Breaking the Cycle: The Financial Exploitation of Immigrants through Auto Loans

By Jessica Aliaga Froelke, Consumer Activist

For years, we’ve knocked on the doors of attorneys general and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), demanding action against the systemic exploitation embedded in the auto loan industry. While progress has been made, it is far from enough. The sophistication of these contracts and the incentive programs designed to perpetuate a vicious cycle of poverty and financial abuse continue to harm the most vulnerable among us—particularly immigrants disproportionately.

The Cycle of Exploitation

For many immigrants, especially those who are undocumented, a car is not a luxury—it’s a lifeline. It’s how they get to work, access healthcare, and provide for their families. Yet, this necessity has become the target of predatory practices. Lenders and dealers design financial products that promise accessibility but deliver crushing debt fueled by opaque terms and exorbitant interest rates.

These financial products are often accompanied by:

• Complex and opaque contracts are designed to confuse borrowers.
• Hidden fees and add-ons like GAP insurance and service warranties that are neither requested nor fully explained.
• Incentive programs that reward dealers for inflating costs and adding unnecessary products, often at the expense of consumers.

The result? It is a cycle where borrowers, unable to keep up with inflated payments, lose their vehicles and are forced to start the process again, sinking deeper into debt.

Sophisticated Systems of Abuse

What makes this issue even more egregious is the sophistication of the mechanisms that perpetuate it. These are not accidents or isolated incidents but systemic practices backed by carefully crafted incentive structures. Lenders reward dealers for volume, not fairness, and use outdated and deceptive interest calculation methods—like the Rule of 78s—that inflate costs and exploit borrowers.

This level of sophistication makes it incredibly difficult for consumers to advocate for themselves. The contracts are intentionally complex, and the fear of legal repercussions or deportation silences many immigrants, leaving them at the mercy of these predatory systems.

Progress and the Road Ahead

There has been progress thanks to the tireless work of advocates, whistleblowers, and some regulatory bodies. Cases have been brought against companies like Credit Acceptance and Westlake, and awareness of these issues is growing. However, the systemic nature of this exploitation means we are fighting an uphill battle.

The laws and enforcement mechanisms currently in place are insufficient to address the sophistication of these practices. We need stronger regulations, better oversight, and more accessible resources for vulnerable communities to understand and protect their rights.

What Must Change

1. Transparency in Contracts: Lenders and dealers must provide clear, concise, and multilingual explanations of loan terms.
2. Stronger Regulation of Incentive Structures: Programs that reward volume or encourage adding unnecessary products should be banned or strictly monitored.
3. Caps on Interest Rates: Predatory rates that disproportionately harm immigrants and low-income borrowers must be eliminated.
4. Community Advocacy: Organizations must continue to educate immigrants about their financial rights and provide support in cases of abuse.
5. Allow advocates to share their knowledge with the AG and the FTC.

This is not just about cars or loans; it’s about dignity and fairness. It’s about breaking a system designed to profit from the desperation of those seeking better opportunities. As we continue to advocate for justice, we must demand accountability from lenders and dealers who perpetuate these cycles of abuse.

A car should empower individuals, not chain them to debt. It’s time for meaningful action to ensure that financial systems serve as tools for progress—not as traps of exploitation.

O