The Chaos of Choice: How ‘noise’ shapes consumer behavior

For years, traditional marketing has portrayed consumers as rational beings, making decisions based on logic and clear information. However, neuroscience has proven that this view is incomplete and misleading.

Consumer purchasing behavior does not follow a purely rational process: the consumer is an emotional being, driven by intuition, perceptions, and unconscious processes that standard marketing analysis often overlooks. The human brain is influenced by factors such as attention, implicit memory, and emotions, making consumer behavior complex but not random.

One key aspect of this complexity is "noise" in decision-making processes, meaning the variability in behaviors and choices. Recent research shows that this is not an error to eliminate but rather a tool to understand the consumer’s mind better.

What Is "Noise" in Decision-Making?

In psychology, noise refers to variability in people's responses, even in identical situations. This phenomenon appears in various ways in consumer behavior:

• Context-driven choices → A consumer may perceive the same product differently depending on where they see it and their mental state.
• Shifting preferences → Even without concrete changes, a customer may be drawn to a brand one day and ignore it the next.
• Hesitation between similar alternatives → Two products with almost identical features can create indecision and contradictory behaviors.

For a long time, marketing aimed to reduce this variability to create "cleaner" behavioral models. But neuroscience teaches us that noise is not a problem—it is a signal of how the human brain works.

Recent Research: What Does Noise Teach Us About Consumer Decisions?

Three recent studies explored the role of noise in cognitive processes, providing key insights into consumer behavior and marketing.

1. Noise in Product Categorization

? (Seitz et al., 2025 - University of Basel)

When a consumer sees a product, their brain does not identify it objectively but categorizes it based on subjective perceptions. This seemingly simple process is unstable and influenced by several factors.

How Does Noise in Categorization Arise?

Seitz et al. found that categorization is subject to three types of noise:

1. Perceptual noise → Perception changes depending on lighting, color, and the context in which the product is presented.
2. Attention noise → If a consumer focuses on different product details (e.g., packaging versus logo), their interpretation changes.
3. Similarity noise → Two products may seem more or less alike depending on how they are displayed and compared.

Implications for Marketing and Retail

• Packaging can alter how a product is perceived → A minimalist design makes it look "premium," while bright colors make it seem more accessible.
• Shelf placement influences mental categorization → A product placed near organic items can be perceived as healthier, even without explicit claims.
• Keyword selection in communication guides categorization → Labeling a product as "artisanal" or "industrial" changes its perceived value.

2. Noise in Decision-Making: Bug or Feature?

? (Sanborn et al., 2025 - University of Warwick)

If Seitz showed that noise affects categorization, what happens at the moment of decision-making? Sanborn et al. (2025)found that noise is not a flaw but rather an evolutionary strategy of the brain to manage uncertainty.

How Does the Brain Use Noise to Make Decisions?

Sanborn's team demonstrated that the human mind does not follow a rigid model but operates with a probabilistic sampling system:

• It does not always make the same decision → It explores multiple alternatives to evaluate the context.
• It adapts responses to the environment → If an option appears more advantageous at a given moment, the brain favors it.

Implications for Marketing and E-Commerce

• Remarketing strategies work because consumers change their minds over time.
• Repeated exposure to products strengthens preferences and helps stabilize choices.
• Promotions should be timed strategically → A small incentive can push an undecided consumer to purchase.

3. Noise and Intuition vs. Analysis

? (Sundh et al., 2025 - University of Uppsala)

The Sundh et al. (2025) team developed the Precise/Not Precise (PNP) model to distinguish intuitive decisions from analytical ones.

What Does Noise Tell Us About the Type of Decision?

• High variability choices (high noise) → Intuitive decisions, fast, based on emotions and first impressions.
• Stable and consistent choices (low noise) → More analytical, deliberate decisions based on logical comparison.

Implications for UX, E-Commerce, and Sales Strategies

• Simplifying checkout reduces noise and facilitates impulse purchases.
• Call-to-actions should be direct → “Buy Now” works better than “Learn More.”
• Reviews reduce uncertainty and help consumers decide more quickly.

How to Leverage Noise in Marketing and Retail?

If consumers are emotional beings rather than rational ones, then marketing should adapt to their minds instead of trying to force decisions. This is where consumer neuroscience plays a crucial role: understanding unconscious behavior through research can help optimize marketing strategies, retail experiences, and e-commerce performance.

• Use Neuroscience and Cognitive Psychology → Marketing strategies should be based on how the brain actually processes information, not on rational models that do not reflect human behavior.
• Conduct Consumer Neuroscience Research → Studying how unconscious factors influence purchasing decisions can help fine-tune messaging, pricing, and product positioning.
• Create Fluid and Intuitive Experiences → An e-commerce site with too many steps increases uncertainty and discourages purchases.
• Personalize Messaging → Since noise is an inherent part of decision-making, remarketing is essential to re-engage customers who initially hesitated.
• Leverage the Right Timing → Offering an incentive at the moment of maximum indecision can trigger a purchase.

Conclusion

Consumers are not rational, but they are predictable in their impulses, emotions, and unconscious processes. Understanding noise means better understanding their behavior and transforming uncertainty into opportunities.

Want to apply neuroscience to your marketing? Let’s talk! ??