Calculated Risks: Hiring Candidates with High Potential

Throughout our many years of experience, both individually and through Key4Nova, we have witnessed several instances of what could be considered “risky hires.” But what does this really mean?

Safe vs. Risky Hires: Weighing Stability Against Potential.

A "safe" hire, although such a thing rarely truly exists, given that we are dealing with human dynamics, refers to a situation where the candidate’s hard skills and soft skills align with the expectations of the company.

Soft skills, in particular, play a crucial role in ensuring harmony between the candidate and the work environment. However, a risky hire often occurs when the candidate’s technical skills do not entirely meet the job’s requirements.?

That said, it’s increasingly recognized that, in many cases, hiring for aptitude and training for technical skills can be a winning strategy. While certain roles undoubtedly require specific knowledge that must be acquired in advance, many gaps can be filled through proper guidance and training, which in turn fosters long-term employee loyalty.

?

Turning Overqualification into Opportunity.

Another form of risky hire is the overqualified candidate. Employers may fear that someone with too much experience might grow bored and leave the company too soon.

Yet, this challenge can be mitigated by digging into the candidate's true motivations. Often, an overqualified individual seeks to join a company that aligns with their values and accepts a position they know they can excel at, all while contributing more broadly to the organization’s growth. A wise employer can utilize this candidate’s expertise to improve internal processes, and potentially envision their future promotion. This type of hire can make a meaningful impact on overall company performance and create future leaders.

?

Challenging the Norm.

Additionally, a risky hire can also refer to bringing in someone with an unconventional background or experience outside the targeted industry. While such a decision may seem bold, it often introduces innovation and a fresh perspective to the company. Non-traditional profiles bring a different outlook, challenging standard practices and stimulating team creativity. With appropriate support, these apparent risks can turn into real opportunities for the business.

Lastly, we must not underestimate a candidate's ability to adapt and grow quickly. In a constantly changing job market, technical skills are no longer static, and agility is becoming an essential trait. Hiring candidates who can learn, adapt to new situations, and engage in continuous learning is a gamble that can truly pay off. A motivated individual who is eager to learn can soon become an very great asset to the company.

Advice for Managing Risky Hires:

1. Focus on Potential, Not Just Experience: When considering a candidate with limited technical skills or an unconventional background, evaluate their potential for growth. Look for indicators such as adaptability, curiosity, and a strong work ethic. These traits often signal that the candidate can quickly bridge skill gaps and contribute to the company's success.
2. Invest in Training and Development: A strong onboarding program and ongoing training can transform a risky hire into a long-term asset. Employers who invest in upskilling their employees often gets the benefits of improved retention and loyalty, while creating a more agile workforce.
3. Assess Motivation and Cultural Fit: With overqualified candidates or those coming from different industries, dig deep into their personal motivations. Do they align with the company's mission and values? If so, these candidates can bring not only expertise but also a long-term commitment to the organization.
4. Encourage Diverse Perspectives: Candidates with unconventional backgrounds often bring new ideas and approaches. Support these hires by creating an environment where different perspectives are valued and encouraged. This will not only boost innovation but also help build a more resilient and creative team.
5. Monitor and Provide Feedback Regularly: Risky hires may require additional support in their early days. Provide continuous feedback and mentorship to help them adjust. Regular check-ins allow both the employer and employee to track progress and make adjustments as needed.
6. Take a Balanced Approach to Risk: While hiring for potential and adaptability is crucial, it’s important to balance these attributes with the role's essential requirements. Ensure that you identify the core skills or competencies that cannot be compromised, and hire candidates who at least meet these criteria.

By approaching hiring decisions with a combination of openness and strategic planning, businesses can turn what appears to be a "risky" hire into an opportunity for growth, innovation, and long-term success.

For tailored and strategic HR solutions, connect with us at [email protected]. We're here to support your organization's growth.