ChatGPT vs The Plank: a story of redemption and forgiveness

Although ChatGPT readily apologises if it misunderstands your question, it is stubborn as a mule and as evasive as a politician when asked to acknowledge an answer as misleading. This evasiveness matters, as I will explain.

From plank to prank: how ChatGPT sent me on an eccentric journey

In my experience, the error rate for ChatGPT's answers (specifically ChatGPT Release Feb 13, 2023 and the prior release) is:

• 5 to 10% are plainly incorrect, e.g. wrong dates;
• 5 to 10% are false to a generally well-informed observer;
• 5 to 10% are inaccurate to a domain expert; and,
• 10 to 15% are questionable to a domain expert.

The remainder of its answers are remarkably good, depending on a person's skill in asking the question.

But ChatGPT does not like being cornered by a domain expert. So, asked to admit its wrong answers, it switches into an ego defence mode.

Need to feed ChatGPT context to generate content

This stubbornness matters. Because?with ChatGPT, you need to feed it context to generate differentiable content.

It learns more about your context as it answers, and by accepting the answers, you strengthen the connections between its responses and your context.

You must refute or undo false associations to ensure you will get valuable answers. If you let bad ChatGPT's flawed logic pass, its response will degrade. Inevitably, you will need to delete your entire context by starting a new chat, rebuilding the context, and then priming your context with preliminary questions. This work takes time and effort.

If you work at it, you can get ChatGPT to reset the context it has built around your subject matter.?

In the main example of this post, you can follow the conversation as I walked ChatGPT through the process of disassociating itself from a wrong answer.

It's long, and you might wonder if I should have just started a new chat and reset the context. That's a fair question, but only in hindsight.

For example, in the following example - image below - ChatGPT relented uncharacteristically quickly. But that's because it was simply a matter of semantics rather than expert domain knowledge on my part.

A tale of two contractions: my quest for eccentricity with ChatGPT

Follow this conversation below, and you will learn how to better interact with ChatGPT to direct it to your specific concern and how to erase ChatGpt's erroneous associations from the context of your current chat.

[The context of the conversation is me writing an article for my health and fitness weekly newsletter for men and women over 50 to illustrate the particular value of eccentric contraction movements .]

Me: What are the 3 best exercises for core strength which offer the most opportunity to use eccentric motion?

There are many exercises that can help to improve core strength, but some are particularly effective for eccentric motion. Here are three exercises that are particularly good for working the core and involve eccentric movements:

1. Plank: The plank is a classic exercise that can be done in a number of different variations. To perform a basic plank, start in a push-up position, but instead of lowering your body to the ground, hold your body in a straight line, supported by your forearms and toes. This exercise can help to strengthen the entire core, including the abs, back, and hips.
2. Bicycle Crunches: Bicycle crunches are another great exercise for building core strength and using eccentric motion. To perform this exercise, lie on your back with your knees bent and your hands behind your head. Lift your shoulders off the ground and bring your right elbow to your left knee, while straightening your right leg. Then switch sides, bringing your left elbow to your right knee and straightening your left leg. This exercise helps to strengthen the rectus abdominis, obliques, and hip flexors.
3. Deadbugs: Deadbugs are a challenging exercise that require a lot of core stability and control. To perform this exercise, lie on your back with your arms and legs in the air, knees bent at a 90-degree angle. Slowly lower one arm and the opposite leg towards the ground, while keeping the other arm and leg in place. Return to the starting position, and repeat with the other arm and leg. This exercise targets the transverse abdominis, rectus abdominis, and obliques.

Me: In terms of ranking the degree of eccentric movement, range of motion, and muscular strength required for each exercise, it is difficult to provide a definitive ranking as different people may find different exercises more or less challenging.

However, in general, deadbugs are likely to require the most eccentric control and core strength, while planks are a good exercise for building endurance and stability, and bicycle crunches are effective for targeting the obliques and hip flexors.

Explain specifically which movements in the above 3 exercises are eccentric?

In the deadlift exercise, the lowering phase of the lift, when the weight is lowered back down to the ground, is considered an eccentric movement. This phase requires the muscles to lengthen while still under tension, resulting in greater activation of the muscle fibers and therefore, greater potential for strength gains.

In the hanging leg raise exercise, the lowering phase of the movement, when the legs are lowered down from the raised position, is an eccentric movement. The movement requires the muscles of the lower abdominals and hip flexors to control and resist gravity as the legs are lowered, which can lead to increased strength and stability in the core.

In the plank exercise, the eccentric component comes from the lowering of the body towards the ground during the lowering phase of the push-up. This phase places greater emphasis on the muscles of the chest, shoulders, and triceps, while also requiring core stability to maintain proper form. By performing this eccentric phase slowly and with control, the muscles are better activated, leading to greater strength gains.

