Brands Struggle with Social Because They Aren't Human

Brands Struggle with Social Because They Aren't Human

Human beings are complex and messy and completely flawed. We are also incredibly social and driven to connect. We differ so fundamentally from all other life forms on our planet, mainly because of our 'wiring'. We're so complex and fascinating that multiple science disciplines have been dedicated to trying to figure out the intricacy of being human: psychology, sociology, anthropology, behavioral economics, neuroscience, cognitive science, philosophy, epistemology, heterophenomenology...the list goes on!

So when I sat down to make a video to outline and demonstrate how different brand behavior is from human behavior - and, therefore, brands can never truly be social without letting go of the rules and brand guidelines and everything else that makes them non-human - I realized that it's almost impossible to make a comparison. Humans are to brands what horses are to skateboards. Brands are too one-dimensional with their brand guidelines and editorial voice. 

Instead of making the comparison, I created a list of ways in which humans are very uniquely NOT like brands:

 
So, what are the implications here? Am I saying that brands will never be social? That brands should act like humans and have bad days and act selfishly altruistic?

Honestly, I'm not sure what the answer is, but I refuse to believe that brands will never play a true role in social. In fact, long before there was Facebook or Twitter or even MySpace and Friendster, I was seeing people discuss brands online and representatives (employees) of brands be part of those discussions. They weren't trying to broadcast a message, though. They were just part of a conversation. You know: "markets are conversations," and all of that.

People, of course, talk about themselves as brands, and I am as guilty as the next person. That means we are framing ourselves as an image to shape, project, and hone. We are watching what we post and put filters on our photos so we look younger, hotter, and more capable. We hustle. We edit. But the difference between the "brand of Tara Hunt" and the real Tara Hunt is that, at the end of the day, I'm always a flawed, complex human beneath it all. No amount of photoshopping can erase that.

So should brands act more like people, warts and all? I'm not sure that is the answer, either, but injecting some humanity and all of the uncertain, flawed, inconsistent, and imperfect qualities of being human into how a brand interacts on social could be key. Brands that screw up and show the humility to apologize are traditionally well-received. Brands that ask for help or show their struggles are often celebrated and loved.

Of course, there are plenty of brands, like Apple, who project a rigid brand discipline who fare perfectly well, but when you think of Apple, it's not social...it's an icon. Like a celebrity we hold up on a pedestal, the Apples of this world have a gift for showing us an image many of us aspire toward. They don't need to be human. They represent an ideal. Most brands don't have that status.

So what do YOU think are the human qualities brands should adopt and why? Or are you in the camp of "brands will never be my friend, so f&^k off!"? If you watch the video, let me know which important, unique human traits I missed.

Marc Dhalluin

Would Your BRAND ask you to LEAD it NO MATTER What? THINK. Carefully.

9 å¹´

A bit to add; brands struggle in the social realm because they usually attempt to participate without a decent point of view - a crafted, amplified insight that's deep enough to hold it's ground. Brands must participate as brands - not as people. Social interactions are rooted in psychology as Tara illustrates. A brand can't arrive at the party and not be present. Kinda like watching the red carpet parade at the Oscars and then ticking the box that 'I was there and present'.

赞
回复
Shaun Coulton OLY

Director | Career Growth Advisor | People Capability, Attraction and Development Leader

9 å¹´

Great video and a really accurate piece.

赞
回复
Nick Throckmorton

6+ years as a growth product designer ??

9 å¹´

Very good insight as to why you can't connect with customers if you constantly self-promote your brand . Like, share and comment on things that don't directly deal with your product and you may find that engagement metrics sky rocket.

赞
回复
Tracy King

Leading with compassion and expertise in the Insurance industry. Advocating for financial security and equality in life planning through financial education and career growth.

9 å¹´

A truly great brand is built on the experience of their clients, not what they desire it to be. So yes, the client end of the brand is human. The business end - well?!?!

赞
回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Tara Hunt的更多文章

  • Why I "left" marketing and, at 50, am starting a whole new career

    Why I "left" marketing and, at 50, am starting a whole new career

    Even before 2020 threw the entire world for a loop, I could feel something in the air that wasn't quite right..

    74 条评论
  • I'm not okay and that's okay: A note on our collective trauma

    I'm not okay and that's okay: A note on our collective trauma

    How do I know that social platforms aren't safe spaces? Because I only want to post when I feel positive and…

    51 条评论
  • The Anatomy of Code-Switching

    The Anatomy of Code-Switching

    Stefani and I are holding a series of conversations with Black professionals in various parts of the marketing industry…

    8 条评论
  • It's Brand Messaging Month on Phlywheel!

    It's Brand Messaging Month on Phlywheel!

    One of the features we've planned on Phlywheel is to create focused learning sprints each month around a different…

  • Just because #blacklivesmatter is no longer trending doesn't mean it's time to move on

    Just because #blacklivesmatter is no longer trending doesn't mean it's time to move on

    This has been a touchy year for marketing (to say the least). I've spoken out against scheduling social posts for many…

    3 条评论
  • There's no such thing as a perfect plan

    There's no such thing as a perfect plan

    In 4 more sleeps (*gulp*) we launch Phlywheel - a DIY platform using community, content, and coaching to help SMBs get…

    9 条评论
  • Marketing success starts with setting the right goals

    Marketing success starts with setting the right goals

    Nine times out of ten, we get approached by companies who, when asked, "What are your goals?" answer one of two ways:…

    6 条评论
  • Can we all agree to stop performing now?

    Can we all agree to stop performing now?

    One of the outcomes of the Stay-at-Home/Shelter-in-Place/Lockdown/whatever-we-call-this-self-isolation-thing I'm quite…

    24 条评论
  • Community Marketing: going back to my roots

    Community Marketing: going back to my roots

    Just recently, we made the decision to build our soon-to-be-launched community for marketers (and aspiring marketers)…

    15 条评论
  • Shopping online more during your lockdown? Buy from these amazing women-led ventures!

    Shopping online more during your lockdown? Buy from these amazing women-led ventures!

    Right before the world sat up, took notice and we all sequestered ourselves at home, I attended the SheEO Global…

    7 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了