Buy-Sell Agreements: Facilitating Ownership Transfers and Protecting Businesses

For many business owners, planning for the future involves more than just financial growth and daily operations; it includes ensuring the continuity and stability of their enterprise in the event of unforeseen changes. One essential tool for this purpose is the Buy-Sell Agreement (BSA), a legally binding contract that outlines how a business will handle the transfer of ownership when an owner departs due to death, disability, retirement, or other circumstances.

As a veteran in business succession and estate planning, I’ve seen firsthand how these agreements can either safeguard a business or, if absent, lead to chaos and confusion. Let’s explore how a Buy-Sell Agreement works and why every closely-held business should have one.

What is a Buy-Sell Agreement?

A Buy-Sell Agreement is a contract between business co-owners that dictates how shares in the company can be sold or transferred under specific conditions. This agreement can prevent a host of issues when ownership transitions due to unforeseen events, such as the sudden death of a business partner, a debilitating illness, or even an owner deciding to retire or leave the business.

The key feature of a BSA is that it sets predetermined terms for the sale or transfer of ownership stakes, including who can buy the departing owner’s shares and how the price will be determined.

Types of Buy-Sell Agreements

There are generally three types of Buy-Sell Agreements:

1. Cross-Purchase Agreements: In this arrangement, the remaining owners purchase the departing owner’s shares directly. This works well for businesses with fewer owners, where each owner can afford to buy the shares.

2. Entity-Purchase (or Stock Redemption) Agreements: In this structure, the business entity itself buys the departing owner’s shares. This is more common for larger businesses where the company has enough liquidity to handle such a purchase.

3. One Way Buy Sell Agreements: Sometimes, there are occasions where a normal Buy Sell may not be feasible or desired. In those sitautions, it may be more appropriate to do a One -way Buy Sell Agreement. Usually this could be a case where the majority wants to retain the business and would prefer to leave the business to his family instead of selling.

How Buy-Sell Agreements Protect Businesses

Consider this: without a BSA, what happens if one owner passes away? Typically, the deceased owner’s shares may pass on to a spouse or children, individuals who may not have the interest or expertise to run the business. Worse, this new family shareholder may want to sell their stake to an outsider or become a disruptive force in daily operations.

This is where a Buy-Sell Agreement steps in. By clearly outlining who can purchase the shares and at what price, the remaining owners are protected from sudden and undesirable changes in ownership. For example, if an owner passes away, the BSA can mandate that their shares be sold to the remaining owners or the company itself, preserving the continuity of ownership.

Real-World Example: Avoiding Chaos

Let’s look at an example. Imagine a family-owned business where two siblings, John and Sarah, co-own a manufacturing company. John passes away unexpectedly. Without a Buy-Sell Agreement, his shares transfer to his spouse, who has no interest or knowledge in running the business. Disputes arise over how to manage the company, and eventually, the business suffers due to internal conflict.

Now, had a Buy-Sell Agreement been in place, it could have stipulated that Sarah, as the surviving partner, would have the first option to purchase John’s shares. The agreement would have also predetermined a fair price based on the company’s valuation. This arrangement would have allowed Sarah to maintain control, while John’s spouse received fair compensation without interfering in the company’s operations.

Funding the Buy Sell

While i've discussed the importance of having a Buy Sell Agreement and how having one can avoid confusion and unhappiness in Business Succession, it's equally important to consider the funding mechanism. Because without a well thought out strategy to fund the Buy Sell, the Agreement may not be executed when the trigger event happens. This would negate the original intention to have a smooth business succession and lead to unhappiness among the surviving business owners and the family of the deceased owner.

The Funding mechanism can be in the form of a sinking fund, borrowings or personal savings or a financial solution. Each will have its pros and cons.

Sinking Fund:-

It may be useful to periodically set aside some earnings as a sinking fund. This sinking fund can be used a funding mechanism to fund the BSA but at the same time, can be used to take advantage of any business opportunities that come along.

Borrowings or personal savings:-

The surviving business owners can consider using credit facility to fund the BSA. The funds can be in the form of corporate loan or personal loan from banks or from personal savings. However, whether it's feasible at that moment to borrow or do they have the savings to fund the BSA is uncertain.

Financial Solution:-

Another way that can potential fund the BSA is through the use of a financial solution. This financial solution can be activated when the trigger event happen or it can be used a capital investment to fund retirement of business owners themselves.

Conclusion: A Critical Safeguard

In the absence of a Buy-Sell Agreement and Funding Mechanism, business owners risk seeing their company destabilised by disputes, unclear succession plans, or sudden ownership changes. These agreements act as a safety net, ensuring a smooth ownership transition, preserving business continuity, and preventing potential legal battles or internal strife.

For business owners seeking long-term success, integrating a Buy-Sell Agreement and Funding Mechanism into their business strategy isn’t just smart—it’s essential. It protects not only the business but also the legacy that owners work so hard to build.

By Thomas Tan.

With over 25 years of experience in the financial advisory landscape, specializing in retirement and estate planning, I'm dedicated to helping you secure your financial future. Whether you're an executive, business owner, or a mass affluent individual, my team and I are here to provide tailored strategies that create sustainable passive retirement income and fortify your estate.

Rest assured, your financial well-being is at the heart of everything we do. If you have questions, concerns, or simply want to explore further, please don't hesitate to reach out. Remember, your financial journey is unique, and together, we'll navigate it with expertise and care.

Thank you for being a part of our community. Until next time, here's to prosperous planning and a future filled with financial peace of mind.

Warm Regards

?

P/S: Disclaimer - All info shared are for general consumption and based on best effort basis and opinions are mine only. This article does not constitute any legal or financial advice.

Everybody situation is different.