Choosing Between EDGE and LEED Certification.

Choosing Between EDGE and LEED Certification.


Deciding between EDGE (Excellence in Design for Greater Efficiencies) and LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) depends on your project’s needs. Each has its strengths, especially in regions like Asia and the GCC. Here’s a quick guide to help you choose the right one.

?

1. Cost: EDGE is Cheaper

Cost is a major factor, and EDGE is much more affordable:

  • EDGE costs between $1,000 to $8,000, with an average of $4,000 for typical projects in Asia or the GCC.
  • LEED is more expensive, often exceeding $20,000.

If budget is a concern, EDGE is the more cost-effective choice for most projects.

?

2. Speed: EDGE is Quicker

EDGE certification is faster to achieve:

  • It takes around 6-8 weeks to get certified.
  • LEED can take several months, sometimes up to a year.

If you’re on a tight deadline, EDGE is the quicker option.

?

3. Efficiency Targets: EDGE is Clear

EDGE sets clear, easy-to-reach goals:

  • It requires a 20% improvement in energy, water, and materials.
  • LEED often targets more than 30%, but uses a complex point system.

EDGE’s 20% target is more straightforward, especially in markets with fewer resources.

?

4. Market Focus: EDGE is for Emerging Markets

EDGE is built for emerging markets like Asia and the GCC:

  • It works well for affordable housing and commercial buildings in these regions.
  • LEED is better for high-end projects in developed markets.

For projects in growing regions, EDGE is often the best fit.

?

Visual Comparison: EDGE vs LEED

Here’s a simple chart showing key differences between EDGE and LEED:

  • Cost: EDGE costs around $4,000, LEED can go up to $20,000.
  • Speed: EDGE takes 6-8 weeks, LEED takes over 26 weeks.
  • Energy Efficiency: EDGE targets 20%, LEED often aims for 30% or more.
  • Market Focus: EDGE is best for emerging markets, while LEED fits developed countries.

?

Conclusion: Which One to Choose?

For projects in Asia or the GCC, EDGE is usually the better choice. It’s cheaper, quicker, and designed for emerging markets. LEED is better suited for larger, high-end projects that need global recognition.

Choose based on your budget, timeline, and goals.

Noman Asghar

Environmental and Sustainability Manager| LEED GA | Redsea Global Approved | ISO 14001:2015

5 个月

Both EDGE and LEED offer valuable pathways for sustainable building, but the choice depends on your project's goals. LEED provides a comprehensive approach with global recognition and broader sustainability metrics, while EDGE is more focused on cost-efficient green building, especially in emerging markets. It’s not about which is better—it’s about which system aligns with your project’s specific needs and sustainability goals.

回复
Joseph John

Project Manager

5 个月

I think that despite the similarity they share, i.e. objective and progressive sustainability, they are at the same time different. LEED has a higher complexity as compared to EDGE, and from my understanding EDGE has been established for emerging markets, hence an entry point to the concept of sustainability for developing countries. Comparing the two is a disservice as they both strive to achieve the same goal objective at different starting points.

Imran Khurshid

Environmental & Sustainability Engineer (LEED GA, IEMA)

5 个月

I agree

回复
Bill Schreiber

Contract Consultant to the Plastics and Rubber Industries.

5 个月

Very helpful

Mohammed Sufiyan

Sustainability Consultant -LEED, IGBC & GRIHA | Active score & Mode score AP | Climate Change | Civil Engineer | Contracts

5 个月

Insightful

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Muhammad Umar LEED AP的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了