Break Free from “Either/Or” Thinking: How High-Performing Companies Achieve More

Imagine this: A sales team at a fast-growing tech company faces an all-too-common dilemma. They’re under pressure to expand the customer base, yet leadership insists on protecting profit margins. To the team, it feels like they’re boxed in—they believe they can either lower prices to drive new accounts or hold firm on pricing and miss out on growth. For months, they push as hard as they can within these limits, but no matter what they try, the numbers fall short.

Then, a new sales leader joins the team with a different perspective. Instead of accepting the choice between growth and profitability, he challenges the team to think bigger: “How can we grow our customer base and protect our margins?” At first, there’s hesitation, but soon the team starts identifying untapped customer segments, refining their value proposition, and shifting their focus to high-value accounts that don’t require heavy discounts. The result? Revenue increases, profit margins stay intact, and the team realizes that the limits they’d believed in were self-imposed.

This story is a reminder of how easy it is to fall into “either/or” thinking. Too many companies set themselves up for mediocrity by assuming they have to choose between quality or cost, growth or profitability, speed or efficiency. High-performing companies reject these limitations. They look for ways to achieve more, pushing for both quality and efficiency, growth and profitability.

Here’s how you can break free from “either/or” thinking and unlock your team’s full potential.

Recognizing the Trap of “Either/Or” Thinking

The first step in breaking free from “either/or” thinking is recognizing how common this mindset is and how it limits potential. Companies that fall into this trap often convince themselves there are no other options. Here are a few common false trade-offs:

• “We can deliver high quality or low cost, but not both.”
• “We can meet tight deadlines or stay on budget, but one has to give.”
• “We can grow our market share, but only by lowering prices.”
• “We can either innovate or reduce costs, but not both.”

Once a company buys into these trade-offs, they become self-fulfilling. The moment leaders believe they can’t achieve both, they stop looking for ways to make it happen. Teams settle for “good enough,” and the bar for success is lowered.

Why “And” Thinking Matters

High-performing companies refuse to accept the limits of “either/or” thinking. They push for “and” solutions that enable multiple outcomes without forcing compromise. This isn’t about pushing teams to exhaustion; it’s about fostering a disciplined, innovative mindset that drives growth and prevents complacency.

• Encourages Innovation: When teams are challenged to achieve multiple goals simultaneously, they’re forced to think creatively and move beyond the status quo, exploring new ways to drive sustainable growth.
• Raises Standards: “Either/or” thinking often lowers expectations, settling for one outcome at the expense of another. By aiming for “and,” you raise the bar across the board and reinforce a culture of high standards.
• Builds Resilience: Companies that achieve multiple objectives without compromise are more adaptable. They’re ready to thrive in fluctuating markets, economic shifts, and changing customer needs.

Shifting from “Either/Or” to “And”

Making the shift from “either/or” to “and” thinking requires a change in approach at all levels of the organization. Here’s how you can start transforming your team’s mindset:

1. Question Every Trade-Off

When someone says, “We can do this or that, but not both,” challenge it. Ask, “Why not? What’s really stopping us?”

• Weak Response: “We can’t hit quality standards and reduce costs.”
• High-Caliber Response: “We’re exploring how to streamline our production process to reduce rework, which would lower costs while improving quality.”

Most trade-offs exist because of unchallenged assumptions or outdated processes. By questioning these limits, you open up new possibilities. Reframing the problem as “How can we achieve both?” encourages creative thinking and exposes options that might have been overlooked.

2. Focus on Process and Efficiency Improvements

“Either/or” thinking often stems from a belief that current capabilities define what’s possible. In reality, “and” solutions frequently emerge from process improvements that allow teams to achieve both objectives.

• Weak Response: “We’ll have to compromise on speed to keep costs low.”
• High-Caliber Response: “We’re analyzing workflow bottlenecks to reduce cycle time and drive down costs without compromising speed.”

Take Toyota, for instance. They broke the false choice between cost and quality by creating the Toyota Production System, allowing them to deliver high quality at low cost. They didn’t settle for one or the other; they reengineered processes to achieve both.

3. Set Stretch Goals That Challenge the Status Quo

Stretch goals push teams to move beyond comfort zones and “either/or” thinking. Instead of meeting a budget, set the target at meeting the budget and delivering ahead of schedule. Instead of choosing between quality and cost, set a goal to achieve both.

