh (ICMAB)

Cost Leadership: CMAs specialize in management accounting, which is all about financial strategy, risk management, and decision-making.

Express Lane: You can fast-track your way to becoming a CMA, which means you can start your career sooner. There are no long term training or PER requirement.

Close knit network: CMA is a close-knit community of professionals who share common goals and interests. This network will offer a sense of camaraderie, support, and collaboration for your career growth and development.

Employment and Education: Similar to ACCA, individuals can pursue the CMA designation while working full-time jobs.

Rising demand: As expenses continue to rise and affect company's bottom line, management is increasingly scrutinizing cost components. This focus has generated a growing demand for CMAs.

Cons:

Focus on cost: The CMA certification places a stronger emphasis on costing and may not offer the same versatility as the CA or ACCA qualifications if you are seeking a broader array of career opportunities.

Corporate Champ: CMAs are typically a better fit for corporate and management roles, so it might not be your cup of tea if you aim to go into public practice or broader financial sectors.

Chartered Management Accountant (CMA), from Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA)

Pros:

Master of Strategy: CMAs specialize in management accounting, which is all about financial strategy, risk management, and decision-making.

Comprehensive and up-to-date curriculum: The CIMA syllabus is known for its depth and diversity, regularly refreshed to align with the latest industry advancements and emerging trends. The curriculum focuses on real-world applications, equipping you with practical skills that can be immediately applied in your job.

Shared recognition: The merger between CIMA and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) has established the largest global network of accountants. Consequently, CIMA members have practicing rights in the United States.

Chartered Global Management Accountant (CGMA) Designation: CIMA members automatically qualify for the CGMA designation, further enhancing their professional standing and recognition worldwide.

Faster completion: Just like ACCA, it's possible to achieve the CMA qualification at a quicker pace compared to the CA route.

Cons:

Limited local awareness: Due to the absence of dedicated CIMA presence in Bangladesh, the general awareness and recognition of the qualification are comparatively lower when compared to other certifications.

Not for accounting purists: If you have a strong inclination towards traditional financial accounting, CIMA may not align with your preferences. The CIMA curriculum predominantly focuses on areas such as strategy and risk management, rather than catering to those seeking specialization in financial accounting.

So, which accounting qualification suits you best?

The decision ultimately comes down to your career goals and personal preferences. Research each qualification thoroughly, consider your long-term goals, and consult with professionals who have these designations to make an informed choice that aligns with your ambitions.

Happy accounting adventures!

?