The Cherry on top for Business Owners and CRE Investors

Unveiling the Power of Partial Asset Disposition and Cost Segregation

When it comes to owning real estate or business property, there's more than meets the eye. Beyond the bricks and mortar, there are clever tax strategies that shrewd investors and business owners can employ to maximize their financial benefits. Partial Asset Disposition (PAD) is probably the most recent tax strategy to grace property owners' pocketbooks, even though it has been around since 2014. PAD is the cherry on top of additional tax savings, especially when utilized in a Cost Segregation study.

The Backstory: Partial Asset Disposition

To understand Partial Asset Disposition, we need to take a step back in time. Before its introduction, property owners faced a tax dilemma when they made significant changes or improvements to their assets. Under the traditional rules, any replacement, retirement, or disposal of an asset had to be accounted for as an overall change in the property's value, making it subject to depreciation schedules that often stretched over several decades.

In 2014, the IRS recognized the need for a change. They introduced the concept of Partial Asset Disposition (PAD) as part of the Tangible Property Regulations (more on this concept down the road). This allowed property owners to recognize a loss when a portion of an asset was disposed of or replaced, creating a more accurate reflection of the asset's true value.

?The Essentials of Partial Asset Disposition

So, how does Partial Asset Disposition work?

Let's say you own a commercial building, and the HVAC system, which is a significant part of the property, needs to be replaced due to wear and tear. Under PAD, you can identify and retire the old HVAC system as a separate asset. This allows you to recognize a loss equal to the remaining undepreciated value of the old system. By recognizing this loss, you reduce your taxable income, leading to immediate tax savings. This tax-optimized approach also enables you to align your asset's value with its real-world condition.

Understanding when to apply PAD:

Imagine you own a $5 million hotel, and you plan to invest $1 million in renovations a year after placing the building into service. A crucial point to remember is that it is not advised to perform a PAD in the same year you put the property into service. Instead, the asset must be in service for its intended purpose for at least one tax year before you can take advantage of the PAD. The reason for this requirement is to avoid conveying to the government that the assets being removed during renovation are worthless.

For instance, if you purchased the hotel for $5 million in 2023 and decide to undertake a $1 million renovation in 2024, you've met the necessary waiting period to consider a partial asset disposition. This requirement is in place to ensure that assets removed during renovations are not prematurely deemed worthless by the government, as these assets still hold value and can provide immediate write-offs.

The "Use It or Lose It" Provision

One critical aspect of PAD is the "use it or lose it" provision. If you complete the renovation in 2023, you must take the PAD in the same year. Delaying it until the following year, such as 2024, means forfeiting this opportunity permanently.

A partial asset disposition will also yield permanent tax savings at the time of sale by reducing the building basis. This means NO RECAPTURE TAX on Section 1245 components.?

There’s Gold in them Dumpsters!

As outlined earlier, it is not advised to perform a Partial Asset Disposition (PAD) in the same year that a property is acquired and placed in service. PAD is used to account for the removal or replacement of specific assets within a property after it has been in service for some time.

Here's why:

1. Depreciation Start Date: When you acquire and place a property in service, you start depreciating the entire property or its components as a whole. In the year of acquisition, you may not have accumulated any depreciation on the individual components or assets that you would later consider for PAD.
2. Identification of Replaced Assets: Partial asset disposition involves identifying specific assets within the property that are being retired or replaced. This identification typically occurs after some years of ownership when these assets have been in service, depreciated, and are now being removed or replaced.
3. Adjusting Basis: PAD involves adjusting the basis of the property to remove the value of the assets being retired or replaced. This adjustment is necessary to accurately calculate depreciation going forward. This adjustment is typically done in the tax year following the year of the removal or replacement.

So, you generally need to wait until the following year to make the improvements or replacements and then implement a partial asset disposition in the same year renovations have been completed. The idea is to account for the depreciation on specific assets up to the year of its removal or replacement and then adjust the basis accordingly.

PAD in Detail:

1. Identification of Disposed Assets: The first step in implementing PAD is to identify and document the specific assets or components of a property that are being disposed of, retired, or replaced. These could include items like roofing systems, HVAC units, machinery, or any other substantial component that is part of a larger property.
2. Separate Valuation: Once the disposed assets are identified, they should be valued separately from the overall property. This valuation determines the remaining undepreciated basis of the disposed assets. In other words, it quantifies the loss associated with the retired components.
3. Tax Deduction: The recognized loss on the disposed assets can then be deducted from your taxable income in the year in which the disposition occurs. This deduction provides immediate tax savings, effectively lowering your tax liability for that year.
4. Documentation: Proper documentation is critical when implementing PAD. You need to maintain records that clearly show the assets disposed of, their original cost, the cost of the replacement or retirement, and the calculation of the loss. Thorough documentation ensures you can substantiate your claims in case of an IRS audit.
5. Compliance with Tax Regulations: It's essential to comply with the specific rules and regulations surrounding PAD, as outlined in the IRS Tangible Property Regulations (Treasury Regulation Section 1.263(a)-1). These regulations provide guidance on what constitutes a partial disposition, how to calculate the loss and the documentation requirements.