• Weak Response: “Let’s just focus on hitting our sales target.”
• High-Caliber Response: “Our target is to hit the sales goal while maintaining our current margin. Let’s brainstorm ways to achieve both.”

Stretch goals reframe challenges, encouraging teams to rethink workflows, optimize resource allocation, and tackle bottlenecks. When well-crafted, they inspire innovation and unlock your team’s true potential.

4. Encourage Cross-Functional Collaboration

Some of the best “and” solutions come from collaboration across departments. Cross-functional teams bring diverse perspectives and skill sets, enabling solutions that aren’t possible in silos.

• Weak Response: “This is a marketing issue; let them handle it.”
• High-Caliber Response: “Let’s bring in marketing and product development to see how we can improve customer satisfaction and reduce costs together.”

For example, a product team might see cost as a constraint, while the sales team sees quality as the key to customer loyalty. Together, they can find a way to deliver both. Cross-functional collaboration fosters a company-wide mindset of “and” thinking.

5. Cultivate a Culture of Curiosity and Continuous Learning

Organizations that embrace “and” thinking create cultures where curiosity and learning are embedded in daily work. Encourage your team to question assumptions, explore ideas from other industries, and pursue unconventional approaches.

• Weak Response: “That’s just the way we’ve always done it.”
• High-Caliber Response: “Is there a different industry approach we can learn from to achieve both objectives?”

When people are afraid to fail, they stick to “safe” approaches that reinforce “either/or” thinking. Reward innovative solutions that push past limits. Recognize and celebrate examples where teams achieved multiple objectives. A culture of curiosity and risk-taking is essential to breaking out of limiting beliefs.

Real-World Example: Apple and Design Excellence

Consider Apple’s approach to product design. For years, the tech industry assumed there was a trade-off between powerful hardware and intuitive design. Apple rejected this notion, pushing its teams to create products that were both beautifully designed and highly functional. This “and” thinking led to iconic products like the iPhone, which transformed the industry and raised the bar for customer expectations.

Apple didn’t settle for lower standards. They pushed for solutions that delivered on multiple fronts, showing that high performance and elegant design could enhance each other.

Breaking Free from Mediocrity

“Either/or” thinking is a shortcut to mediocrity. It limits your company’s potential and leaves growth, efficiency, and innovation on the table. Companies that break free from this mindset achieve more, delivering on multiple objectives others believe are mutually exclusive.

If you want your organization to lead, start by questioning every false trade-off. Ask, “How can we achieve both?” Then give your team the tools, support, and encouragement to explore solutions. Companies that do this consistently don’t just outperform—they set new standards in their industries.

A Challenge for CEOs: Lead with “And” Thinking

Starting today, challenge your team to bring you solutions that deliver on multiple fronts. Encourage them to reframe “either/or” decisions as “how can we achieve both?” Push them to bring you ideas that challenge the limitations they once thought were fixed.

This shift from “or” to “and” isn’t just a mindset change—it’s a leadership standard. Stop settling for “good enough.” Start leading with “and,” and watch your organization realize its full potential.

"The only way to discover the limits of the possible is to go beyond them into the impossible." — Arthur C. Clarke

?? Found this helpful? Give it a like!

?? Got insights or thoughts? Drop a comment—I’d love to hear them.

?? Know someone who’d benefit from this? Share it with your network.

? Want more content like this? Follow for future discussions and tips!

Sign up for our monthly "Lean Catalyst Interview Series". In this dynamic, one-hour interview series, we will bring together like-minded CEOs who have successfully embraced lean thinking to drive exceptional results. Through captivating conversations, we delve into their remarkable achievements, uncovering the strategies, insights, and practical wisdom that have propelled their organizations forward. Each series features an in-depth interview with a distinguished CEO who has demonstrated extraordinary leadership in leveraging lean principles. It's a great opportunity for sharing experiences, strategies, and valuable knowledge that others can apply to their own leadership journeys.

At Lean Focus, we help businesses overcome their biggest challenges by transforming them for the better, and for the long-term. Learn more about what we do:

? 2024 All Rights Reserved. Do not reproduce this or portions of this document without written permission from Lean Focus LLC, Damon Baker.??(630) 800-8519