Breaking Cultural Barriers: Navigating Cross-Cultural Communication with the Three A’s
Eugene Toh
Empowering Lives Through Storytelling | Corporate Leader in Governance | Chairperson at Methodist Welfare Services | Assistant Chief Executive at Energy Market Authority
In today’s cosmopolitan workforce, where we often collaborate with people from diverse cultural backgrounds, how often do we misinterpret the words or actions of others due to cultural differences? Have you ever wondered whether a simple request may carry unintended meanings because of language barriers or different communication styles? As leaders in this globalized environment, how can we navigate these challenges while fostering mutual respect and understanding in our teams?
Once, I had a particularly awkward experience during a meeting with the director of a think tank from a Northeast Asian country. The meeting was progressing smoothly until the director asked if I could "send him in advance policies on sustainability." I was taken aback, wondering if he was requesting privileged access to policy information before official announcements. My response was cautious, unsure of his intentions. He thanked me and then invited me to a party at his office, mentioning good wine would be served. At that moment, my instincts flared—I worried that this might be a subtle attempt at bribery, pairing an ask with an invitation. This incident was a clear example of how misunderstandings can arise in cross-cultural communication.
After the meeting, I spoke with a colleague who attended the meeting with me and spoke the director’s language. He explained that the director had likely translated his request literally from his native language, meaning he wanted “policies that are advanced or forward-looking,” not policies sent ahead of time. The misunderstanding arose from this literal translation and the nuances of English as his second language. Suddenly, everything made sense. I realized he was simply asking for public information, and the tension I felt dissipated.
This experience reminded me of a story shared by Pellegrino Riccardi in his TED Talk Cross-cultural Communication. Riccardi, who has lived in the UK and Norway but is of Italian origin, spoke about how different cultures interpret rules. In Norway, he was fined for having his car’s wheel slightly outside of a parking space, showcasing the strict adherence to rules there. On the other hand, while in Italy, a parking warden once told him that parking in a “no-parking” zone and paying a 30 Euro fine was a cheaper option than paying 40 Euros for legal parking! This contrast highlighted the flexibility in Italian culture regarding rules. Riccardi's advice resonated with me: stay curious, and try to create a unique, blended culture by embracing the best from different worlds.
Reflecting on these experiences, I realized the importance of a practical approach to navigating cross-cultural interactions. I have come up with the Three A’s Framework—Awareness, Ask, and Affirm—to help leaders communicate more effectively across cultures.
1. Awareness: Being aware of cultural differences is half the battle won. Personally, I’ve watched a lot of American shows, where phrases like "hit a home run" are used to signify success. However, many people outside the U.S. may not be familiar with baseball, and such phrases could confuse them. Understanding that cultural references don’t always translate well is key to avoiding miscommunication.
2. Ask: If in doubt, ask. I’ve worked in cross-cultural contexts, particularly with some Asian societies, where saying "yes" may simply mean acknowledgment rather than agreement. To ensure clarity, I’ve learned to ask, “Do you mean yes to the task or yes you understand it?” Asking clarifying questions is essential in navigating these differences.
3. Affirm: Always affirm and confirm the details. I once worked with a multicultural team where meeting at 2 p.m. was interpreted differently—some saw it as flexible by 10 minutes, while others expected strict punctuality. To avoid confusion, I began confirming: "Can I confirm that the deadline means exactly 2 p.m.?" This ensures everyone is aligned and avoids misunderstandings due to differing expectations.
As leaders, navigating cross-cultural communication isn’t just about avoiding misunderstandings—it’s about fostering an inclusive environment where diverse perspectives are embraced. Working across cultures is like learning to use different utensils: some use a fork and spoon, others use chopsticks, and some eat with their hands. Once you’re aware of these differences and adapt to them, it becomes second nature, allowing you to work more effectively. Similarly, by practicing Awareness, Ask, and Affirm, leaders can bridge cultural gaps and create strong, cohesive teams that thrive.
Power and Energy | Physical Asset Management | Sustainability
3 周I think it isn’t just between cultural-socio norms but increasingly, because of increasing career specialization, there exists sub-cultures and micro-climates, all within the same organization, often within the same building itself.? Leadership has to take on the role of being the bridge and the toll-keeper between how these individuals and departments interact with each other.????