The case for enhanced PhD programs

The case for enhanced PhD programs

Read on my blog

Industry-involved PhD programs are all the range now. The NISA (National Innovation and Science Agenda) has really put a spotlight on universities working more closely with industry; and what better place to start than a PhD. Added to this, PhD graduate data paints a start picture of employment – with less than 5% of graduates turning their training into a long term research career. That is, only 1.5% of PhD graduates spend ten or more years in research and go on to be professors. This is a daunting statistic if you’re undertaking a PhD. And it is a scary statistic if you manage or offer PhD programs. Its even more scary if you see a PhD as training to be a researcher – rather than training to be a thinker (but that’s the topic of another blog).


Figure 1: PhD Careers (UK Data)

No alt text provided for this image

Figure 2: PhD Careers (US Data)

No alt text provided for this image

Figure 3: PhD Careers (Aus Data)

No alt text provided for this image

These statistics are compounded further when the employment data are viewed. On average[1]:

·???????45,000 students are enrolled in a PhD in Australia at any one time. If a PhD is 5 years long, then that’s 9,000 per year. If its 4 years long, then more like 11,000 and 6 years, perhaps as few as 7,000.

·???????Completion data suggests 6,500 finish each year. So, if we’re taking more than 6 years for a PhD at the same number start as finish. If we take 5 years the completion rate is 70% - about the rate being reported by individual universities.

·???????University jobs are growing at about 1,400 per year.

If you have not already made the leap that’s 6,500 graduates for 1,400 positions! And those 1,400 positions cover the entire university – not just research or PhD requiring positions.

If these data weren’t bad enough, there are two other statistics (admittedly both from the UK) that are worth bearing in mind:

1.?????Two thirds of students in their final year of their PhD have no fixed idea of their career. That is, they don’t know what they want to do when they finish their PhD.

2.?????30% (almost one third) of PhD graduates said THEY WOULD NOT DO THEIR PHD AGAIN IF GIVEN THEIR TIME OVER!

On top of all that having a PhD is not necessary for a research job. Employment data suggests less than 30% of the researcher workforce have PhDs. The rest have Masters by Research (15%), Degrees (45%) or other (10%)[2]. Thus, doing PhD – and therefore staying out of the workforce – may put you behind your peers who have otherwise been working for the last 4-7 years (depending on how long you have been doing your PhD for). That’s time gaining experience. That’s time working in industry. That’s time building and growing a network. That’s time being mentored as a staff member – not as a research student.

No alt text provided for this image

Figure 4: Minimum Qualification by Researcher Type

So – what does all of this mean for you? What does it mean for the person designing or implementing a PhD program?

Its worth noting the situation is not all bad. Although clear employment data don’t exist for Australian PhD graduates, we do know that most newly employed researchers have the skills to be productive[3].

No alt text provided for this image


Figure 5: Extent to which employer (respondents) agree that newly employed researchers have necessary skills to be productive

Therefore there is not a lot that needs to change. Or that should change.


[1] Data via UCube – University-reported data held by the Department of Education (https://highereducationstatistics.education.gov.au/)

[2] Employer Demand for Researchers in Australia, 2010

[3] Employer Demand for Researchers in Australia, 2010


要查看或添加评论,请登录

Richard Huysmans, PhD, AICGG的更多文章

  • Project Management for Research

    Project Management for Research

    Project management in research is often talked about in the context of being a transferable skill. A skill you pick up…

  • Ten Questions for Your (STEM) Career

    Ten Questions for Your (STEM) Career

    Here are some questions I got asked at a recent careers event. It was aimed at those in third year science.

  • 6 tips to building a PhD program

    6 tips to building a PhD program

    Cooperative Research Centres, Centres of Excellence, Centres of Research Excellence, Institutes, etc. are all large…

  • Getting the most out of your PhD training

    Getting the most out of your PhD training

    The predominant method for delivering training within a PhD is through apprenticeship-style approaches. Essentially…

  • Should I Do a PhD Thesis by Publication?

    Should I Do a PhD Thesis by Publication?

    I did a traditional thesis. But I have since coached/helped many PhD students do both thesis by publication and…

  • Metrics for Measuring Research Outputs

    Metrics for Measuring Research Outputs

    Download as PDF The last few blogs have focused on measuring your success, and then reporting your success. Here, I’m…

  • Planning your (ideal) PhD

    Planning your (ideal) PhD

    Increasingly, PhDs are planned, and project managed. Certainly in Australia anyway.

  • What’s the Easiest PhD?

    What’s the Easiest PhD?

    This question really doesn't have a straight answer. PhDs are not easy.

  • Building a Reading Habit

    Building a Reading Habit

    This is (essentially) James Clear's take on building habits. And I'll try to put context into it in terms of reading -…

    2 条评论
  • How to fall in love with your PhD

    How to fall in love with your PhD

    There's a difference between, "it is hard", and "it is killing me". So much of what people tell you when you sign up to…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了