So, What Qualifies for PAD?

• Roof Repairs
• Replacing Lighting
• Resurfacing Parking Lots
• Replacing Doors and Windows
• Resurfacing Interior or External Floors
• Painting (Interior or Exterior)
• Replacement of HVAC
• Tenant space configurations or allocations
• Common area renovations

Advantages of PAD:

Now, let's explore some of the advantages of utilizing Partial Asset Disposition:

1. Immediate Tax Savings: Significant tax savings, enhancing your cash flow.
2. Accurate Asset Valuation: Up-to-date records of your property's value is beneficial for tax purposes but also for financial reporting, insurance claims, and making informed investment decisions.
3. Tax Planning and Optimization: Recognizing losses through PAD can be strategically timed to offset gains from other investments or income.
4. Exit Strategy: A PAD study allows you to remove assets from your books without incurring recapture tax.

?

But How do you figure out the value of my disposed-of contents?

The IRS defines the use of 3 “reasonable methods”

1. Producer Price Index: Discount cost of replacement portion of the asset to its placed in-service year cost using PPI
2. Replacement Cost: Pro rata allocation of the unadjusted depreciable basis of the asset based on the replacement cost
3. Cost Segregation Study: Cost Seg study allocates the cost of the asset to the individual components

Now bring these two together and you create Magic!

If you have been following my previous newsletters, you know that I am a huge proponent of cost segregation.

Again, Cost Segregation is not a new concept

It appeals to property owners as it allows businesses to segregate and depreciate specific components of their buildings over shorter periods, such as 5, 7, or 15 years, rather than the traditional 27.5 or 39 years. When these accelerated items are coupled with Bonus depreciation- Huge tax savings can be realized and utilized to reduce taxable income.

The Role of Cost Segregation Firms

A vital step in the PAD process involves hiring a cost segregation firm to evaluate the assets being removed during renovations. For instance, let's say you dispose of $100,000 worth of depreciable assets. At a 37% tax bracket, this translates to a substantial $37,000 in income tax savings. Moreover, capitalizing on immediate write-offs can lead to further tax savings, as you can also write off disposal and removal costs. This tax strategy can also prove beneficial if you plan to sell the building in the future. By removing these assets from your books, you eliminate the risk of recapture tax, potentially saving you even more in the long run.

?A Real-World Example

Let's put it all together with a real-world example. Imagine you have purchased a $2 million commercial building, and you decide to utilize both Partial Asset Disposition and Cost Segregation. Here's how it might look:

You purchased the building in 2020 and completed renovations in 2021. You perform a cost segregation analysis the same year and the firm informs you that the renovations put in place also qualify for partial asset disposition.

1. Partial Asset Disposition: Suppose you replace the aging roof of the building at a cost of $500,000. By recognizing the loss on the old roof, (at a 37% tax bracket) this translates to a substantial $185,000 in income tax savings!
2. Cost Segregation: After a thorough cost segregation study is performed, it's determined that $300,000 of the building's value can be reclassified as shorter-lived assets, like HVAC systems, lighting, flooring, and fixtures. These can be depreciated over 5 and 15 years. This shift in depreciation schedules can provide an additional deduction of around $110,000 for the year for tax purposes.

By combining these strategies, you can potentially save an additional significant amount on your tax bill while maintaining accurate records of your property's value and condition. Without the added benefit of PAD in this scenario, the owner may just be walking away with the $300,000 tax deferral from the cost seg study. By utilizing PAD, this owner defers their tax liability by $300,000 with Cost Seg and effectively reduces their current year's taxes by an additional $185,000.

Let's wrap it up and put a bow on it

Partial Asset Disposition is a powerful tax strategy that can help property owners reap substantial benefits when renovating their buildings. By understanding the waiting period, leveraging cost segregation firms, and adhering to the "use it or lose it" provision, you can optimize your tax position and potentially save significant sums over time. Partial Asset Disposition and Cost Segregation are valuable tools that can help business owners and real estate investors optimize their tax savings, improve cash flow, and enhance the return on their investments. These strategies, when used wisely, allow you to align your tax treatment with the real value and condition of your assets, providing immediate financial benefits. PAD can be applied with a cost segregation study as long as the renovations were made after the first year the building was placed in service. As always, it is best to consult with tax professionals or advisors experienced in these strategies to ensure compliance with tax regulations and maximize your benefits. In the world of taxes, knowledge is power, and these strategies can be a powerful tool in your financial arsenal.