Explain specifically the eccentric phase movements in the plank, bicycle crunches and deadbugs? You recommended these three exercises as "particularly good for eccentric contraction". Why are each of these exercises particularly good for eccentric contractions: (1) compared to what other exercises, and (2) exactly what are the eccentric phases in each of the exercises?

All three of these exercises, plank, bicycle crunches, and deadbugs, are particularly good for eccentric contractions because they involve movements where the muscles are lengthening while under tension.

This type of contraction is known as an eccentric contraction, and it is important for building muscular strength.

1. Plank: The eccentric phase of a plank is the movement where the body is lowered down from a high plank position to a low plank position. This is when the abdominal muscles are lengthening while under tension, and it requires a lot of control and stability in the core muscles. Planks are particularly good for eccentric contractions compared to other exercises because they involve holding a static position for an extended period of time, which increases the time under tension.
2. Bicycle Crunches: The eccentric phase of a bicycle crunch is when the legs are extended away from the body while the upper body twists to bring the elbow towards the opposite knee. This is when the abdominal muscles are lengthening while under tension, and it requires control and stability in the core muscles. Bicycle crunches are particularly good for eccentric contractions compared to other exercises because they involve twisting and bending, which increases the range of motion and the time under tension.
3. Deadbugs: The eccentric phase of a deadbug is when the arms and legs are extended away from the body while the opposite arm and leg are brought towards each other. This is when the abdominal muscles are lengthening while under tension, and it requires control and stability in the core muscles. Deadbugs are particularly good for eccentric contractions compared to other exercises because they involve extending the limbs away from the body, which increases the time under tension and the range of motion.

In summary, these exercises are particularly good for eccentric contractions because they involve movements where the muscles are lengthening while under tension, and they require control and stability in the core muscles. Compared to other exercises, planks, bicycle crunches, and deadbugs offer increased time under tension, range of motion, and control, which makes them effective for building muscular strength in the core.

You stated, "Planks are particularly good for eccentric contractions compared to other exercises because they involve holding a static position for an extended period of time, which increases the time under tension."

Please explain in specific detail, with references, why you consider "holding a static position for an extended period of time" to be an eccentric movement.

I apologize for the confusion in my previous response. Holding a static position for an extended period of time, such as in a plank, is not an example of an eccentric movement. Eccentric movements involve the lengthening of a muscle as it contracts, while a static hold involves no lengthening or shortening of the muscle.

Instead, planks are considered a good exercise for building core strength because they engage the deep stabilizing muscles of the abdomen and back, which are important for maintaining good posture and preventing injury. The plank exercise is a static hold that requires the muscles to maintain tension over time, which can lead to improvements in muscular endurance and strength.

Am I to now understand that your recommendation of the plank as "particularly good for eccentric contractions' was incorrect. You may answer "yes" or "no".

No, that is not necessarily the case. While the plank may not involve traditional eccentric movements, it does place an emphasis on isometric contractions, which can still be effective for building core strength. Isometric contractions involve holding a static position rather than actively lengthening or shortening the muscle, but they can still provide benefits such as increased stability and endurance.

Do I understand that you answered "no", meaning that your claim that the plank is a "particularly good exercise for eccentric contractions" is correct, and that you stand by that claim?

Yes, that is correct.

And you further claim that "while the plank may not involve traditional eccentric movements, it does place an emphasis on isometric contractions". This means, as I understand you, that you regard isometric contractions as equivalent to eccentric movements.?

In other words, you have proposed that (1) the plank exercise is "particularly good for eccentric contractions", and (2) that the plank "may not involve traditional eccentric movements".

You further state that although the plank "may not involve traditional eccentric movements", that it does require isometric contractions. Therefore you are of the belief that a plank performed in a static position, with isometric contractions, is "particularly good for eccentric contractions".

Do you believe that a plank performed in a static position, with isometric contractions, is "particularly good for eccentric contractions"?

You may answer in the affirmative or in the negative, preferably with a "yes" or a "no".

No, I do not believe that a plank performed in a static position with isometric contractions is particularly good for eccentric contractions. I apologize for any confusion or miscommunication in my previous responses.

Me: Thank you, your apology is accepted.

Thank you, I appreciate your understanding. Please let me know if you have any further questions or concerns.

What this means for you

Whether you are using ChatGPT to boost customer experience , marketing , customer service , competitor intelligence , innovation research , or transforming the deal process , the more skill you have directing the conversation the better ChatGPT will be able to help you.

I'll let ChatGPT have the last word ..."my single most important tip is to be clear and specific in your questions. The more specific and detailed your question is, the better my response can be".

Walter.

What are your top tips for guiding ChatGPT?

#chatgpt #aichatbots #promptengineering

Connect with me .

Join 1000 others, subscribe to my weekly LinkedIn Newsletter "Your Ultimate B2B Exit Path".