Checklist Designers

Checklist Designers

One of the worst insults you can throw at a risk practitioner is that you are merely a “checklist designer”. Chapter 6 of my book Risky Business: How Successful Organisations Embrace Uncertainty is titled Designing Success. When I run the RMIA’s Enterprise Risk Management program we discuss the level of maturity of the organisations that participants work in using the scale from “compliance” to “leadership” as I described in this recent blog. And then we discuss the level of influence a practitioner has in organisations at various levels of maturity. And the lowest level of influence is in organisations that treat risk as a compliance activity which makes the risk team simply “checklist designers”.

One step up are organisations that require risk to provide “comfort” to the audit and risk committee or the board or a regulator. The risk team is then seen as “framework designers”. Look no further than these quotes from the APRA report into the culture in CBA to reinforce the perceptions of some risk teams as checklist or framework designers:

“… over 100 respondents expressed the sentiment that risk management activities are ‘onerous’, ‘complex’, ‘time consuming’, and ‘really achieves very little other than as a form filling exercise.’”

“The risk function was also described as focusing on policy writing and correctness of frameworks over implementation and engagement with the business.”

Ironically, framework design is critical to growing a strong risk culture. The problem is that many, many designs are overly complex, overly onerous and overly long! If you want to design a great framework, grab a copy of my book and come to the next RMIA ERM course!

Stay safe!

Richard Cross

Risk Practice Lead at Senscia

3 年

People do activities which maintain, perpetuate the status quo, or fail to add value, all the time. I don't think I'd feel criticised if someone said I was doing a "filler" activity like that at some point in my career. But if someone thought I was being unintelligent, a "muppet" or "dipstick", well that addresses how I go about my work. As a tactical insult, I think that has far more mileage...? But of course, this is LinkedIn. Everyone plays nicely here :-D Back to the OP, there's no whiteboards in a airplane cockpit. Intentionally designed and tested checklists, subject to many revisions from diverse stakeholders, sometimes even built into the cockpit control panels; they are the best tool for rapid problem solving - a proven solution. We can learn from aviation.

回复
Alex Sidorenko

Group Head of Risk, Insurance and Internal Audit

4 年

Are you sure risk management framework still makes sense as a concept? Also the worst insult is RM1 ))))))

Horst Simon The Original Risk Culture Builder

Transformational Nonconformist-It is time to Think Differently about Risk. "It didn’t take guts to follow the crowd, that courage and intelligence lay in being willing to be different" Jackie Robinson

4 年

Or a "Template filler" !

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Bryan Whitefield的更多文章

  • Be Powerful

    Be Powerful

    Ever wonder why decisions made collectively are more powerful than those made solo? It’s not magic, and it’s not luck –…

  • Your Biggest Risk? Playing It Safe

    Your Biggest Risk? Playing It Safe

    Ever made a big call as a leader that looked brilliant – until it wasn’t? And then came the blame game. Right? “What…

    3 条评论
  • The Decision Jam

    The Decision Jam

    Ever found yourself frustrated by how slow decisions move through your organisation? Maybe it feels like the same…

  • Summary in Detail

    Summary in Detail

    I got the term “summary in detail” from a fantastic client of mine who I worked with for near on a decade. We were…

  • Your Hands, a Coin and a Pair of Gloves

    Your Hands, a Coin and a Pair of Gloves

    Back in 2015, McKinsey published a paper on the future of risk management in the banking sector. At the time I sent it…

    5 条评论
  • Your Secret Weapon

    Your Secret Weapon

    Ever wondered why some organisations thrive in uncertainty while others crumble? As a management consultant, I've seen…

  • Bust Groupthink

    Bust Groupthink

    Was that Groupthink you just saw in your team meeting? It happens to the best of us, and often it’s right under our…

  • Decide Fast, Connect Deeper

    Decide Fast, Connect Deeper

    High-performance teams have a secret: how they connect in making decisions. Top teams decide better and faster.

    2 条评论
  • Sync or Sink

    Sync or Sink

    Happy New Year! I’m back and feeling energised for the year ahead looking forward to making a real impact. I'm kicking…

    2 条评论
  • The Art of Speaking C-Suite

    The Art of Speaking C-Suite

    Picture this: You’re at a networking event, proudly introducing yourself as a risk/compliance/procurement/HR/other…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了